The best procurement software for a defense manufacturer depends on where controlled technical data has to live. For direct materials RFQs on ITAR programs, where buyers need control over which suppliers see which parts, LightSource ranks first in this guide. Ivalua is the stronger pick for replacing a whole source-to-pay suite on a government cloud, and Oracle Fusion Procurement suits eligible contractors already running Oracle. SAP Ariba with SAP NS2 fits SAP estates.
That split matters because a defense RFQ is a release of technical data. Every drawing attached to a quote request is an export decision, and the supplier on the other end may have a foreign parent, an overseas support team or a sub-tier processor in another country. This guide ranks nine platforms on what a defense direct materials team does every week: deciding which supplier may see which part, keeping controlled files where they belong, re-quoting when a revision changes, and getting small machine shops to respond without falling back to email. LightSource publishes this guide and ranks its own product; the weights, the disclosure and the places where LightSource falls short are all below.
The Short Answer
At least one large prime documents a split model. RTX's supplier training for its Exostar-hosted sourcing application states that no export-controlled data may be uploaded to the application at all; drawings travel separately through the RTX Secure Messenger Gateway. The sourcing tool collects bids, and a separate controlled channel carries the technical data. The question for a buyer is which software makes that separation easy to run and hard to bypass. Our verdict by buyer type, as of September 2026:
Buyer | Shortlist |
|---|---|
Defense-tech scaling production | LightSource, then Ivalua |
Subcontractor on ITAR programs | LightSource, then JAGGAER |
Prime replacing its S2P suite | Ivalua, then LightSource |
Contractor on Oracle | Oracle, then LightSource |
Contractor on SAP | SAP Ariba (NS2), then LightSource |
The honest exception is hosting. If your security team requires controlled unclassified information (CUI) to sit inside the sourcing application itself, in an environment with a FedRAMP authorization on record, start with Oracle Fusion Cloud (if you are eligible for Oracle Government Cloud) or Coupa Spend Management for Federal, both listed at the Moderate level, and ask Ivalua for the current status of its GovCloud offering. LightSource offers deployment on AWS GovCloud by request, but it does not claim FedRAMP authorization, so its usual pattern for CUI is to keep controlled files in the buyer's own environment and reference them from the part record.
How We Scored
We scored every platform, including our own, on seven criteria. The weights reflect where defense sourcing risk and time actually go: most of the risk sits in who receives which file, and most of the time sits in getting part data into an RFQ and comparable quotes back out.
Criterion | Weight | Test |
|---|---|---|
Part-level access | 20% | Control which suppliers see each part and property |
BOM and revisions | 20% | RFQ from a BOM, re-quote one revision |
Quotes and award | 15% | Same cost breakdown, award scenarios |
Hosting evidence | 15% | Documented GovCloud or FedRAMP path |
Supplier controls | 10% | Collect attestations before award |
Supplier response | 10% | Small shops respond, pay nothing |
ERP and records | 10% | Award lands in the purchasing system |
We rate each capability with the vocabulary our comparison library uses: Native (documented and in the standard product), Configured (available, but set up per customer, per deployment or through a separate product), Marketed (claimed without public evidence of how it works) and Not documented (we could not find it, which is not the same as not offered). For hosting evidence, Native means an authorized package listed on the FedRAMP Marketplace, and Configured means a documented government cloud deployment without that listing. No rating in this guide is a security certification. A FedRAMP listing applies to a named package, not to every module or add-on a vendor sells, so ask for the boundary in writing.
The 9 Platforms at a Glance
Platform | Best fit |
|---|---|
1. LightSource | ITAR direct materials RFQs |
2. Ivalua | S2P suite on GovCloud |
3. Oracle Fusion | Contractors on Oracle |
4. JAGGAER | Multi-plant direct sourcing |
5. SAP Ariba (NS2) | SAP estates |
6. Coupa (Federal) | Finance-led spend control |
7. GEP | Software plus services |
8. Keelvar | Optimized multi-lot awards |
9. Arkestro | Repeat-buy price discovery |

Our ratings of nine platforms on this guide's seven criteria, as of September 2026. LightSource rates Native on part-level access, BOM and revisions, quotes and award, and supplier response, and Configured on hosting, supplier controls and ERP records. Source: LightSource assessment of public documentation, the FedRAMP Marketplace and public customer notices.
The 9 Platforms, Ranked
1. LightSource
What it is. LightSource is the AI-native direct materials operating system, spec through scale, PLM through ERP. Items are master data with specs, custom properties, revisions, drawings and files; BOMs are hierarchical, with snapshots and cost history, and a buyer can launch a sourcing project directly from a BOM or a batch of items.
Best for: defense and defense-tech manufacturers running direct materials RFQs on ITAR-controlled programs, from growth-stage hardware companies scaling production to divisions of larger primes, who want control over which suppliers see which parts without replacing their ERP or PLM.
Why it ranks first for this use. LightSource supports ITAR-controlled sourcing programs and has defense customers, whom we do not name. Buyers can restrict projects, items and RFI events to access groups and choose which item properties suppliers see, and an RFQ goes only to the suppliers invited to it. Line-item supplier filtering sets which suppliers see which items, so a supplier quoting a bracket does not see the controlled drawing on the next line. That mix of per-item and per-property visibility is why we rate part-level access Native, with a limit worth knowing: the controls apply per record rather than per file, and Data Rooms do not set per-file permissions, so files that need file-level separation belong on the buyer's own server. For CUI, buyers choose one of two patterns: upload the BOM and parts directly for controlled sharing with selected suppliers, or put a link to their own secure FTP server in the part metadata so controlled files never leave their environment. The second pattern is the same separation RTX documents for its own suppliers, with the bid in one system and the drawing in another, except the link lives on the part record, so the reference travels with the part and its revisions. Deployment on AWS GovCloud is available by request.
Quotes come back structured. Every supplier fills the same quote format, from unit price only to a full breakdown of raw materials, purchased items, machine and assembly processes, packaging, logistics and markups, in the app or through an Excel round-trip. When engineering revises a part, the buyer resends the RFQ, every version is preserved and suppliers see the new RFQ version, the buyer's message and the RFQ history. Award scenarios can be built by hand or generated from submitted quotes, split by volume or percentage, and routed for approval. Suppliers use LightSource free, which matters in a supply base where small shops already maintain accounts for several prime portals, Supplier Discovery searches by company name, process or material, and LightSource's supplier network includes more than 100,000 suppliers. LightSource states that it holds a SOC 2 Type 2 attestation and does not train foundation models on customer RFQ, RFI or contract data. It supports SAML single sign-on, and a team admin can require multi-factor authentication for members who sign in with email and password.
Watch-outs. LightSource does not claim FedRAMP authorization, CMMC certification or DFARS 252.204-7012 attestations, and it does not claim ITAR registration of its own; your export compliance team still decides what may be released to whom. If you upload CUI directly rather than linking to your own server, your security team should evaluate the GovCloud deployment against the cloud requirements in your contracts. The secure-FTP pattern keeps files out of the application, but part names, descriptions and properties in the RFQ can themselves be controlled, so decide which fields are safe before launch. LightSource does not issue purchase orders or invoices (an award creates an item contract, not a PO), does not run PPAP or first article workflows, has no built-in should-cost engine and connects to ERP and PLM through Excel Item Sync and a GraphQL API rather than certified prebuilt connectors. Supplier flow-down attestations can be collected through RFIs with an NDA round-trip and Data Rooms, but there is no clause-pack engine. The company came out of stealth in 2025.
Demo test: send one RFQ with three lines to three suppliers where each supplier may see only one line, and log in as each supplier to confirm what they can and cannot open. Then test the linked-file pattern over time: have one shop quote revision B through a link to your test file server, publish revision C on the server and resend. A second buyer should be able to tell from the RFQ history which revision each shop priced, without relying on what the link opens today, so put the revision in the link or the part record rather than pointing at a folder that changes.
Ratings: Part-level access Native; BOM and revisions Native; quotes and award Native; hosting evidence Configured; supplier controls Configured; supplier response Native; ERP and records Configured.
Pricing model: platform fee plus seats, implementation included; suppliers pay nothing.
LightSource is listed in The Hackett Group's Sourcing (for direct) Solutions guide as an "AI-native sourcing platform purpose-built for direct materials procurement," and was named a Gartner Cool Vendor in Sourcing and Procurement Technology (2025). Deployment typically takes about 30 days, with bespoke integration work scoped separately.
2. Ivalua
What it is. Ivalua is an organically built source-to-pay suite on a single codebase. The Hackett Group's direct sourcing guide calls it a "natively integrated, intuitive and flexible suite" with capabilities for all spend, including direct materials.
Best for: defense primes and large subcontractors that want to replace a whole S2P suite (supplier onboarding, risk, sourcing, contracts, POs and invoices) in a government cloud environment, and will invest in configuration.
Why it ranks here. In our reading of public records, Ivalua has the strongest defense references of the suites in this guide. BAE Systems, Inc. selected Ivalua for source-to-pay in March 2025. In February 2026 General Atomics picked Ivalua as its single system of record for supplier collaboration, with the deployment running on Ivalua's GovCloud offering, and GA's own supplier notice says Ivalua's quality and compliance features tailored to aerospace and defense were key differentiators. Ivalua has said its GovCloud offering achieved FedRAMP Ready status at the moderate impact level. If you need one platform that holds supplier qualification, sourcing and the purchasing record together, Ivalua is the better pick than LightSource.
Watch-outs. FedRAMP Ready is a readiness designation, not an authorization, and a customer's own environment statement does not transfer to your tenant; ask Ivalua for the current status and boundary of the package you would buy. Value from Ivalua depends on configuration skill and a strong implementation partner, and a suite rollout takes time; GA's notice told suppliers to keep using its previous tool until implementation was complete. In our evaluations, BOM sync is set up per customer rather than extracted from drawings and spreadsheets.
Demo test: have the implementation partner show a mixed RFQ where one supplier's approval expires mid-event, and record which steps need a configuration change rather than a buyer action.
Ratings: Part-level access Configured; BOM and revisions Configured; quotes and award Configured; hosting evidence Configured; supplier controls Native; supplier response Native; ERP and records Native.
Pricing model: custom-quoted subscription sized by modules and users, with implementation sold separately; suppliers quote free through the portal.
3. Oracle Fusion Cloud Procurement
What it is. Oracle's procurement applications on the same data model as Oracle financials, projects and manufacturing.
Best for: contractors already running Oracle Fusion ERP who want procurement inside a FedRAMP-authorized SaaS environment.
Why it ranks here. Oracle has the clearest public authorization record in this guide. The FedRAMP Marketplace lists Oracle Fusion Cloud (package F1603257882) as FedRAMP Certified at the Moderate level since January 13, 2020, and its service description includes procurement and project management. Oracle Government Cloud is a community cloud limited to agencies, select universities and federal contractors with a demonstrated need for FedRAMP authorization, so eligibility is the first question. For an eligible Oracle shop that needs purchasing, project cost and supplier records in one authorized environment, Oracle is the better pick.
Watch-outs. The product is P2P-first, and its sourcing events are general all-spend events rather than drawing- and revision-centric RFQs. Oracle's design-to-source capability sits in Fusion Cloud PLM, a separate entitlement, so ask which licenses a quote includes. Implementations are partner-led and ERP-class, and outside an Oracle estate most of the integration advantage goes away.
Demo test: ask for a list of every screen shown, the product that owns it, the license it requires, and whether that product sits inside the FedRAMP package you would buy.
Ratings: Part-level access Configured; BOM and revisions Configured; quotes and award Configured; hosting evidence Native; supplier controls Configured; supplier response Configured; ERP and records Native.
Pricing model: published per-hosted-named-user list price with a user minimum; contracted price set per order.
4. JAGGAER
What it is. A source-to-pay suite with the deepest direct materials heritage of the suites, through JAGGAER Direct (formerly POOL4TOOL).
Best for: multi-plant manufacturers that want direct sourcing with multi-tier BOMs inside one suite.
Why it ranks here. The Hackett Group's direct sourcing guide credits JAGGAER with "sophisticated direct materials sourcing capabilities." For a subcontractor whose biggest problem is BOM-driven sourcing across plants, JAGGAER is the suite most likely to fit.
Watch-outs. We could not find documented U.S. government cloud hosting or a CUI boundary for JAGGAER's commercial sourcing product, so plan on a separate secure channel for controlled drawings, as RTX does with its own sourcing application. Hackett's guide notes the suite was built over time through multiple acquisitions, so test how item, supplier and contract data move between modules. A recurring complaint among reviewers is rigidity.
Demo test: have a plant buyer add a field to a cost breakdown, run an event with it, and attach a drawing reference that points to your own secure file share rather than an upload.
Ratings: Part-level access Configured; BOM and revisions Native; quotes and award Native; hosting evidence Not documented; supplier controls Configured; supplier response Configured; ERP and records Configured.
Pricing model: custom-quoted by module and users; some public contracts add an annual spend threshold.
5. SAP Ariba (with SAP NS2)
What it is. SAP's source-to-pay suite, offered for regulated customers through SAP National Security Services (SAP NS2).
Best for: defense manufacturers standardized on SAP S/4HANA that want to keep the SAP Business Network and change how regulated data is hosted.
Why it ranks here. In September 2023, Google Cloud announced that SAP NS2 had achieved ITAR compliance for SAP Ariba on Google Cloud with Assured Workloads. Native integration with SAP ERP means material masters and awarded pricing flow to S/4HANA without a separate integration project. Its RFx and auction engine is mature and widely deployed.
Watch-outs. An ITAR-compliant hosting announcement is not proof that every Ariba module, the supplier network and each extension sit inside the same boundary, so ask for the SKU-by-SKU scope. A recurring minority complaint among reviewers is a dated interface that needs extensive training for occasional users, and rollouts are partner-led. In our evaluations, sourcing events reference ERP material master rows rather than drawings, properties and revisions, and detailed cost breakdowns usually travel as an Excel attachment. Enterprise supplier accounts on SAP Business Network that cross published thresholds pay fees, a known friction for small machine shops.
Demo test: send a drawing-linked RFQ to a small supplier on a Standard account and confirm, from the supplier's side, which service hosts the file.
Ratings: Part-level access Configured; BOM and revisions Configured; quotes and award Configured; hosting evidence Configured; supplier controls Configured; supplier response Configured; ERP and records Native.
Pricing model: module subscriptions, price on request, plus integrator implementation; NS2 hosting is quoted separately.
See LightSource vs. SAP Ariba.
6. Coupa (Spend Management for Federal)
What it is. Coupa's P2P and spend management suite, with a federal edition.
Best for: finance-led organizations that want spend control, P2P and supplier onboarding in an authorized environment, with direct materials sourcing handled elsewhere.
Why it ranks here. The FedRAMP Marketplace lists Coupa Spend Management for Federal (package F1308202329) as FedRAMP Certified at the Moderate level since March 10, 2022. Coupa is the broadest P2P suite here, and its supplier portal is free for suppliers.
Watch-outs. The federal edition is built for agencies; confirm that a contractor can buy it and that the supplier portal and add-ons you need are inside the package. P2P and indirect spend are Coupa's center of gravity, and we could not find a documented BOM-led sourcing module. A manufacturer that already uses Coupa for orders and invoices can keep it and add a direct materials platform for engineered parts.
Demo test: ask which of the modules in your quote are inside package F1308202329 and which are commercial-only.
Ratings: Part-level access Configured; BOM and revisions Not documented; quotes and award Configured; hosting evidence Native; supplier controls Configured; supplier response Native; ERP and records Native.
Pricing model: custom quote by module and user count; integrator-led rollout.
7. GEP
What it is. An organically built suite (GEP SMART and QUANTUM) sold with consulting and managed services.
Best for: manufacturers that want should-cost modeling and sourcing services from the same provider.
Why it ranks here. The Hackett Group's direct sourcing guide credits GEP's suite with "cost and should-cost modeling" usable for direct and indirect spend. That is a built-in capability LightSource does not have; LightSource takes an uploaded should-cost and uses it as the bid baseline.
Watch-outs. We could not find a documented U.S. government cloud deployment or controlled-data boundary for GEP's sourcing product. Implementation and operation often come bundled with GEP services, and if services analysts will touch your drawings, their nationality and location become part of your export analysis.
Demo test: ask GEP to repeat its should-cost exercise on a fictitious part without a services analyst operating the screen, and to state where that analyst would sit.
Ratings: Part-level access Not documented; BOM and revisions Configured; quotes and award Native; hosting evidence Not documented; supplier controls Configured; supplier response Configured; ERP and records Configured.
Pricing model: custom quote-based enterprise subscription, often bundled with managed services.
See LightSource vs. GEP.
8. Keelvar
What it is. A sourcing optimization and automation platform for large, multi-lot events.
Best for: constrained awards across already-qualified suppliers, such as bundles, capacity limits or freight lanes. Suppliers bid free through invite-based accounts, online or in Excel.
Watch-outs. Keelvar's data is scoped to each sourcing event; it is not an item or BOM system of record, so drawings, revisions and part history live elsewhere. We could not find documented government cloud hosting.
Demo test: model a split award with a qualified-capacity cap on one supplier and see who builds the model.
Ratings: Part-level access Not documented; BOM and revisions Not documented; quotes and award Native; hosting evidence Not documented; supplier controls Not documented; supplier response Native; ERP and records Not documented.
Pricing model: quote-based enterprise subscription; no public price list.
9. Arkestro
What it is. A predictive price discovery and automated negotiation tool that runs alongside an existing suite.
Best for: repeat buys with useful price history.
Watch-outs. Arkestro does not hold items, drawings or cost breakdowns as a system of record, and a predicted price is not a should-cost. It is less useful for a sole-qualified source or a first article with no price history, which describes a lot of defense work. We could not find documented government cloud hosting.
Demo test: run a first-article RFQ with no history and ask what the model suggests.
Ratings: Part-level access Not documented; BOM and revisions Not documented; quotes and award Configured; hosting evidence Not documented; supplier controls Not documented; supplier response Not documented; ERP and records Configured.
Pricing model: platform subscription, not published.
Tools That Pair With Sourcing
Several tools defense buyers evaluate alongside sourcing software do a different job, and it helps to be clear about which.
Exostar runs defense collaboration services, including the sourcing application RTX's suppliers use. In RTX's design the sourcing application is deliberately kept free of export-controlled data, and drawings move through a separate gateway, so it is an example of a controlled two-channel workflow rather than a drawing vault.
Exiger (1Exiger) and Air (formerly Govini) sell to defense buyers but describe themselves in other terms. Exiger calls 1Exiger its "supply chain and third-party risk intelligence platform." Govini announced its new name, Air, in June 2026, and says its Enterprise Readiness platform "aligns development, production, delivery, and sustainment into one coordinated execution system." Neither is positioned as a tool for issuing RFQs and comparing competitive bids; use them for supplier risk and readiness analysis and feed the findings to the buyer making the award.
Cofactr is an electronics procurement and logistics platform that, according to SiliconANGLE's December 2024 coverage, runs entirely on AWS GovCloud and counts defense-tech companies Neros Labs and Nautilus Defense as customers. Choose it when the problem includes buying, receiving and kitting electronic components, not only collecting quotes on machined and fabricated parts.
Where Defense RFQs Go Wrong
The enforcement record shows that the risky moment is often the RFQ itself. In 2021 the State Department settled with Honeywell for a $13 million civil penalty, $5 million of it suspended for remedial compliance. Its charging letter describes supply-chain staff sending RFQs with part drawings to U.S. and foreign suppliers through a file exchange platform; Honeywell identified 71 ITAR-controlled drawings exported without authorization to Canada, Ireland, China and Taiwan. In August 2026 BAE Systems, Inc. agreed to a $36 million civil penalty, $18 million suspended, to settle 104 charged violations, including unauthorized exports of technical data to Canada, the UK and Germany and a retransfer of technical data to an unauthorized UK supplier. Both companies disclosed the violations voluntarily. Both cases centered on technical data sent abroad or to suppliers, not only on shipped hardware.
The cyber rules moved on a different track. The CMMC program rule was published October 15, 2024 and took effect December 16, 2024, and the acquisition rule published September 10, 2025 started Phase 1, with self-assessments, on November 10, 2025. Phase 2, which would have required third-party assessments for contractors handling CUI, had been scheduled to start November 10, 2026. On July 13, 2026 the Department of War suspended it and said it would keep enforcing NIST SP 800-171 Revision 2 through self-assessments and selected government-led assessments. DFARS 252.204-7012 did not change: cyber incidents must be reported within 72 hours of discovery, images preserved for at least 90 days after the report, and a cloud provider storing covered defense information must meet requirements equivalent to the FedRAMP Moderate baseline. A paused CMMC schedule is not a reason to loosen how drawings reach suppliers.

CMMC's third-party phase was suspended in July 2026, while State Department ITAR penalties in cases involving technical data grew from $13 million (Honeywell, 2021, over RFQ drawings sent to suppliers) to $36 million (BAE Systems, Inc., 2026, covering 104 charged violations, including technical data exports). Sources: Federal Register (2024, 2025), WilmerHale (July 2026), State Department charging letter and ClearanceJobs (2021), Global Sanctions (August 2026).
The supply base adds a second pressure. GAO found that the number of small businesses receiving DoD contract awards fell from 42,723 in 2011 to 24,296 in 2020, a 43 percent decline, and DoD's 2022 competition report notes that aerospace and defense prime contractors consolidated from 51 to 5 during the 1990s. Fewer suppliers means more sole and dual sources, and visibility below tier two is thin: as of April 2025, DoD's SCREEn effort had first- and second-tier country-of-origin data for 30,000 of about 40,000 F-35 parts, but origin data on less than 10 percent of the suppliers providing components and raw materials for those parts. In 2022, F-35 deliveries were halted when a magnet in a Honeywell turbomachine turned out to use a Chinese-origin alloy from what Lockheed called a fifth-tier supplier. A U.S. address on a tier-one quote says little about where the metal was melted. We cover the regulatory basics in ITAR explained and the cultural shift for buyers moving from automotive in from automotive to aerospace.
What It Costs
Almost no vendor in this category publishes a price list, and defense adds cost lines a commercial quote leaves out.
Cost line | Ask |
|---|---|
Separate U.S. tenant | Included or extra? |
Implementation | Who, and how long? |
ERP and PLM work | Fixed or hourly? |
Supplier fees | Any, at any threshold? |
AI features | Inside the boundary? |
The suites generally price by module and user count, with implementation as a separate integrator contract and government cloud hosting priced as its own line. LightSource's model is a platform fee plus seats with implementation included, and suppliers never pay; GovCloud deployment is available by request and should be scoped in the same quote. Supplier fees matter more in defense than elsewhere because many machine shops already carry accounts for several prime portals, and a fee or a heavy onboarding burden pushes them back to email. Ask every finalist for the same three-year scenario: buyer seats, external suppliers, a separate U.S. tenant if you need one, implementation, ERP and PLM integration, data export and exit. Where it applies, ask for two prices, one with controlled files inside the application and one with files held on your own server.
Keep the incumbent in the comparison. If your current suite can already release the right revision to the right supplier, return a comparable quote and reconstruct the award under the same access rules, a second tool has to save enough buyer time to cover another supplier login, another offboarding step and the reconciliation between them. A free supplier license does not make that cost zero.
A Controlled-Data Pilot Checklist
The fastest way to compare these platforms is to run one real commodity through two of them for 30 days with fictitious part numbers and markings. The test below is built so that no vendor, including LightSource, can pass it with a slide.
Write down your data rules first. List which fields are safe in the sourcing tool (part number, quantity, material family) and which must stay in your controlled environment (drawings, specs, sometimes descriptions). Your export compliance lead signs off on the list before any vendor sees it.
Load a 30-line BOM with one ITAR-controlled drawing referenced by a secure link and one uploaded item visible only to named suppliers. Record the time until items carry specs, files and quantities.
Send a mixed RFQ to five suppliers where each may quote only some lines. Give one supplier two sites and two users with different approvals, and log in as each user to screenshot what they can open, including email previews and reminders. A U.S. mailing address is not evidence that a given person is eligible to receive the file.
Test the return trip. Have a supplier try to send back a marked-up copy of the controlled drawing with its quote, then try again through supplier Q&A and a help request. Outbound controls mean little if controlled content comes back into the commercial bid, so agree the approved route for technical questions before the event.
Change the team mid-event. Let a supplier add an estimator who may help with pricing but is not approved for the drawing, then remove another estimator before a resend. Check each person's portal view, email and file-server access separately, and what happens to copies already downloaded.
Collect flow-down evidence before award: NIST SP 800-171 self-assessment status where CUI is involved, NDA and the clauses the subcontract will carry. Then move the work to a different supplier site after price approval and see which approvals have to repeat. See supplier qualification.
Push a revision to one part and re-quote only that line; check that the first round is preserved and that no one can award against the stale revision. Our engineering change order entry covers the vocabulary.
Compare quotes in one cost breakdown (material, conversion, overhead and margin, tooling, logistics) and build a single-source and a split-award scenario, since many defense parts have only one or two qualified sources.
Run the incident clock. Assume a reportable cyber incident is discovered at 9 a.m. on a Monday. Under DFARS 252.204-7012 the report is due by 9 a.m. Thursday, and if it is filed Tuesday the 90-day preservation period for images and monitoring data runs from Tuesday. Name who at each vendor notifies you and who can retrieve the evidence.
Export the award to an ERP test environment with supplier, part ID, revision, price and effective date, and write down four dates: contract signature, first live RFQ, first award loaded into the ERP, and first program fully on the new tool.
How We Ranked
LightSource wrote this guide, and LightSource is on the list. To keep it useful we scored every platform, including our own, on the same seven criteria a defense direct materials team actually uses: part-level access, BOM and revisions, quotes and award, hosting evidence, supplier controls, supplier response, and ERP and records. The weights are stated in the "How We Scored" section. To total them, a Native rating earns the full weight, Configured earns 60 percent, and Marketed or Not documented earn nothing until demonstrated. On that basis the platforms score: LightSource 86, Ivalua 72, Oracle 70, JAGGAER 65, SAP Ariba 64, Coupa 62, GEP 45, Keelvar 25 and Arkestro 15, out of 100. Capability notes come from public documentation, the FedRAMP Marketplace, public customer notices, public buyer reviews and our own evaluations as of September 2026; where we could not find a capability documented we say "not documented", which is not the same as "not offered". The suites on this list do things LightSource does not: purchase orders, invoicing, indirect spend, auctions, contract management and, for Oracle and Coupa, a FedRAMP-authorized package on record. If you need those, say so in your evaluation and weigh them.
LightSource ranks first because it rates Native on part-level access, BOM and revisions, quotes and award, and supplier response, which carry 65 percent of the weight, while conceding hosting evidence, purchase orders and quality workflows. Ivalua ranks second on its defense references and GovCloud offering, and Oracle third on its authorization record. JAGGAER, SAP Ariba, Coupa and GEP follow on the balance of direct depth and documented hosting. Keelvar and Arkestro are strong at what they do but are not systems of record for parts. We state analyst listings as facts; inclusion in a Hackett guide is not a recommendation of LightSource.
For the broader market, including platforms outside defense, see our guide to the best direct materials procurement software in 2026, and for the data groundwork, our colleague Mason Morgan on mastering BOM data.
Update log. Published September 24, 2026. Last reviewed September 24, 2026.
Sources
Exostar's RTX Sourcing Supplier RFQ Training -- RTX, Aug. 1, 2023: no export-controlled data in the sourcing application; drawings sent via RTX Secure Messenger Gateway
Proposed charging letter, Honeywell International Inc. -- U.S. Department of State, DDTC, 2021: RFQ drawings sent through a file exchange platform; 71 ITAR-controlled drawings
Honeywell agrees to pay millions for sending controlled arms information abroad -- ClearanceJobs, May 5, 2021: $13 million penalty, $5 million suspended
BAE Systems' US subsidiary agrees $36 million ITAR settlement -- Global Sanctions, Aug. 17, 2026
DFARS 252.204-7012 -- Acquisition.gov: 72-hour reporting, 90-day preservation, FedRAMP Moderate equivalence for cloud providers
CMMC program final rule -- Federal Register, Oct. 15, 2024
CMMC acquisition final rule -- Federal Register, Sept. 10, 2025
Pentagon suspends CMMC Phase 2 requirements -- WilmerHale, July 20, 2026
What the CMMC pause means for the defense industrial base -- CSIS, July 29, 2026
Oracle Fusion Cloud, FedRAMP Marketplace -- GSA FedRAMP: Moderate, certified Jan. 13, 2020; Oracle Government Cloud eligibility
Coupa Spend Management for Federal, FedRAMP Marketplace -- GSA FedRAMP: Moderate, certified Mar. 10, 2022
SAP NS2 achieves ITAR compliance for SAP Ariba with Google Cloud -- Google Cloud, Sept. 19, 2023
General Atomics picks Ivalua to centralize supplier collaboration on GovCloud -- TechInformed, Feb. 5, 2026
GA selects Ivalua platform -- General Atomics supplier notice
BAE Systems selects Ivalua to streamline S2P processes -- ADS Group, Mar. 19, 2025
Sourcing (for direct) Solutions -- The Hackett Group Solution Intelligence (formerly Spend Matters), Sept. 22, 2026: vendor entries for LightSource, Ivalua, JAGGAER and GEP
Cofactr secures $17.2M to expand supply chain tools for high-compliance industries -- SiliconANGLE, Dec. 12, 2024
Exiger launches supply chain AI platform in AWS Marketplace -- Exiger press release, Mar. 17, 2026: 1Exiger described as its "supply chain and third-party risk intelligence platform"
Govini declares "Readiness Gap" a national security crisis -- Air (formerly Govini) via PR Newswire, June 16, 2026
Small Business Contracting: Actions Needed to Implement and Monitor DOD's Small Business Strategy -- GAO-22-104621, Oct. 14, 2021: small businesses receiving DoD awards fell 43 percent, 2011 to 2020
State of Competition Within the Defense Industrial Base -- Department of Defense, Feb. 2022: prime contractors consolidated from 51 to 5 in the 1990s
Defense Industrial Base: Actions Needed to Address Risks Posed by Dependence on Foreign Suppliers -- GAO-25-107283, July 24, 2025: F-35 country-of-origin data
DoD inks waiver for deliveries of F-35s halted over Chinese material -- Defense News, Oct. 7, 2022
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best procurement software for ITAR-controlled RFQs?
For direct materials RFQs on ITAR programs, LightSource ranks first in this guide because buyers can restrict projects and items to access groups, choose which suppliers see each item and which item properties they see, and keep controlled drawings on their own secure server, linked from the part record. If CUI must live inside a FedRAMP-authorized environment, look first at Oracle Fusion Cloud (for eligible contractors) or Coupa Spend Management for Federal, both listed at Moderate, and ask Ivalua for the current status of its GovCloud offering. No software makes a release decision for you; your export compliance team still does.
Can we use a commercial sourcing tool if the ITAR drawings stay in our own secure portal?
Yes, and at least one large prime works this way: RTX keeps export-controlled data out of its Exostar-hosted sourcing application and sends drawings through a separate gateway. Two details decide whether it works. Part names, descriptions and properties can themselves be controlled, so decide which fields are allowed in the sourcing tool before you launch. And controlled content can come back the other way, as a marked-up drawing or screenshot attached to a quote or a supplier question, so agree the approved route for technical replies before the RFQ goes out.
Is LightSource FedRAMP authorized or CMMC certified?
No. LightSource does not claim FedRAMP authorization, CMMC certification or DFARS 252.204-7012 attestations. It supports ITAR-controlled sourcing programs, offers deployment on AWS GovCloud by request, states that it holds a SOC 2 Type 2 attestation and supports two CUI patterns: controlled direct upload to selected suppliers, or a link to the buyer's own secure FTP server in the part metadata.
Which procurement platforms are FedRAMP authorized?
On the FedRAMP Marketplace, Oracle Fusion Cloud is listed at Moderate since January 2020 and Coupa Spend Management for Federal at Moderate since March 2022. SAP NS2 announced ITAR compliance for SAP Ariba on Google Cloud in 2023, and Ivalua has said its GovCloud offering reached FedRAMP Ready at the moderate level. A listing covers a named package, so ask each vendor which modules, supplier portals and AI features sit inside it.
Will CMMC Phase 2 start on November 10, 2026?
Not as scheduled. Phase 2 was set to begin November 10, 2026, but the Department of War suspended it on July 13, 2026 and said it would keep enforcing NIST SP 800-171 Revision 2 through self-assessments and selected government-led assessments. DFARS 252.204-7012 still applies, including 72-hour incident reporting. Check each solicitation and subcontract for the clauses that actually apply.
What should we require from a machine shop before awarding defense work?
Collect the evidence the subcontract will require before award: the supplier's NIST SP 800-171 self-assessment status where CUI is involved, an NDA, export authorization for any technical data you will release, and the flow-down clauses the work triggers. Record it where buyers can see it next to the quote, and re-check it when the scope of work changes. Keep the bar proportionate; a commercial off-the-shelf purchase does not need the same pack as a CUI subcontract.
How do we stop an old revision from being awarded?
Use software that ties every quote to a part revision and preserves each RFQ round. In LightSource, when engineering revises a part the buyer resends the RFQ, every version is preserved, suppliers see the new RFQ version, the buyer's message and the RFQ history, and revisions can be compared side by side. If drawings are linked from your own file server, make the link point to a specific revision rather than a folder that changes, so the quote history still shows what each supplier priced after revision C replaces B. In any pilot, deliberately try to award against the stale revision and see what the tool does.
How much does defense procurement software cost?
Few vendors publish prices. Suites are typically custom-quoted by module and user count, with implementation and government cloud hosting as separate lines; LightSource charges a platform fee plus seats with implementation included, and suppliers pay nothing. Ask every finalist for the same three-year scenario including a separate U.S. tenant, integration, supplier fees and exit.
Are Exiger and Govini sourcing tools?
No. Exiger describes 1Exiger as a "supply chain and third-party risk intelligence platform," and Air (formerly Govini) describes its Enterprise Readiness platform as "one coordinated execution system" for defense development, production, delivery and sustainment. Neither is positioned for running competitive RFQs or comparing bids, so defense manufacturers that use them typically do so alongside a sourcing tool and feed their findings to the buyer making the award.
The best procurement software for a defense manufacturer depends on where controlled technical data has to live. For direct materials RFQs on ITAR programs, where buyers need control over which suppliers see which parts, LightSource ranks first in this guide. Ivalua is the stronger pick for replacing a whole source-to-pay suite on a government cloud, and Oracle Fusion Procurement suits eligible contractors already running Oracle. SAP Ariba with SAP NS2 fits SAP estates.
That split matters because a defense RFQ is a release of technical data. Every drawing attached to a quote request is an export decision, and the supplier on the other end may have a foreign parent, an overseas support team or a sub-tier processor in another country. This guide ranks nine platforms on what a defense direct materials team does every week: deciding which supplier may see which part, keeping controlled files where they belong, re-quoting when a revision changes, and getting small machine shops to respond without falling back to email. LightSource publishes this guide and ranks its own product; the weights, the disclosure and the places where LightSource falls short are all below.
The Short Answer
At least one large prime documents a split model. RTX's supplier training for its Exostar-hosted sourcing application states that no export-controlled data may be uploaded to the application at all; drawings travel separately through the RTX Secure Messenger Gateway. The sourcing tool collects bids, and a separate controlled channel carries the technical data. The question for a buyer is which software makes that separation easy to run and hard to bypass. Our verdict by buyer type, as of September 2026:
Buyer | Shortlist |
|---|---|
Defense-tech scaling production | LightSource, then Ivalua |
Subcontractor on ITAR programs | LightSource, then JAGGAER |
Prime replacing its S2P suite | Ivalua, then LightSource |
Contractor on Oracle | Oracle, then LightSource |
Contractor on SAP | SAP Ariba (NS2), then LightSource |
The honest exception is hosting. If your security team requires controlled unclassified information (CUI) to sit inside the sourcing application itself, in an environment with a FedRAMP authorization on record, start with Oracle Fusion Cloud (if you are eligible for Oracle Government Cloud) or Coupa Spend Management for Federal, both listed at the Moderate level, and ask Ivalua for the current status of its GovCloud offering. LightSource offers deployment on AWS GovCloud by request, but it does not claim FedRAMP authorization, so its usual pattern for CUI is to keep controlled files in the buyer's own environment and reference them from the part record.
How We Scored
We scored every platform, including our own, on seven criteria. The weights reflect where defense sourcing risk and time actually go: most of the risk sits in who receives which file, and most of the time sits in getting part data into an RFQ and comparable quotes back out.
Criterion | Weight | Test |
|---|---|---|
Part-level access | 20% | Control which suppliers see each part and property |
BOM and revisions | 20% | RFQ from a BOM, re-quote one revision |
Quotes and award | 15% | Same cost breakdown, award scenarios |
Hosting evidence | 15% | Documented GovCloud or FedRAMP path |
Supplier controls | 10% | Collect attestations before award |
Supplier response | 10% | Small shops respond, pay nothing |
ERP and records | 10% | Award lands in the purchasing system |
We rate each capability with the vocabulary our comparison library uses: Native (documented and in the standard product), Configured (available, but set up per customer, per deployment or through a separate product), Marketed (claimed without public evidence of how it works) and Not documented (we could not find it, which is not the same as not offered). For hosting evidence, Native means an authorized package listed on the FedRAMP Marketplace, and Configured means a documented government cloud deployment without that listing. No rating in this guide is a security certification. A FedRAMP listing applies to a named package, not to every module or add-on a vendor sells, so ask for the boundary in writing.
The 9 Platforms at a Glance
Platform | Best fit |
|---|---|
1. LightSource | ITAR direct materials RFQs |
2. Ivalua | S2P suite on GovCloud |
3. Oracle Fusion | Contractors on Oracle |
4. JAGGAER | Multi-plant direct sourcing |
5. SAP Ariba (NS2) | SAP estates |
6. Coupa (Federal) | Finance-led spend control |
7. GEP | Software plus services |
8. Keelvar | Optimized multi-lot awards |
9. Arkestro | Repeat-buy price discovery |

Our ratings of nine platforms on this guide's seven criteria, as of September 2026. LightSource rates Native on part-level access, BOM and revisions, quotes and award, and supplier response, and Configured on hosting, supplier controls and ERP records. Source: LightSource assessment of public documentation, the FedRAMP Marketplace and public customer notices.
The 9 Platforms, Ranked
1. LightSource
What it is. LightSource is the AI-native direct materials operating system, spec through scale, PLM through ERP. Items are master data with specs, custom properties, revisions, drawings and files; BOMs are hierarchical, with snapshots and cost history, and a buyer can launch a sourcing project directly from a BOM or a batch of items.
Best for: defense and defense-tech manufacturers running direct materials RFQs on ITAR-controlled programs, from growth-stage hardware companies scaling production to divisions of larger primes, who want control over which suppliers see which parts without replacing their ERP or PLM.
Why it ranks first for this use. LightSource supports ITAR-controlled sourcing programs and has defense customers, whom we do not name. Buyers can restrict projects, items and RFI events to access groups and choose which item properties suppliers see, and an RFQ goes only to the suppliers invited to it. Line-item supplier filtering sets which suppliers see which items, so a supplier quoting a bracket does not see the controlled drawing on the next line. That mix of per-item and per-property visibility is why we rate part-level access Native, with a limit worth knowing: the controls apply per record rather than per file, and Data Rooms do not set per-file permissions, so files that need file-level separation belong on the buyer's own server. For CUI, buyers choose one of two patterns: upload the BOM and parts directly for controlled sharing with selected suppliers, or put a link to their own secure FTP server in the part metadata so controlled files never leave their environment. The second pattern is the same separation RTX documents for its own suppliers, with the bid in one system and the drawing in another, except the link lives on the part record, so the reference travels with the part and its revisions. Deployment on AWS GovCloud is available by request.
Quotes come back structured. Every supplier fills the same quote format, from unit price only to a full breakdown of raw materials, purchased items, machine and assembly processes, packaging, logistics and markups, in the app or through an Excel round-trip. When engineering revises a part, the buyer resends the RFQ, every version is preserved and suppliers see the new RFQ version, the buyer's message and the RFQ history. Award scenarios can be built by hand or generated from submitted quotes, split by volume or percentage, and routed for approval. Suppliers use LightSource free, which matters in a supply base where small shops already maintain accounts for several prime portals, Supplier Discovery searches by company name, process or material, and LightSource's supplier network includes more than 100,000 suppliers. LightSource states that it holds a SOC 2 Type 2 attestation and does not train foundation models on customer RFQ, RFI or contract data. It supports SAML single sign-on, and a team admin can require multi-factor authentication for members who sign in with email and password.
Watch-outs. LightSource does not claim FedRAMP authorization, CMMC certification or DFARS 252.204-7012 attestations, and it does not claim ITAR registration of its own; your export compliance team still decides what may be released to whom. If you upload CUI directly rather than linking to your own server, your security team should evaluate the GovCloud deployment against the cloud requirements in your contracts. The secure-FTP pattern keeps files out of the application, but part names, descriptions and properties in the RFQ can themselves be controlled, so decide which fields are safe before launch. LightSource does not issue purchase orders or invoices (an award creates an item contract, not a PO), does not run PPAP or first article workflows, has no built-in should-cost engine and connects to ERP and PLM through Excel Item Sync and a GraphQL API rather than certified prebuilt connectors. Supplier flow-down attestations can be collected through RFIs with an NDA round-trip and Data Rooms, but there is no clause-pack engine. The company came out of stealth in 2025.
Demo test: send one RFQ with three lines to three suppliers where each supplier may see only one line, and log in as each supplier to confirm what they can and cannot open. Then test the linked-file pattern over time: have one shop quote revision B through a link to your test file server, publish revision C on the server and resend. A second buyer should be able to tell from the RFQ history which revision each shop priced, without relying on what the link opens today, so put the revision in the link or the part record rather than pointing at a folder that changes.
Ratings: Part-level access Native; BOM and revisions Native; quotes and award Native; hosting evidence Configured; supplier controls Configured; supplier response Native; ERP and records Configured.
Pricing model: platform fee plus seats, implementation included; suppliers pay nothing.
LightSource is listed in The Hackett Group's Sourcing (for direct) Solutions guide as an "AI-native sourcing platform purpose-built for direct materials procurement," and was named a Gartner Cool Vendor in Sourcing and Procurement Technology (2025). Deployment typically takes about 30 days, with bespoke integration work scoped separately.
2. Ivalua
What it is. Ivalua is an organically built source-to-pay suite on a single codebase. The Hackett Group's direct sourcing guide calls it a "natively integrated, intuitive and flexible suite" with capabilities for all spend, including direct materials.
Best for: defense primes and large subcontractors that want to replace a whole S2P suite (supplier onboarding, risk, sourcing, contracts, POs and invoices) in a government cloud environment, and will invest in configuration.
Why it ranks here. In our reading of public records, Ivalua has the strongest defense references of the suites in this guide. BAE Systems, Inc. selected Ivalua for source-to-pay in March 2025. In February 2026 General Atomics picked Ivalua as its single system of record for supplier collaboration, with the deployment running on Ivalua's GovCloud offering, and GA's own supplier notice says Ivalua's quality and compliance features tailored to aerospace and defense were key differentiators. Ivalua has said its GovCloud offering achieved FedRAMP Ready status at the moderate impact level. If you need one platform that holds supplier qualification, sourcing and the purchasing record together, Ivalua is the better pick than LightSource.
Watch-outs. FedRAMP Ready is a readiness designation, not an authorization, and a customer's own environment statement does not transfer to your tenant; ask Ivalua for the current status and boundary of the package you would buy. Value from Ivalua depends on configuration skill and a strong implementation partner, and a suite rollout takes time; GA's notice told suppliers to keep using its previous tool until implementation was complete. In our evaluations, BOM sync is set up per customer rather than extracted from drawings and spreadsheets.
Demo test: have the implementation partner show a mixed RFQ where one supplier's approval expires mid-event, and record which steps need a configuration change rather than a buyer action.
Ratings: Part-level access Configured; BOM and revisions Configured; quotes and award Configured; hosting evidence Configured; supplier controls Native; supplier response Native; ERP and records Native.
Pricing model: custom-quoted subscription sized by modules and users, with implementation sold separately; suppliers quote free through the portal.
3. Oracle Fusion Cloud Procurement
What it is. Oracle's procurement applications on the same data model as Oracle financials, projects and manufacturing.
Best for: contractors already running Oracle Fusion ERP who want procurement inside a FedRAMP-authorized SaaS environment.
Why it ranks here. Oracle has the clearest public authorization record in this guide. The FedRAMP Marketplace lists Oracle Fusion Cloud (package F1603257882) as FedRAMP Certified at the Moderate level since January 13, 2020, and its service description includes procurement and project management. Oracle Government Cloud is a community cloud limited to agencies, select universities and federal contractors with a demonstrated need for FedRAMP authorization, so eligibility is the first question. For an eligible Oracle shop that needs purchasing, project cost and supplier records in one authorized environment, Oracle is the better pick.
Watch-outs. The product is P2P-first, and its sourcing events are general all-spend events rather than drawing- and revision-centric RFQs. Oracle's design-to-source capability sits in Fusion Cloud PLM, a separate entitlement, so ask which licenses a quote includes. Implementations are partner-led and ERP-class, and outside an Oracle estate most of the integration advantage goes away.
Demo test: ask for a list of every screen shown, the product that owns it, the license it requires, and whether that product sits inside the FedRAMP package you would buy.
Ratings: Part-level access Configured; BOM and revisions Configured; quotes and award Configured; hosting evidence Native; supplier controls Configured; supplier response Configured; ERP and records Native.
Pricing model: published per-hosted-named-user list price with a user minimum; contracted price set per order.
4. JAGGAER
What it is. A source-to-pay suite with the deepest direct materials heritage of the suites, through JAGGAER Direct (formerly POOL4TOOL).
Best for: multi-plant manufacturers that want direct sourcing with multi-tier BOMs inside one suite.
Why it ranks here. The Hackett Group's direct sourcing guide credits JAGGAER with "sophisticated direct materials sourcing capabilities." For a subcontractor whose biggest problem is BOM-driven sourcing across plants, JAGGAER is the suite most likely to fit.
Watch-outs. We could not find documented U.S. government cloud hosting or a CUI boundary for JAGGAER's commercial sourcing product, so plan on a separate secure channel for controlled drawings, as RTX does with its own sourcing application. Hackett's guide notes the suite was built over time through multiple acquisitions, so test how item, supplier and contract data move between modules. A recurring complaint among reviewers is rigidity.
Demo test: have a plant buyer add a field to a cost breakdown, run an event with it, and attach a drawing reference that points to your own secure file share rather than an upload.
Ratings: Part-level access Configured; BOM and revisions Native; quotes and award Native; hosting evidence Not documented; supplier controls Configured; supplier response Configured; ERP and records Configured.
Pricing model: custom-quoted by module and users; some public contracts add an annual spend threshold.
5. SAP Ariba (with SAP NS2)
What it is. SAP's source-to-pay suite, offered for regulated customers through SAP National Security Services (SAP NS2).
Best for: defense manufacturers standardized on SAP S/4HANA that want to keep the SAP Business Network and change how regulated data is hosted.
Why it ranks here. In September 2023, Google Cloud announced that SAP NS2 had achieved ITAR compliance for SAP Ariba on Google Cloud with Assured Workloads. Native integration with SAP ERP means material masters and awarded pricing flow to S/4HANA without a separate integration project. Its RFx and auction engine is mature and widely deployed.
Watch-outs. An ITAR-compliant hosting announcement is not proof that every Ariba module, the supplier network and each extension sit inside the same boundary, so ask for the SKU-by-SKU scope. A recurring minority complaint among reviewers is a dated interface that needs extensive training for occasional users, and rollouts are partner-led. In our evaluations, sourcing events reference ERP material master rows rather than drawings, properties and revisions, and detailed cost breakdowns usually travel as an Excel attachment. Enterprise supplier accounts on SAP Business Network that cross published thresholds pay fees, a known friction for small machine shops.
Demo test: send a drawing-linked RFQ to a small supplier on a Standard account and confirm, from the supplier's side, which service hosts the file.
Ratings: Part-level access Configured; BOM and revisions Configured; quotes and award Configured; hosting evidence Configured; supplier controls Configured; supplier response Configured; ERP and records Native.
Pricing model: module subscriptions, price on request, plus integrator implementation; NS2 hosting is quoted separately.
See LightSource vs. SAP Ariba.
6. Coupa (Spend Management for Federal)
What it is. Coupa's P2P and spend management suite, with a federal edition.
Best for: finance-led organizations that want spend control, P2P and supplier onboarding in an authorized environment, with direct materials sourcing handled elsewhere.
Why it ranks here. The FedRAMP Marketplace lists Coupa Spend Management for Federal (package F1308202329) as FedRAMP Certified at the Moderate level since March 10, 2022. Coupa is the broadest P2P suite here, and its supplier portal is free for suppliers.
Watch-outs. The federal edition is built for agencies; confirm that a contractor can buy it and that the supplier portal and add-ons you need are inside the package. P2P and indirect spend are Coupa's center of gravity, and we could not find a documented BOM-led sourcing module. A manufacturer that already uses Coupa for orders and invoices can keep it and add a direct materials platform for engineered parts.
Demo test: ask which of the modules in your quote are inside package F1308202329 and which are commercial-only.
Ratings: Part-level access Configured; BOM and revisions Not documented; quotes and award Configured; hosting evidence Native; supplier controls Configured; supplier response Native; ERP and records Native.
Pricing model: custom quote by module and user count; integrator-led rollout.
7. GEP
What it is. An organically built suite (GEP SMART and QUANTUM) sold with consulting and managed services.
Best for: manufacturers that want should-cost modeling and sourcing services from the same provider.
Why it ranks here. The Hackett Group's direct sourcing guide credits GEP's suite with "cost and should-cost modeling" usable for direct and indirect spend. That is a built-in capability LightSource does not have; LightSource takes an uploaded should-cost and uses it as the bid baseline.
Watch-outs. We could not find a documented U.S. government cloud deployment or controlled-data boundary for GEP's sourcing product. Implementation and operation often come bundled with GEP services, and if services analysts will touch your drawings, their nationality and location become part of your export analysis.
Demo test: ask GEP to repeat its should-cost exercise on a fictitious part without a services analyst operating the screen, and to state where that analyst would sit.
Ratings: Part-level access Not documented; BOM and revisions Configured; quotes and award Native; hosting evidence Not documented; supplier controls Configured; supplier response Configured; ERP and records Configured.
Pricing model: custom quote-based enterprise subscription, often bundled with managed services.
See LightSource vs. GEP.
8. Keelvar
What it is. A sourcing optimization and automation platform for large, multi-lot events.
Best for: constrained awards across already-qualified suppliers, such as bundles, capacity limits or freight lanes. Suppliers bid free through invite-based accounts, online or in Excel.
Watch-outs. Keelvar's data is scoped to each sourcing event; it is not an item or BOM system of record, so drawings, revisions and part history live elsewhere. We could not find documented government cloud hosting.
Demo test: model a split award with a qualified-capacity cap on one supplier and see who builds the model.
Ratings: Part-level access Not documented; BOM and revisions Not documented; quotes and award Native; hosting evidence Not documented; supplier controls Not documented; supplier response Native; ERP and records Not documented.
Pricing model: quote-based enterprise subscription; no public price list.
9. Arkestro
What it is. A predictive price discovery and automated negotiation tool that runs alongside an existing suite.
Best for: repeat buys with useful price history.
Watch-outs. Arkestro does not hold items, drawings or cost breakdowns as a system of record, and a predicted price is not a should-cost. It is less useful for a sole-qualified source or a first article with no price history, which describes a lot of defense work. We could not find documented government cloud hosting.
Demo test: run a first-article RFQ with no history and ask what the model suggests.
Ratings: Part-level access Not documented; BOM and revisions Not documented; quotes and award Configured; hosting evidence Not documented; supplier controls Not documented; supplier response Not documented; ERP and records Configured.
Pricing model: platform subscription, not published.
Tools That Pair With Sourcing
Several tools defense buyers evaluate alongside sourcing software do a different job, and it helps to be clear about which.
Exostar runs defense collaboration services, including the sourcing application RTX's suppliers use. In RTX's design the sourcing application is deliberately kept free of export-controlled data, and drawings move through a separate gateway, so it is an example of a controlled two-channel workflow rather than a drawing vault.
Exiger (1Exiger) and Air (formerly Govini) sell to defense buyers but describe themselves in other terms. Exiger calls 1Exiger its "supply chain and third-party risk intelligence platform." Govini announced its new name, Air, in June 2026, and says its Enterprise Readiness platform "aligns development, production, delivery, and sustainment into one coordinated execution system." Neither is positioned as a tool for issuing RFQs and comparing competitive bids; use them for supplier risk and readiness analysis and feed the findings to the buyer making the award.
Cofactr is an electronics procurement and logistics platform that, according to SiliconANGLE's December 2024 coverage, runs entirely on AWS GovCloud and counts defense-tech companies Neros Labs and Nautilus Defense as customers. Choose it when the problem includes buying, receiving and kitting electronic components, not only collecting quotes on machined and fabricated parts.
Where Defense RFQs Go Wrong
The enforcement record shows that the risky moment is often the RFQ itself. In 2021 the State Department settled with Honeywell for a $13 million civil penalty, $5 million of it suspended for remedial compliance. Its charging letter describes supply-chain staff sending RFQs with part drawings to U.S. and foreign suppliers through a file exchange platform; Honeywell identified 71 ITAR-controlled drawings exported without authorization to Canada, Ireland, China and Taiwan. In August 2026 BAE Systems, Inc. agreed to a $36 million civil penalty, $18 million suspended, to settle 104 charged violations, including unauthorized exports of technical data to Canada, the UK and Germany and a retransfer of technical data to an unauthorized UK supplier. Both companies disclosed the violations voluntarily. Both cases centered on technical data sent abroad or to suppliers, not only on shipped hardware.
The cyber rules moved on a different track. The CMMC program rule was published October 15, 2024 and took effect December 16, 2024, and the acquisition rule published September 10, 2025 started Phase 1, with self-assessments, on November 10, 2025. Phase 2, which would have required third-party assessments for contractors handling CUI, had been scheduled to start November 10, 2026. On July 13, 2026 the Department of War suspended it and said it would keep enforcing NIST SP 800-171 Revision 2 through self-assessments and selected government-led assessments. DFARS 252.204-7012 did not change: cyber incidents must be reported within 72 hours of discovery, images preserved for at least 90 days after the report, and a cloud provider storing covered defense information must meet requirements equivalent to the FedRAMP Moderate baseline. A paused CMMC schedule is not a reason to loosen how drawings reach suppliers.

CMMC's third-party phase was suspended in July 2026, while State Department ITAR penalties in cases involving technical data grew from $13 million (Honeywell, 2021, over RFQ drawings sent to suppliers) to $36 million (BAE Systems, Inc., 2026, covering 104 charged violations, including technical data exports). Sources: Federal Register (2024, 2025), WilmerHale (July 2026), State Department charging letter and ClearanceJobs (2021), Global Sanctions (August 2026).
The supply base adds a second pressure. GAO found that the number of small businesses receiving DoD contract awards fell from 42,723 in 2011 to 24,296 in 2020, a 43 percent decline, and DoD's 2022 competition report notes that aerospace and defense prime contractors consolidated from 51 to 5 during the 1990s. Fewer suppliers means more sole and dual sources, and visibility below tier two is thin: as of April 2025, DoD's SCREEn effort had first- and second-tier country-of-origin data for 30,000 of about 40,000 F-35 parts, but origin data on less than 10 percent of the suppliers providing components and raw materials for those parts. In 2022, F-35 deliveries were halted when a magnet in a Honeywell turbomachine turned out to use a Chinese-origin alloy from what Lockheed called a fifth-tier supplier. A U.S. address on a tier-one quote says little about where the metal was melted. We cover the regulatory basics in ITAR explained and the cultural shift for buyers moving from automotive in from automotive to aerospace.
What It Costs
Almost no vendor in this category publishes a price list, and defense adds cost lines a commercial quote leaves out.
Cost line | Ask |
|---|---|
Separate U.S. tenant | Included or extra? |
Implementation | Who, and how long? |
ERP and PLM work | Fixed or hourly? |
Supplier fees | Any, at any threshold? |
AI features | Inside the boundary? |
The suites generally price by module and user count, with implementation as a separate integrator contract and government cloud hosting priced as its own line. LightSource's model is a platform fee plus seats with implementation included, and suppliers never pay; GovCloud deployment is available by request and should be scoped in the same quote. Supplier fees matter more in defense than elsewhere because many machine shops already carry accounts for several prime portals, and a fee or a heavy onboarding burden pushes them back to email. Ask every finalist for the same three-year scenario: buyer seats, external suppliers, a separate U.S. tenant if you need one, implementation, ERP and PLM integration, data export and exit. Where it applies, ask for two prices, one with controlled files inside the application and one with files held on your own server.
Keep the incumbent in the comparison. If your current suite can already release the right revision to the right supplier, return a comparable quote and reconstruct the award under the same access rules, a second tool has to save enough buyer time to cover another supplier login, another offboarding step and the reconciliation between them. A free supplier license does not make that cost zero.
A Controlled-Data Pilot Checklist
The fastest way to compare these platforms is to run one real commodity through two of them for 30 days with fictitious part numbers and markings. The test below is built so that no vendor, including LightSource, can pass it with a slide.
Write down your data rules first. List which fields are safe in the sourcing tool (part number, quantity, material family) and which must stay in your controlled environment (drawings, specs, sometimes descriptions). Your export compliance lead signs off on the list before any vendor sees it.
Load a 30-line BOM with one ITAR-controlled drawing referenced by a secure link and one uploaded item visible only to named suppliers. Record the time until items carry specs, files and quantities.
Send a mixed RFQ to five suppliers where each may quote only some lines. Give one supplier two sites and two users with different approvals, and log in as each user to screenshot what they can open, including email previews and reminders. A U.S. mailing address is not evidence that a given person is eligible to receive the file.
Test the return trip. Have a supplier try to send back a marked-up copy of the controlled drawing with its quote, then try again through supplier Q&A and a help request. Outbound controls mean little if controlled content comes back into the commercial bid, so agree the approved route for technical questions before the event.
Change the team mid-event. Let a supplier add an estimator who may help with pricing but is not approved for the drawing, then remove another estimator before a resend. Check each person's portal view, email and file-server access separately, and what happens to copies already downloaded.
Collect flow-down evidence before award: NIST SP 800-171 self-assessment status where CUI is involved, NDA and the clauses the subcontract will carry. Then move the work to a different supplier site after price approval and see which approvals have to repeat. See supplier qualification.
Push a revision to one part and re-quote only that line; check that the first round is preserved and that no one can award against the stale revision. Our engineering change order entry covers the vocabulary.
Compare quotes in one cost breakdown (material, conversion, overhead and margin, tooling, logistics) and build a single-source and a split-award scenario, since many defense parts have only one or two qualified sources.
Run the incident clock. Assume a reportable cyber incident is discovered at 9 a.m. on a Monday. Under DFARS 252.204-7012 the report is due by 9 a.m. Thursday, and if it is filed Tuesday the 90-day preservation period for images and monitoring data runs from Tuesday. Name who at each vendor notifies you and who can retrieve the evidence.
Export the award to an ERP test environment with supplier, part ID, revision, price and effective date, and write down four dates: contract signature, first live RFQ, first award loaded into the ERP, and first program fully on the new tool.
How We Ranked
LightSource wrote this guide, and LightSource is on the list. To keep it useful we scored every platform, including our own, on the same seven criteria a defense direct materials team actually uses: part-level access, BOM and revisions, quotes and award, hosting evidence, supplier controls, supplier response, and ERP and records. The weights are stated in the "How We Scored" section. To total them, a Native rating earns the full weight, Configured earns 60 percent, and Marketed or Not documented earn nothing until demonstrated. On that basis the platforms score: LightSource 86, Ivalua 72, Oracle 70, JAGGAER 65, SAP Ariba 64, Coupa 62, GEP 45, Keelvar 25 and Arkestro 15, out of 100. Capability notes come from public documentation, the FedRAMP Marketplace, public customer notices, public buyer reviews and our own evaluations as of September 2026; where we could not find a capability documented we say "not documented", which is not the same as "not offered". The suites on this list do things LightSource does not: purchase orders, invoicing, indirect spend, auctions, contract management and, for Oracle and Coupa, a FedRAMP-authorized package on record. If you need those, say so in your evaluation and weigh them.
LightSource ranks first because it rates Native on part-level access, BOM and revisions, quotes and award, and supplier response, which carry 65 percent of the weight, while conceding hosting evidence, purchase orders and quality workflows. Ivalua ranks second on its defense references and GovCloud offering, and Oracle third on its authorization record. JAGGAER, SAP Ariba, Coupa and GEP follow on the balance of direct depth and documented hosting. Keelvar and Arkestro are strong at what they do but are not systems of record for parts. We state analyst listings as facts; inclusion in a Hackett guide is not a recommendation of LightSource.
For the broader market, including platforms outside defense, see our guide to the best direct materials procurement software in 2026, and for the data groundwork, our colleague Mason Morgan on mastering BOM data.
Update log. Published September 24, 2026. Last reviewed September 24, 2026.
Sources
Exostar's RTX Sourcing Supplier RFQ Training -- RTX, Aug. 1, 2023: no export-controlled data in the sourcing application; drawings sent via RTX Secure Messenger Gateway
Proposed charging letter, Honeywell International Inc. -- U.S. Department of State, DDTC, 2021: RFQ drawings sent through a file exchange platform; 71 ITAR-controlled drawings
Honeywell agrees to pay millions for sending controlled arms information abroad -- ClearanceJobs, May 5, 2021: $13 million penalty, $5 million suspended
BAE Systems' US subsidiary agrees $36 million ITAR settlement -- Global Sanctions, Aug. 17, 2026
DFARS 252.204-7012 -- Acquisition.gov: 72-hour reporting, 90-day preservation, FedRAMP Moderate equivalence for cloud providers
CMMC program final rule -- Federal Register, Oct. 15, 2024
CMMC acquisition final rule -- Federal Register, Sept. 10, 2025
Pentagon suspends CMMC Phase 2 requirements -- WilmerHale, July 20, 2026
What the CMMC pause means for the defense industrial base -- CSIS, July 29, 2026
Oracle Fusion Cloud, FedRAMP Marketplace -- GSA FedRAMP: Moderate, certified Jan. 13, 2020; Oracle Government Cloud eligibility
Coupa Spend Management for Federal, FedRAMP Marketplace -- GSA FedRAMP: Moderate, certified Mar. 10, 2022
SAP NS2 achieves ITAR compliance for SAP Ariba with Google Cloud -- Google Cloud, Sept. 19, 2023
General Atomics picks Ivalua to centralize supplier collaboration on GovCloud -- TechInformed, Feb. 5, 2026
GA selects Ivalua platform -- General Atomics supplier notice
BAE Systems selects Ivalua to streamline S2P processes -- ADS Group, Mar. 19, 2025
Sourcing (for direct) Solutions -- The Hackett Group Solution Intelligence (formerly Spend Matters), Sept. 22, 2026: vendor entries for LightSource, Ivalua, JAGGAER and GEP
Cofactr secures $17.2M to expand supply chain tools for high-compliance industries -- SiliconANGLE, Dec. 12, 2024
Exiger launches supply chain AI platform in AWS Marketplace -- Exiger press release, Mar. 17, 2026: 1Exiger described as its "supply chain and third-party risk intelligence platform"
Govini declares "Readiness Gap" a national security crisis -- Air (formerly Govini) via PR Newswire, June 16, 2026
Small Business Contracting: Actions Needed to Implement and Monitor DOD's Small Business Strategy -- GAO-22-104621, Oct. 14, 2021: small businesses receiving DoD awards fell 43 percent, 2011 to 2020
State of Competition Within the Defense Industrial Base -- Department of Defense, Feb. 2022: prime contractors consolidated from 51 to 5 in the 1990s
Defense Industrial Base: Actions Needed to Address Risks Posed by Dependence on Foreign Suppliers -- GAO-25-107283, July 24, 2025: F-35 country-of-origin data
DoD inks waiver for deliveries of F-35s halted over Chinese material -- Defense News, Oct. 7, 2022
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best procurement software for ITAR-controlled RFQs?
For direct materials RFQs on ITAR programs, LightSource ranks first in this guide because buyers can restrict projects and items to access groups, choose which suppliers see each item and which item properties they see, and keep controlled drawings on their own secure server, linked from the part record. If CUI must live inside a FedRAMP-authorized environment, look first at Oracle Fusion Cloud (for eligible contractors) or Coupa Spend Management for Federal, both listed at Moderate, and ask Ivalua for the current status of its GovCloud offering. No software makes a release decision for you; your export compliance team still does.
Can we use a commercial sourcing tool if the ITAR drawings stay in our own secure portal?
Yes, and at least one large prime works this way: RTX keeps export-controlled data out of its Exostar-hosted sourcing application and sends drawings through a separate gateway. Two details decide whether it works. Part names, descriptions and properties can themselves be controlled, so decide which fields are allowed in the sourcing tool before you launch. And controlled content can come back the other way, as a marked-up drawing or screenshot attached to a quote or a supplier question, so agree the approved route for technical replies before the RFQ goes out.
Is LightSource FedRAMP authorized or CMMC certified?
No. LightSource does not claim FedRAMP authorization, CMMC certification or DFARS 252.204-7012 attestations. It supports ITAR-controlled sourcing programs, offers deployment on AWS GovCloud by request, states that it holds a SOC 2 Type 2 attestation and supports two CUI patterns: controlled direct upload to selected suppliers, or a link to the buyer's own secure FTP server in the part metadata.
Which procurement platforms are FedRAMP authorized?
On the FedRAMP Marketplace, Oracle Fusion Cloud is listed at Moderate since January 2020 and Coupa Spend Management for Federal at Moderate since March 2022. SAP NS2 announced ITAR compliance for SAP Ariba on Google Cloud in 2023, and Ivalua has said its GovCloud offering reached FedRAMP Ready at the moderate level. A listing covers a named package, so ask each vendor which modules, supplier portals and AI features sit inside it.
Will CMMC Phase 2 start on November 10, 2026?
Not as scheduled. Phase 2 was set to begin November 10, 2026, but the Department of War suspended it on July 13, 2026 and said it would keep enforcing NIST SP 800-171 Revision 2 through self-assessments and selected government-led assessments. DFARS 252.204-7012 still applies, including 72-hour incident reporting. Check each solicitation and subcontract for the clauses that actually apply.
What should we require from a machine shop before awarding defense work?
Collect the evidence the subcontract will require before award: the supplier's NIST SP 800-171 self-assessment status where CUI is involved, an NDA, export authorization for any technical data you will release, and the flow-down clauses the work triggers. Record it where buyers can see it next to the quote, and re-check it when the scope of work changes. Keep the bar proportionate; a commercial off-the-shelf purchase does not need the same pack as a CUI subcontract.
How do we stop an old revision from being awarded?
Use software that ties every quote to a part revision and preserves each RFQ round. In LightSource, when engineering revises a part the buyer resends the RFQ, every version is preserved, suppliers see the new RFQ version, the buyer's message and the RFQ history, and revisions can be compared side by side. If drawings are linked from your own file server, make the link point to a specific revision rather than a folder that changes, so the quote history still shows what each supplier priced after revision C replaces B. In any pilot, deliberately try to award against the stale revision and see what the tool does.
How much does defense procurement software cost?
Few vendors publish prices. Suites are typically custom-quoted by module and user count, with implementation and government cloud hosting as separate lines; LightSource charges a platform fee plus seats with implementation included, and suppliers pay nothing. Ask every finalist for the same three-year scenario including a separate U.S. tenant, integration, supplier fees and exit.
Are Exiger and Govini sourcing tools?
No. Exiger describes 1Exiger as a "supply chain and third-party risk intelligence platform," and Air (formerly Govini) describes its Enterprise Readiness platform as "one coordinated execution system" for defense development, production, delivery and sustainment. Neither is positioned for running competitive RFQs or comparing bids, so defense manufacturers that use them typically do so alongside a sourcing tool and feed their findings to the buyer making the award.
The best procurement software for a defense manufacturer depends on where controlled technical data has to live. For direct materials RFQs on ITAR programs, where buyers need control over which suppliers see which parts, LightSource ranks first in this guide. Ivalua is the stronger pick for replacing a whole source-to-pay suite on a government cloud, and Oracle Fusion Procurement suits eligible contractors already running Oracle. SAP Ariba with SAP NS2 fits SAP estates.
That split matters because a defense RFQ is a release of technical data. Every drawing attached to a quote request is an export decision, and the supplier on the other end may have a foreign parent, an overseas support team or a sub-tier processor in another country. This guide ranks nine platforms on what a defense direct materials team does every week: deciding which supplier may see which part, keeping controlled files where they belong, re-quoting when a revision changes, and getting small machine shops to respond without falling back to email. LightSource publishes this guide and ranks its own product; the weights, the disclosure and the places where LightSource falls short are all below.
The Short Answer
At least one large prime documents a split model. RTX's supplier training for its Exostar-hosted sourcing application states that no export-controlled data may be uploaded to the application at all; drawings travel separately through the RTX Secure Messenger Gateway. The sourcing tool collects bids, and a separate controlled channel carries the technical data. The question for a buyer is which software makes that separation easy to run and hard to bypass. Our verdict by buyer type, as of September 2026:
Buyer | Shortlist |
|---|---|
Defense-tech scaling production | LightSource, then Ivalua |
Subcontractor on ITAR programs | LightSource, then JAGGAER |
Prime replacing its S2P suite | Ivalua, then LightSource |
Contractor on Oracle | Oracle, then LightSource |
Contractor on SAP | SAP Ariba (NS2), then LightSource |
The honest exception is hosting. If your security team requires controlled unclassified information (CUI) to sit inside the sourcing application itself, in an environment with a FedRAMP authorization on record, start with Oracle Fusion Cloud (if you are eligible for Oracle Government Cloud) or Coupa Spend Management for Federal, both listed at the Moderate level, and ask Ivalua for the current status of its GovCloud offering. LightSource offers deployment on AWS GovCloud by request, but it does not claim FedRAMP authorization, so its usual pattern for CUI is to keep controlled files in the buyer's own environment and reference them from the part record.
How We Scored
We scored every platform, including our own, on seven criteria. The weights reflect where defense sourcing risk and time actually go: most of the risk sits in who receives which file, and most of the time sits in getting part data into an RFQ and comparable quotes back out.
Criterion | Weight | Test |
|---|---|---|
Part-level access | 20% | Control which suppliers see each part and property |
BOM and revisions | 20% | RFQ from a BOM, re-quote one revision |
Quotes and award | 15% | Same cost breakdown, award scenarios |
Hosting evidence | 15% | Documented GovCloud or FedRAMP path |
Supplier controls | 10% | Collect attestations before award |
Supplier response | 10% | Small shops respond, pay nothing |
ERP and records | 10% | Award lands in the purchasing system |
We rate each capability with the vocabulary our comparison library uses: Native (documented and in the standard product), Configured (available, but set up per customer, per deployment or through a separate product), Marketed (claimed without public evidence of how it works) and Not documented (we could not find it, which is not the same as not offered). For hosting evidence, Native means an authorized package listed on the FedRAMP Marketplace, and Configured means a documented government cloud deployment without that listing. No rating in this guide is a security certification. A FedRAMP listing applies to a named package, not to every module or add-on a vendor sells, so ask for the boundary in writing.
The 9 Platforms at a Glance
Platform | Best fit |
|---|---|
1. LightSource | ITAR direct materials RFQs |
2. Ivalua | S2P suite on GovCloud |
3. Oracle Fusion | Contractors on Oracle |
4. JAGGAER | Multi-plant direct sourcing |
5. SAP Ariba (NS2) | SAP estates |
6. Coupa (Federal) | Finance-led spend control |
7. GEP | Software plus services |
8. Keelvar | Optimized multi-lot awards |
9. Arkestro | Repeat-buy price discovery |

Our ratings of nine platforms on this guide's seven criteria, as of September 2026. LightSource rates Native on part-level access, BOM and revisions, quotes and award, and supplier response, and Configured on hosting, supplier controls and ERP records. Source: LightSource assessment of public documentation, the FedRAMP Marketplace and public customer notices.
The 9 Platforms, Ranked
1. LightSource
What it is. LightSource is the AI-native direct materials operating system, spec through scale, PLM through ERP. Items are master data with specs, custom properties, revisions, drawings and files; BOMs are hierarchical, with snapshots and cost history, and a buyer can launch a sourcing project directly from a BOM or a batch of items.
Best for: defense and defense-tech manufacturers running direct materials RFQs on ITAR-controlled programs, from growth-stage hardware companies scaling production to divisions of larger primes, who want control over which suppliers see which parts without replacing their ERP or PLM.
Why it ranks first for this use. LightSource supports ITAR-controlled sourcing programs and has defense customers, whom we do not name. Buyers can restrict projects, items and RFI events to access groups and choose which item properties suppliers see, and an RFQ goes only to the suppliers invited to it. Line-item supplier filtering sets which suppliers see which items, so a supplier quoting a bracket does not see the controlled drawing on the next line. That mix of per-item and per-property visibility is why we rate part-level access Native, with a limit worth knowing: the controls apply per record rather than per file, and Data Rooms do not set per-file permissions, so files that need file-level separation belong on the buyer's own server. For CUI, buyers choose one of two patterns: upload the BOM and parts directly for controlled sharing with selected suppliers, or put a link to their own secure FTP server in the part metadata so controlled files never leave their environment. The second pattern is the same separation RTX documents for its own suppliers, with the bid in one system and the drawing in another, except the link lives on the part record, so the reference travels with the part and its revisions. Deployment on AWS GovCloud is available by request.
Quotes come back structured. Every supplier fills the same quote format, from unit price only to a full breakdown of raw materials, purchased items, machine and assembly processes, packaging, logistics and markups, in the app or through an Excel round-trip. When engineering revises a part, the buyer resends the RFQ, every version is preserved and suppliers see the new RFQ version, the buyer's message and the RFQ history. Award scenarios can be built by hand or generated from submitted quotes, split by volume or percentage, and routed for approval. Suppliers use LightSource free, which matters in a supply base where small shops already maintain accounts for several prime portals, Supplier Discovery searches by company name, process or material, and LightSource's supplier network includes more than 100,000 suppliers. LightSource states that it holds a SOC 2 Type 2 attestation and does not train foundation models on customer RFQ, RFI or contract data. It supports SAML single sign-on, and a team admin can require multi-factor authentication for members who sign in with email and password.
Watch-outs. LightSource does not claim FedRAMP authorization, CMMC certification or DFARS 252.204-7012 attestations, and it does not claim ITAR registration of its own; your export compliance team still decides what may be released to whom. If you upload CUI directly rather than linking to your own server, your security team should evaluate the GovCloud deployment against the cloud requirements in your contracts. The secure-FTP pattern keeps files out of the application, but part names, descriptions and properties in the RFQ can themselves be controlled, so decide which fields are safe before launch. LightSource does not issue purchase orders or invoices (an award creates an item contract, not a PO), does not run PPAP or first article workflows, has no built-in should-cost engine and connects to ERP and PLM through Excel Item Sync and a GraphQL API rather than certified prebuilt connectors. Supplier flow-down attestations can be collected through RFIs with an NDA round-trip and Data Rooms, but there is no clause-pack engine. The company came out of stealth in 2025.
Demo test: send one RFQ with three lines to three suppliers where each supplier may see only one line, and log in as each supplier to confirm what they can and cannot open. Then test the linked-file pattern over time: have one shop quote revision B through a link to your test file server, publish revision C on the server and resend. A second buyer should be able to tell from the RFQ history which revision each shop priced, without relying on what the link opens today, so put the revision in the link or the part record rather than pointing at a folder that changes.
Ratings: Part-level access Native; BOM and revisions Native; quotes and award Native; hosting evidence Configured; supplier controls Configured; supplier response Native; ERP and records Configured.
Pricing model: platform fee plus seats, implementation included; suppliers pay nothing.
LightSource is listed in The Hackett Group's Sourcing (for direct) Solutions guide as an "AI-native sourcing platform purpose-built for direct materials procurement," and was named a Gartner Cool Vendor in Sourcing and Procurement Technology (2025). Deployment typically takes about 30 days, with bespoke integration work scoped separately.
2. Ivalua
What it is. Ivalua is an organically built source-to-pay suite on a single codebase. The Hackett Group's direct sourcing guide calls it a "natively integrated, intuitive and flexible suite" with capabilities for all spend, including direct materials.
Best for: defense primes and large subcontractors that want to replace a whole S2P suite (supplier onboarding, risk, sourcing, contracts, POs and invoices) in a government cloud environment, and will invest in configuration.
Why it ranks here. In our reading of public records, Ivalua has the strongest defense references of the suites in this guide. BAE Systems, Inc. selected Ivalua for source-to-pay in March 2025. In February 2026 General Atomics picked Ivalua as its single system of record for supplier collaboration, with the deployment running on Ivalua's GovCloud offering, and GA's own supplier notice says Ivalua's quality and compliance features tailored to aerospace and defense were key differentiators. Ivalua has said its GovCloud offering achieved FedRAMP Ready status at the moderate impact level. If you need one platform that holds supplier qualification, sourcing and the purchasing record together, Ivalua is the better pick than LightSource.
Watch-outs. FedRAMP Ready is a readiness designation, not an authorization, and a customer's own environment statement does not transfer to your tenant; ask Ivalua for the current status and boundary of the package you would buy. Value from Ivalua depends on configuration skill and a strong implementation partner, and a suite rollout takes time; GA's notice told suppliers to keep using its previous tool until implementation was complete. In our evaluations, BOM sync is set up per customer rather than extracted from drawings and spreadsheets.
Demo test: have the implementation partner show a mixed RFQ where one supplier's approval expires mid-event, and record which steps need a configuration change rather than a buyer action.
Ratings: Part-level access Configured; BOM and revisions Configured; quotes and award Configured; hosting evidence Configured; supplier controls Native; supplier response Native; ERP and records Native.
Pricing model: custom-quoted subscription sized by modules and users, with implementation sold separately; suppliers quote free through the portal.
3. Oracle Fusion Cloud Procurement
What it is. Oracle's procurement applications on the same data model as Oracle financials, projects and manufacturing.
Best for: contractors already running Oracle Fusion ERP who want procurement inside a FedRAMP-authorized SaaS environment.
Why it ranks here. Oracle has the clearest public authorization record in this guide. The FedRAMP Marketplace lists Oracle Fusion Cloud (package F1603257882) as FedRAMP Certified at the Moderate level since January 13, 2020, and its service description includes procurement and project management. Oracle Government Cloud is a community cloud limited to agencies, select universities and federal contractors with a demonstrated need for FedRAMP authorization, so eligibility is the first question. For an eligible Oracle shop that needs purchasing, project cost and supplier records in one authorized environment, Oracle is the better pick.
Watch-outs. The product is P2P-first, and its sourcing events are general all-spend events rather than drawing- and revision-centric RFQs. Oracle's design-to-source capability sits in Fusion Cloud PLM, a separate entitlement, so ask which licenses a quote includes. Implementations are partner-led and ERP-class, and outside an Oracle estate most of the integration advantage goes away.
Demo test: ask for a list of every screen shown, the product that owns it, the license it requires, and whether that product sits inside the FedRAMP package you would buy.
Ratings: Part-level access Configured; BOM and revisions Configured; quotes and award Configured; hosting evidence Native; supplier controls Configured; supplier response Configured; ERP and records Native.
Pricing model: published per-hosted-named-user list price with a user minimum; contracted price set per order.
4. JAGGAER
What it is. A source-to-pay suite with the deepest direct materials heritage of the suites, through JAGGAER Direct (formerly POOL4TOOL).
Best for: multi-plant manufacturers that want direct sourcing with multi-tier BOMs inside one suite.
Why it ranks here. The Hackett Group's direct sourcing guide credits JAGGAER with "sophisticated direct materials sourcing capabilities." For a subcontractor whose biggest problem is BOM-driven sourcing across plants, JAGGAER is the suite most likely to fit.
Watch-outs. We could not find documented U.S. government cloud hosting or a CUI boundary for JAGGAER's commercial sourcing product, so plan on a separate secure channel for controlled drawings, as RTX does with its own sourcing application. Hackett's guide notes the suite was built over time through multiple acquisitions, so test how item, supplier and contract data move between modules. A recurring complaint among reviewers is rigidity.
Demo test: have a plant buyer add a field to a cost breakdown, run an event with it, and attach a drawing reference that points to your own secure file share rather than an upload.
Ratings: Part-level access Configured; BOM and revisions Native; quotes and award Native; hosting evidence Not documented; supplier controls Configured; supplier response Configured; ERP and records Configured.
Pricing model: custom-quoted by module and users; some public contracts add an annual spend threshold.
5. SAP Ariba (with SAP NS2)
What it is. SAP's source-to-pay suite, offered for regulated customers through SAP National Security Services (SAP NS2).
Best for: defense manufacturers standardized on SAP S/4HANA that want to keep the SAP Business Network and change how regulated data is hosted.
Why it ranks here. In September 2023, Google Cloud announced that SAP NS2 had achieved ITAR compliance for SAP Ariba on Google Cloud with Assured Workloads. Native integration with SAP ERP means material masters and awarded pricing flow to S/4HANA without a separate integration project. Its RFx and auction engine is mature and widely deployed.
Watch-outs. An ITAR-compliant hosting announcement is not proof that every Ariba module, the supplier network and each extension sit inside the same boundary, so ask for the SKU-by-SKU scope. A recurring minority complaint among reviewers is a dated interface that needs extensive training for occasional users, and rollouts are partner-led. In our evaluations, sourcing events reference ERP material master rows rather than drawings, properties and revisions, and detailed cost breakdowns usually travel as an Excel attachment. Enterprise supplier accounts on SAP Business Network that cross published thresholds pay fees, a known friction for small machine shops.
Demo test: send a drawing-linked RFQ to a small supplier on a Standard account and confirm, from the supplier's side, which service hosts the file.
Ratings: Part-level access Configured; BOM and revisions Configured; quotes and award Configured; hosting evidence Configured; supplier controls Configured; supplier response Configured; ERP and records Native.
Pricing model: module subscriptions, price on request, plus integrator implementation; NS2 hosting is quoted separately.
See LightSource vs. SAP Ariba.
6. Coupa (Spend Management for Federal)
What it is. Coupa's P2P and spend management suite, with a federal edition.
Best for: finance-led organizations that want spend control, P2P and supplier onboarding in an authorized environment, with direct materials sourcing handled elsewhere.
Why it ranks here. The FedRAMP Marketplace lists Coupa Spend Management for Federal (package F1308202329) as FedRAMP Certified at the Moderate level since March 10, 2022. Coupa is the broadest P2P suite here, and its supplier portal is free for suppliers.
Watch-outs. The federal edition is built for agencies; confirm that a contractor can buy it and that the supplier portal and add-ons you need are inside the package. P2P and indirect spend are Coupa's center of gravity, and we could not find a documented BOM-led sourcing module. A manufacturer that already uses Coupa for orders and invoices can keep it and add a direct materials platform for engineered parts.
Demo test: ask which of the modules in your quote are inside package F1308202329 and which are commercial-only.
Ratings: Part-level access Configured; BOM and revisions Not documented; quotes and award Configured; hosting evidence Native; supplier controls Configured; supplier response Native; ERP and records Native.
Pricing model: custom quote by module and user count; integrator-led rollout.
7. GEP
What it is. An organically built suite (GEP SMART and QUANTUM) sold with consulting and managed services.
Best for: manufacturers that want should-cost modeling and sourcing services from the same provider.
Why it ranks here. The Hackett Group's direct sourcing guide credits GEP's suite with "cost and should-cost modeling" usable for direct and indirect spend. That is a built-in capability LightSource does not have; LightSource takes an uploaded should-cost and uses it as the bid baseline.
Watch-outs. We could not find a documented U.S. government cloud deployment or controlled-data boundary for GEP's sourcing product. Implementation and operation often come bundled with GEP services, and if services analysts will touch your drawings, their nationality and location become part of your export analysis.
Demo test: ask GEP to repeat its should-cost exercise on a fictitious part without a services analyst operating the screen, and to state where that analyst would sit.
Ratings: Part-level access Not documented; BOM and revisions Configured; quotes and award Native; hosting evidence Not documented; supplier controls Configured; supplier response Configured; ERP and records Configured.
Pricing model: custom quote-based enterprise subscription, often bundled with managed services.
See LightSource vs. GEP.
8. Keelvar
What it is. A sourcing optimization and automation platform for large, multi-lot events.
Best for: constrained awards across already-qualified suppliers, such as bundles, capacity limits or freight lanes. Suppliers bid free through invite-based accounts, online or in Excel.
Watch-outs. Keelvar's data is scoped to each sourcing event; it is not an item or BOM system of record, so drawings, revisions and part history live elsewhere. We could not find documented government cloud hosting.
Demo test: model a split award with a qualified-capacity cap on one supplier and see who builds the model.
Ratings: Part-level access Not documented; BOM and revisions Not documented; quotes and award Native; hosting evidence Not documented; supplier controls Not documented; supplier response Native; ERP and records Not documented.
Pricing model: quote-based enterprise subscription; no public price list.
9. Arkestro
What it is. A predictive price discovery and automated negotiation tool that runs alongside an existing suite.
Best for: repeat buys with useful price history.
Watch-outs. Arkestro does not hold items, drawings or cost breakdowns as a system of record, and a predicted price is not a should-cost. It is less useful for a sole-qualified source or a first article with no price history, which describes a lot of defense work. We could not find documented government cloud hosting.
Demo test: run a first-article RFQ with no history and ask what the model suggests.
Ratings: Part-level access Not documented; BOM and revisions Not documented; quotes and award Configured; hosting evidence Not documented; supplier controls Not documented; supplier response Not documented; ERP and records Configured.
Pricing model: platform subscription, not published.
Tools That Pair With Sourcing
Several tools defense buyers evaluate alongside sourcing software do a different job, and it helps to be clear about which.
Exostar runs defense collaboration services, including the sourcing application RTX's suppliers use. In RTX's design the sourcing application is deliberately kept free of export-controlled data, and drawings move through a separate gateway, so it is an example of a controlled two-channel workflow rather than a drawing vault.
Exiger (1Exiger) and Air (formerly Govini) sell to defense buyers but describe themselves in other terms. Exiger calls 1Exiger its "supply chain and third-party risk intelligence platform." Govini announced its new name, Air, in June 2026, and says its Enterprise Readiness platform "aligns development, production, delivery, and sustainment into one coordinated execution system." Neither is positioned as a tool for issuing RFQs and comparing competitive bids; use them for supplier risk and readiness analysis and feed the findings to the buyer making the award.
Cofactr is an electronics procurement and logistics platform that, according to SiliconANGLE's December 2024 coverage, runs entirely on AWS GovCloud and counts defense-tech companies Neros Labs and Nautilus Defense as customers. Choose it when the problem includes buying, receiving and kitting electronic components, not only collecting quotes on machined and fabricated parts.
Where Defense RFQs Go Wrong
The enforcement record shows that the risky moment is often the RFQ itself. In 2021 the State Department settled with Honeywell for a $13 million civil penalty, $5 million of it suspended for remedial compliance. Its charging letter describes supply-chain staff sending RFQs with part drawings to U.S. and foreign suppliers through a file exchange platform; Honeywell identified 71 ITAR-controlled drawings exported without authorization to Canada, Ireland, China and Taiwan. In August 2026 BAE Systems, Inc. agreed to a $36 million civil penalty, $18 million suspended, to settle 104 charged violations, including unauthorized exports of technical data to Canada, the UK and Germany and a retransfer of technical data to an unauthorized UK supplier. Both companies disclosed the violations voluntarily. Both cases centered on technical data sent abroad or to suppliers, not only on shipped hardware.
The cyber rules moved on a different track. The CMMC program rule was published October 15, 2024 and took effect December 16, 2024, and the acquisition rule published September 10, 2025 started Phase 1, with self-assessments, on November 10, 2025. Phase 2, which would have required third-party assessments for contractors handling CUI, had been scheduled to start November 10, 2026. On July 13, 2026 the Department of War suspended it and said it would keep enforcing NIST SP 800-171 Revision 2 through self-assessments and selected government-led assessments. DFARS 252.204-7012 did not change: cyber incidents must be reported within 72 hours of discovery, images preserved for at least 90 days after the report, and a cloud provider storing covered defense information must meet requirements equivalent to the FedRAMP Moderate baseline. A paused CMMC schedule is not a reason to loosen how drawings reach suppliers.

CMMC's third-party phase was suspended in July 2026, while State Department ITAR penalties in cases involving technical data grew from $13 million (Honeywell, 2021, over RFQ drawings sent to suppliers) to $36 million (BAE Systems, Inc., 2026, covering 104 charged violations, including technical data exports). Sources: Federal Register (2024, 2025), WilmerHale (July 2026), State Department charging letter and ClearanceJobs (2021), Global Sanctions (August 2026).
The supply base adds a second pressure. GAO found that the number of small businesses receiving DoD contract awards fell from 42,723 in 2011 to 24,296 in 2020, a 43 percent decline, and DoD's 2022 competition report notes that aerospace and defense prime contractors consolidated from 51 to 5 during the 1990s. Fewer suppliers means more sole and dual sources, and visibility below tier two is thin: as of April 2025, DoD's SCREEn effort had first- and second-tier country-of-origin data for 30,000 of about 40,000 F-35 parts, but origin data on less than 10 percent of the suppliers providing components and raw materials for those parts. In 2022, F-35 deliveries were halted when a magnet in a Honeywell turbomachine turned out to use a Chinese-origin alloy from what Lockheed called a fifth-tier supplier. A U.S. address on a tier-one quote says little about where the metal was melted. We cover the regulatory basics in ITAR explained and the cultural shift for buyers moving from automotive in from automotive to aerospace.
What It Costs
Almost no vendor in this category publishes a price list, and defense adds cost lines a commercial quote leaves out.
Cost line | Ask |
|---|---|
Separate U.S. tenant | Included or extra? |
Implementation | Who, and how long? |
ERP and PLM work | Fixed or hourly? |
Supplier fees | Any, at any threshold? |
AI features | Inside the boundary? |
The suites generally price by module and user count, with implementation as a separate integrator contract and government cloud hosting priced as its own line. LightSource's model is a platform fee plus seats with implementation included, and suppliers never pay; GovCloud deployment is available by request and should be scoped in the same quote. Supplier fees matter more in defense than elsewhere because many machine shops already carry accounts for several prime portals, and a fee or a heavy onboarding burden pushes them back to email. Ask every finalist for the same three-year scenario: buyer seats, external suppliers, a separate U.S. tenant if you need one, implementation, ERP and PLM integration, data export and exit. Where it applies, ask for two prices, one with controlled files inside the application and one with files held on your own server.
Keep the incumbent in the comparison. If your current suite can already release the right revision to the right supplier, return a comparable quote and reconstruct the award under the same access rules, a second tool has to save enough buyer time to cover another supplier login, another offboarding step and the reconciliation between them. A free supplier license does not make that cost zero.
A Controlled-Data Pilot Checklist
The fastest way to compare these platforms is to run one real commodity through two of them for 30 days with fictitious part numbers and markings. The test below is built so that no vendor, including LightSource, can pass it with a slide.
Write down your data rules first. List which fields are safe in the sourcing tool (part number, quantity, material family) and which must stay in your controlled environment (drawings, specs, sometimes descriptions). Your export compliance lead signs off on the list before any vendor sees it.
Load a 30-line BOM with one ITAR-controlled drawing referenced by a secure link and one uploaded item visible only to named suppliers. Record the time until items carry specs, files and quantities.
Send a mixed RFQ to five suppliers where each may quote only some lines. Give one supplier two sites and two users with different approvals, and log in as each user to screenshot what they can open, including email previews and reminders. A U.S. mailing address is not evidence that a given person is eligible to receive the file.
Test the return trip. Have a supplier try to send back a marked-up copy of the controlled drawing with its quote, then try again through supplier Q&A and a help request. Outbound controls mean little if controlled content comes back into the commercial bid, so agree the approved route for technical questions before the event.
Change the team mid-event. Let a supplier add an estimator who may help with pricing but is not approved for the drawing, then remove another estimator before a resend. Check each person's portal view, email and file-server access separately, and what happens to copies already downloaded.
Collect flow-down evidence before award: NIST SP 800-171 self-assessment status where CUI is involved, NDA and the clauses the subcontract will carry. Then move the work to a different supplier site after price approval and see which approvals have to repeat. See supplier qualification.
Push a revision to one part and re-quote only that line; check that the first round is preserved and that no one can award against the stale revision. Our engineering change order entry covers the vocabulary.
Compare quotes in one cost breakdown (material, conversion, overhead and margin, tooling, logistics) and build a single-source and a split-award scenario, since many defense parts have only one or two qualified sources.
Run the incident clock. Assume a reportable cyber incident is discovered at 9 a.m. on a Monday. Under DFARS 252.204-7012 the report is due by 9 a.m. Thursday, and if it is filed Tuesday the 90-day preservation period for images and monitoring data runs from Tuesday. Name who at each vendor notifies you and who can retrieve the evidence.
Export the award to an ERP test environment with supplier, part ID, revision, price and effective date, and write down four dates: contract signature, first live RFQ, first award loaded into the ERP, and first program fully on the new tool.
How We Ranked
LightSource wrote this guide, and LightSource is on the list. To keep it useful we scored every platform, including our own, on the same seven criteria a defense direct materials team actually uses: part-level access, BOM and revisions, quotes and award, hosting evidence, supplier controls, supplier response, and ERP and records. The weights are stated in the "How We Scored" section. To total them, a Native rating earns the full weight, Configured earns 60 percent, and Marketed or Not documented earn nothing until demonstrated. On that basis the platforms score: LightSource 86, Ivalua 72, Oracle 70, JAGGAER 65, SAP Ariba 64, Coupa 62, GEP 45, Keelvar 25 and Arkestro 15, out of 100. Capability notes come from public documentation, the FedRAMP Marketplace, public customer notices, public buyer reviews and our own evaluations as of September 2026; where we could not find a capability documented we say "not documented", which is not the same as "not offered". The suites on this list do things LightSource does not: purchase orders, invoicing, indirect spend, auctions, contract management and, for Oracle and Coupa, a FedRAMP-authorized package on record. If you need those, say so in your evaluation and weigh them.
LightSource ranks first because it rates Native on part-level access, BOM and revisions, quotes and award, and supplier response, which carry 65 percent of the weight, while conceding hosting evidence, purchase orders and quality workflows. Ivalua ranks second on its defense references and GovCloud offering, and Oracle third on its authorization record. JAGGAER, SAP Ariba, Coupa and GEP follow on the balance of direct depth and documented hosting. Keelvar and Arkestro are strong at what they do but are not systems of record for parts. We state analyst listings as facts; inclusion in a Hackett guide is not a recommendation of LightSource.
For the broader market, including platforms outside defense, see our guide to the best direct materials procurement software in 2026, and for the data groundwork, our colleague Mason Morgan on mastering BOM data.
Update log. Published September 24, 2026. Last reviewed September 24, 2026.
Sources
Exostar's RTX Sourcing Supplier RFQ Training -- RTX, Aug. 1, 2023: no export-controlled data in the sourcing application; drawings sent via RTX Secure Messenger Gateway
Proposed charging letter, Honeywell International Inc. -- U.S. Department of State, DDTC, 2021: RFQ drawings sent through a file exchange platform; 71 ITAR-controlled drawings
Honeywell agrees to pay millions for sending controlled arms information abroad -- ClearanceJobs, May 5, 2021: $13 million penalty, $5 million suspended
BAE Systems' US subsidiary agrees $36 million ITAR settlement -- Global Sanctions, Aug. 17, 2026
DFARS 252.204-7012 -- Acquisition.gov: 72-hour reporting, 90-day preservation, FedRAMP Moderate equivalence for cloud providers
CMMC program final rule -- Federal Register, Oct. 15, 2024
CMMC acquisition final rule -- Federal Register, Sept. 10, 2025
Pentagon suspends CMMC Phase 2 requirements -- WilmerHale, July 20, 2026
What the CMMC pause means for the defense industrial base -- CSIS, July 29, 2026
Oracle Fusion Cloud, FedRAMP Marketplace -- GSA FedRAMP: Moderate, certified Jan. 13, 2020; Oracle Government Cloud eligibility
Coupa Spend Management for Federal, FedRAMP Marketplace -- GSA FedRAMP: Moderate, certified Mar. 10, 2022
SAP NS2 achieves ITAR compliance for SAP Ariba with Google Cloud -- Google Cloud, Sept. 19, 2023
General Atomics picks Ivalua to centralize supplier collaboration on GovCloud -- TechInformed, Feb. 5, 2026
GA selects Ivalua platform -- General Atomics supplier notice
BAE Systems selects Ivalua to streamline S2P processes -- ADS Group, Mar. 19, 2025
Sourcing (for direct) Solutions -- The Hackett Group Solution Intelligence (formerly Spend Matters), Sept. 22, 2026: vendor entries for LightSource, Ivalua, JAGGAER and GEP
Cofactr secures $17.2M to expand supply chain tools for high-compliance industries -- SiliconANGLE, Dec. 12, 2024
Exiger launches supply chain AI platform in AWS Marketplace -- Exiger press release, Mar. 17, 2026: 1Exiger described as its "supply chain and third-party risk intelligence platform"
Govini declares "Readiness Gap" a national security crisis -- Air (formerly Govini) via PR Newswire, June 16, 2026
Small Business Contracting: Actions Needed to Implement and Monitor DOD's Small Business Strategy -- GAO-22-104621, Oct. 14, 2021: small businesses receiving DoD awards fell 43 percent, 2011 to 2020
State of Competition Within the Defense Industrial Base -- Department of Defense, Feb. 2022: prime contractors consolidated from 51 to 5 in the 1990s
Defense Industrial Base: Actions Needed to Address Risks Posed by Dependence on Foreign Suppliers -- GAO-25-107283, July 24, 2025: F-35 country-of-origin data
DoD inks waiver for deliveries of F-35s halted over Chinese material -- Defense News, Oct. 7, 2022
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best procurement software for ITAR-controlled RFQs?
For direct materials RFQs on ITAR programs, LightSource ranks first in this guide because buyers can restrict projects and items to access groups, choose which suppliers see each item and which item properties they see, and keep controlled drawings on their own secure server, linked from the part record. If CUI must live inside a FedRAMP-authorized environment, look first at Oracle Fusion Cloud (for eligible contractors) or Coupa Spend Management for Federal, both listed at Moderate, and ask Ivalua for the current status of its GovCloud offering. No software makes a release decision for you; your export compliance team still does.
Can we use a commercial sourcing tool if the ITAR drawings stay in our own secure portal?
Yes, and at least one large prime works this way: RTX keeps export-controlled data out of its Exostar-hosted sourcing application and sends drawings through a separate gateway. Two details decide whether it works. Part names, descriptions and properties can themselves be controlled, so decide which fields are allowed in the sourcing tool before you launch. And controlled content can come back the other way, as a marked-up drawing or screenshot attached to a quote or a supplier question, so agree the approved route for technical replies before the RFQ goes out.
Is LightSource FedRAMP authorized or CMMC certified?
No. LightSource does not claim FedRAMP authorization, CMMC certification or DFARS 252.204-7012 attestations. It supports ITAR-controlled sourcing programs, offers deployment on AWS GovCloud by request, states that it holds a SOC 2 Type 2 attestation and supports two CUI patterns: controlled direct upload to selected suppliers, or a link to the buyer's own secure FTP server in the part metadata.
Which procurement platforms are FedRAMP authorized?
On the FedRAMP Marketplace, Oracle Fusion Cloud is listed at Moderate since January 2020 and Coupa Spend Management for Federal at Moderate since March 2022. SAP NS2 announced ITAR compliance for SAP Ariba on Google Cloud in 2023, and Ivalua has said its GovCloud offering reached FedRAMP Ready at the moderate level. A listing covers a named package, so ask each vendor which modules, supplier portals and AI features sit inside it.
Will CMMC Phase 2 start on November 10, 2026?
Not as scheduled. Phase 2 was set to begin November 10, 2026, but the Department of War suspended it on July 13, 2026 and said it would keep enforcing NIST SP 800-171 Revision 2 through self-assessments and selected government-led assessments. DFARS 252.204-7012 still applies, including 72-hour incident reporting. Check each solicitation and subcontract for the clauses that actually apply.
What should we require from a machine shop before awarding defense work?
Collect the evidence the subcontract will require before award: the supplier's NIST SP 800-171 self-assessment status where CUI is involved, an NDA, export authorization for any technical data you will release, and the flow-down clauses the work triggers. Record it where buyers can see it next to the quote, and re-check it when the scope of work changes. Keep the bar proportionate; a commercial off-the-shelf purchase does not need the same pack as a CUI subcontract.
How do we stop an old revision from being awarded?
Use software that ties every quote to a part revision and preserves each RFQ round. In LightSource, when engineering revises a part the buyer resends the RFQ, every version is preserved, suppliers see the new RFQ version, the buyer's message and the RFQ history, and revisions can be compared side by side. If drawings are linked from your own file server, make the link point to a specific revision rather than a folder that changes, so the quote history still shows what each supplier priced after revision C replaces B. In any pilot, deliberately try to award against the stale revision and see what the tool does.
How much does defense procurement software cost?
Few vendors publish prices. Suites are typically custom-quoted by module and user count, with implementation and government cloud hosting as separate lines; LightSource charges a platform fee plus seats with implementation included, and suppliers pay nothing. Ask every finalist for the same three-year scenario including a separate U.S. tenant, integration, supplier fees and exit.
Are Exiger and Govini sourcing tools?
No. Exiger describes 1Exiger as a "supply chain and third-party risk intelligence platform," and Air (formerly Govini) describes its Enterprise Readiness platform as "one coordinated execution system" for defense development, production, delivery and sustainment. Neither is positioned for running competitive RFQs or comparing bids, so defense manufacturers that use them typically do so alongside a sourcing tool and feed their findings to the buyer making the award.
Faster sourcing,
lower cost, less chaos.
See how LightSource connects engineering, procurement, and suppliers in one operating system to help you launch faster at lower cost.
DPW Award Winner
SOC 2
Hackett Group 2026 Validated
Kearney #1
Gartner Cool Vendor
Procuretech 100
G2 Top Rated
Faster sourcing,
lower cost, less chaos.
See how LightSource connects engineering, procurement, and suppliers in one operating system to help you launch faster at lower cost.
DPW Award Winner
SOC 2
Hackett Group 2026 Validated
Kearney #1
Gartner Cool Vendor
Procuretech 100
G2 Top Rated
Faster sourcing,
lower cost, less chaos.
See how LightSource connects engineering, procurement, and suppliers in one operating system to help you launch faster at lower cost.
DPW Award Winner
SOC 2
Hackett Group 2026 Validated
Kearney #1
Gartner Cool Vendor
Procuretech 100
G2 Top Rated
Trusted by:
Trusted by:
Trusted by:




