Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared

LightSource Team

The LightSource logo on a highlighted card surrounded by logos of JAGGAER, SAP, Ivalua, GEP, Coupa, Oracle, Keelvar, Arkestro, Tacto, Fairmarkit and Zip

Direct materials procurement software is the system a manufacturer uses to source the parts and raw materials that go into its products: it turns a bill of materials into line-item RFQs, collects supplier quotes in a comparable cost breakdown, and carries the award back to the part record. Procure-to-pay (P2P) software handles what happens after the sourcing decision (purchase orders, receipts, invoices). Source-to-pay (S2P) suites try to cover both, for every kind of spend.

That distinction matters because most of the "best procurement software for manufacturing" lists in circulation rank S2P and P2P suites on suite breadth. This guide ranks twelve platforms on what a direct materials team does every week: building RFQs from a BOM, getting quotes back in a format that can be compared line by line, re-quoting when engineering changes a revision, and getting suppliers to respond at all. LightSource publishes this guide and ranks its own product first on those criteria; the disclosure, the weights and the places where LightSource falls short are all stated below.

The Short Answer

Sourcing tools have not changed much conceptually in two decades, and most direct materials teams still finish the real analysis in Excel and email. The Hackett Group's 2026 guide to direct sourcing tools describes the average tool as building an RFx from a BOM that carries only a part number, a description and a quantity, and automating little beyond supplier invitations and bid acceptance. That is the gap a direct materials platform has to close. Our verdict by manufacturer type, as of October 2026:

Buyer

Shortlist

Automotive tier 1

LightSource, then JAGGAER

EV or hardware startup

LightSource, then Tacto (DACH)

Build-to-order OEM

LightSource, then Ivalua

Enterprise on SAP

SAP Ariba, then LightSource

The reasons differ by row. Tier 1 suppliers live on BOM-driven RFQs with cost breakdowns; EV and hardware startups need to be live in weeks with suppliers who pay nothing; build-to-order OEMs re-quote constantly as revisions change; and enterprises on SAP often value one vendor for all spend above depth in any one category.

Two rows deserve a caveat. For an automotive tier 1 whose PPAP and APQP workflows must live in the same application as sourcing, start with JAGGAER, because LightSource does not run those quality processes; if a separate quality system already owns them, LightSource is the stronger sourcing tool. The enterprise-on-SAP row is the other honest exception. If the requirement is one vendor for direct, indirect, purchase orders and invoices on S/4HANA, SAP Ariba is the natural choice, and a direct specialist like LightSource is something you would add for the engineering-heavy categories rather than a replacement for the suite.

How We Scored

We scored every platform, including our own, on eight criteria. The weights reflect where direct materials sourcing time actually goes: most of it is spent getting part data into an RFQ and getting comparable quotes back out.

Criterion

Weight

Test

BOM and item data

20%

RFQ built from a spec-aware item record

Quote breakdowns

20%

Every supplier fills the same cost structure

Bid analysis and award

15%

Line-level comparison, award scenarios

Revisions and NPI

10%

Re-quote changed parts, keep history

Supplier participation

10%

Free, low-friction supplier response

ERP and PLM fit

10%

Documented, supportable integration path

Time to go live

10%

First live RFQ in weeks, not quarters

Pricing model

5%

Stated model, no surprise fees

The criteria follow the capability sets The Hackett Group uses to define the category: its Sourcing (for direct) Solutions guide treats BoM management integrated with PLM and ERP, cost analysis and cost-driver identification, NPD and NPI collaboration, and predictive cost analytics as what separates direct sourcing tools from general sourcing tools. We rate each capability with the vocabulary our comparison library uses: Native (documented and in the standard product), Configured (available, but set up per customer or through an integration project), Marketed (claimed on the vendor's site without public evidence of how it works) and Not documented (we could not find it, which is not the same as not offered).

The 12 Platforms at a Glance

Platform (direct depth)

Best fit

1. LightSource (Core)

BOM-led sourcing, NPI to production

2. JAGGAER (Module)

Multi-plant S2P with direct

3. SAP Ariba (Module)

S/4HANA shops wanting one vendor

4. Ivalua (Module)

Teams that will configure deeply

5. GEP (Module)

Software plus managed services

6. Coupa (None)

Indirect and P2P at scale

7. Oracle Fusion (Module)

Oracle ERP shops

8. Keelvar (None)

Large optimized tenders

9. Arkestro (None)

Predictive price discovery

10. Tacto (Core)

DACH industrial mid-market

11. Fairmarkit (None)

Tail spend and tactical buys

12. Zip (None)

Intake and approvals

The main limit of each, in one line: LightSource does no P2P, invoicing or indirect spend; JAGGAER's acquired modules and rigidity draw buyer complaints; SAP Ariba needs a partner-led rollout and training for occasional users; Ivalua depends on configuration skill and a strong partner; GEP's newest features require a move to QUANTUM; Coupa's center of gravity is not direct materials; Oracle's sourcing events are generic and P2P-first; Keelvar and Fairmarkit hold no item master; Arkestro has no documented BOM or cost-breakdown model; Tacto has thin public evidence outside DACH; and Zip's documented scope stops short of parts and BOMs.

"Direct" is our assessment of how central direct materials sourcing is to the product: Core (the product is built around parts and BOMs), Module (an identifiable part of an all-spend suite supports BOM-led sourcing) or None (no comparable BOM-led module is documented). None does not mean a platform cannot buy direct spend, and Core does not guarantee a high rank: Tacto is a direct specialist that ranks tenth because its documented strengths are supplier and cost intelligence rather than RFQs and awards. The designed version below adds a rating per criterion.


Rating table of 12 direct materials procurement platforms across BOM data, quote breakdowns, bid analysis and award, revisions, supplier participation, ERP and PLM fit, time to go live, pricing model and direct depth
Our ratings of the 12 platforms on this guide's criteria, as of October 2026. LightSource rates Native on BOM and item data, quote breakdowns, bid analysis and award, revisions and supplier participation, and Configured on ERP and PLM fit. Source: LightSource assessment of public documentation, public reviews and The Hackett Group's Sourcing (for direct) Solutions guide.

The 12 Platforms, Ranked

1. LightSource

Best for: manufacturers whose purchasing starts from an engineered product, from growth-stage hardware companies to Global 2000 divisions with large direct spend, who want to move sourcing out of Excel and email without replacing their ERP or PLM.

Strengths. LightSource is the AI-native direct materials operating system, spec through scale, PLM through ERP. Items are master data with specs, custom properties, revisions, drawings and files, and BOMs are hierarchical, with snapshots, cost history across snapshots and a cost breakdown view. A buyer can launch a sourcing project directly from a BOM or a batch of items. Item Ingestion reads PDFs, Excel files, drawings and images and creates or updates items from them; it processed more than 3,300 items in its first month. The RFX Setup Agent builds the quote format from category intelligence and past templates, which LightSource's documentation describes as cutting about two weeks of setup to about 15 minutes.

Quotes come back structured. Buyers pick or build a quote format (Unit Price Only, Simple Breakdown with material, conversion, SG&A, margin, packaging and logistics, or Full Breakdown down to machine process, cycle time and machine rate), and every supplier fills the same structure in the app or through an Excel round-trip. Bid comparison shows the delta to baseline, item, tooling and ED&T views, a cost walk across resubmissions, and an AI comparison that explains in plain language how two quotes differ. Award scenarios can be built by hand or generated from submitted quotes, split by volume or percentage, and routed for approval. When engineering revises a part, the buyer resends the RFQ, every version is preserved, and suppliers see what changed.

Suppliers use LightSource free. Supplier Discovery searches a network of more than 100,000 suppliers by name, industry or capability, and suppliers already on the platform or new to it are invited from the RFQ email, get automatic reminders, and Supplier Activation answers common supplier questions and nudges non-responders. At Blue Bird, the school bus maker, buyers ran 38 percent more RFQs per person with the same team, average sourcing cycle time fell from 16 to 14 days, and 398 supplier companies were onboarded with 99.7 percent of them active, according to the published case study. Other customers include Arxada, Aramsco, Time Manufacturing, BRP, Canada Goose, Yum! Brands and Zebra. LightSource holds a SOC 2 Type 2 attestation, supports SAML single sign-on with enforced MFA, and does not train foundation models on customer RFQ or contract data.

Limits. LightSource does not do purchase orders, invoicing, indirect or tail spend, reverse auctions, contract lifecycle management or spend analytics; an award creates an item contract, not a PO. Should-cost models are requested from a third party or uploaded and then used as the bid baseline, so there is no built-in should-cost engine. Post-award quality workflows such as PPAP and APQP tracking are not part of the product. Integration runs through Excel Item Sync (with a PLM and database sync template) and a GraphQL API with team-scoped keys; LightSource connects to the PLM and ERP systems its customers run through those paths rather than through certified prebuilt connectors. The company came out of stealth in 2025, so it does not have a multi-decade track record.

Pricing model: platform fee plus seats, implementation included; suppliers pay nothing.

Direct depth: Core. LightSource is listed in The Hackett Group's Sourcing (for direct) Solutions guide, which describes it as an "AI-native sourcing platform purpose-built for direct materials procurement." Recognition includes Gartner Cool Vendor in Sourcing and Procurement Technology (2025), ProcureTech100 (2025/26), The Hackett Group 50 to Watch (2025-2026) and a debut in the Spend Matters Fall 2025 SolutionMap in both the Sourcing and Direct Sourcing categories. Deployment typically takes about 30 days, with no rip-and-replace of ERP or PLM; bespoke integration work is scoped separately. Read our head-to-head pages for detail: LightSource vs. JAGGAER, vs. SAP Ariba and vs. Ivalua.

2. JAGGAER

Best for: large, multi-plant manufacturers that want one S2P suite with real direct materials heritage and have the administrative staff to run it.

Strengths. Sourcing is JAGGAER's strongest area, including direct materials sourcing and optimization. Its direct offering, JAGGAER Direct, descends from POOL4TOOL, which JAGGAER combined with in 2017 to add direct procurement, and it supports multi-tier BOMs with alternates and engineering change workflows for large manufacturers. The optimization engine traces to the 2013 CombineNet acquisition. In September 2026 JAGGAER closed its acquisition of Ivoflow, which compares a manufacturer's ERP purchasing data with commodity and currency inputs, adding direct materials price intelligence. JAGGAER also markets a large catalog of prebuilt ERP connectors. The Hackett Group's direct sourcing guide credits it with "sophisticated direct materials sourcing capabilities."

Limits. The same Hackett entry notes that the suite was built over time through multiple acquisitions: SciQuest (founded 1995), Upside Software and CombineNet (2012 and 2013), POOL4TOOL and BravoSolution (2017). In our evaluations, buyers should test how item, supplier and contract data move between modules. A recurring complaint among reviewers is rigidity, with limited conditional logic in forms and settings that need re-checking after releases, and some manufacturing users describe the direct offering as rich but demanding, with a risk of over-customization. JAGGAER's own implementation guidance runs to months per module. In our assessment, BOM import exists but sits on an enterprise S2P rollout rather than starting from AI ingestion of drawings and spreadsheets.

Demo test: have a plant buyer add a field to a cost breakdown, run an event with it, and check that it survives the next release.

Pricing model: custom-quoted subscription by module and user band; public-sector schedules show annual module fees by user count.

Direct depth: Module, and the deepest of the suites. See LightSource vs. JAGGAER.

3. SAP Ariba

Best for: enterprises standardized on SAP S/4HANA that want one vendor for every spend type and accept a partner-led rollout.

Strengths. Direct procurement is a credited strength of the suite, and SAP Ariba's largest assets are native integration with SAP ERP (material masters and awarded pricing flow to S/4HANA) and the SAP Business Network of suppliers. The Hackett Group's S2P guide points to its "strong integration with SAP ERP environments." Its RFx and auction engine is mature and widely deployed. In March 2026 SAP announced the next-generation Ariba applications rebuilt on SAP Business Technology Platform, rolling out incrementally through 2026 and 2027.

Limits. Ariba's architecture predates SAP's ownership (SAP completed the acquisition in 2012; Ariba had bought FreeMarkets in 2004), and SAP's own 2026 platform work is aimed at modernizing it. A recurring minority complaint among reviewers is a dated interface that needs extensive training for occasional users. Rollouts are partner-led, so ask who owns the outcome. Some reviewers report that customers on non-SAP ERPs feel sidelined. In our evaluations, as of October 2026, sourcing events reference ERP material master rows rather than drawings, properties and revisions, and detailed cost breakdowns usually travel as an Excel attachment. On the supplier side, Standard accounts on SAP Business Network are free, while Enterprise accounts that cross SAP's published document and value thresholds pay transaction and subscription fees, a known friction for small machine shops.

Demo test: ask to see the version of the sourcing application your plants would actually receive during SAP's phased modernization, carrying a drawing and revision into an RFQ.

Pricing model: module subscriptions, price on request; sourcing is priced by user on public-sector schedules, plus integrator implementation.

Direct depth: Module. See LightSource vs. SAP Ariba.

4. Ivalua

Best for: complex, regulated enterprises that want a deeply configurable suite and will invest in configuration and a strong implementation partner.

Strengths. Ivalua is organically built on a single codebase, which sets it apart from the acquisition-assembled suites; The Hackett Group calls it a "natively integrated, intuitive and flexible suite" with capabilities for all spend, including direct materials. Sourcing is its strongest area, with every RFx type, auctions and optimization, and it supports BOM-driven sourcing events through ERP and PLM interfaces. In August 2026 Deloitte announced an alliance with Ivalua covering direct and indirect source-to-pay.

Limits. Buyers report that getting value from Ivalua takes data-model expertise and configuration time, and partner choice matters more than usual: some manufacturers report that customizations caused upgrade friction. Some describe the direct procurement module and its integrations as still maturing, and some reviewers find the interface dated and the item grid confusing. In our evaluations, BOM sync is set up per customer rather than extracted from files.

Demo test: ask a buyer to add a tooling-life field, send it to suppliers and show it to the award approver, and record which steps need the implementation partner.

Pricing model: custom-quoted subscription sized by modules and users, with implementation sold separately; suppliers quote free through the portal.

Direct depth: Module. See LightSource vs. Ivalua.

5. GEP

Best for: enterprises that want software and managed procurement services from one provider.

Strengths. GEP is also organically built, and direct materials sourcing and complex industry requirements are a long-standing strength. The Hackett Group's direct sourcing guide credits its suite with "cost and should-cost modeling, opportunity identification and sourcing execution" usable for direct and indirect spend, backed by services and BPO. The interface on its QUANTUM platform is credited by reviewers, and GEP sells consulting and managed services that some buyers want.

Limits. GEP's newest capabilities live on QUANTUM, and existing SMART customers face a migration to get them. A recurring minority complaint among reviewers, mostly on the earlier platform, is a sluggish interface and workflow changes that need a support ticket. Buyers also report custom work for ERP integration. Implementation and operation often come bundled with GEP services, so ask what the software does on its own.

Demo test: ask GEP to repeat its should-cost exercise on your part without a services analyst operating the screen.

Pricing model: custom quote-based enterprise subscription, often in the same relationship as managed services.

Direct depth: Module. GEP is the one suite on this list with a credited should-cost module, which LightSource does not have; if building an independent should-cost model inside the software is mandatory, GEP belongs on the shortlist ahead of LightSource. See LightSource vs. GEP.

6. Coupa

Best for: companies running indirect spend and procure-to-pay at scale that want broad spend visibility and community benchmarking.

Strengths. Coupa is the broadest P2P and indirect procurement suite on this list. Its sourcing optimization engine came from the 2017 Trade Extensions acquisition and runs very large events. The Hackett Group credits a "user-friendly interface, automated sourcing processes" and community intelligence. Coupa does run direct materials for some manufacturers: Kimberly-Clark told its suppliers in August 2026 that a direct-material workflow covering sourcing prices, POs and line acknowledgements had gone live in mainland China and Hong Kong. In May 2026 Coupa acquired Tonkean for intake and orchestration.

Limits. P2P and indirect are Coupa's center of gravity, and some manufacturing buyers report gaps bringing direct spend onto the platform. Coupa sells one configurable product and does not build customer-specific features, so a BOM-driven RFQ with a custom cost breakdown has to fit the standard event model. A recurring minority complaint among reviewers is complexity for occasional users and administrators. Coupa has grown by acquisition in optimization, risk, contracts, supply chain design and now intake, so test how those modules share data. Leadership changed in August 2026, when Mike Lipps became interim CEO.

Pricing model: custom quote by module and user count; integrator-led rollout. Suppliers use the Coupa Supplier Portal free, with optional paid supplier subscriptions.

Direct depth: None under this guide's BOM-module definition, although Coupa can and does buy direct spend. A manufacturer happy with Coupa for P2P can keep it for orders and invoices and add a direct materials platform for engineered categories. See LightSource vs. Coupa and Spencer Penn's longer LightSource vs. Coupa post.

7. Oracle Fusion Cloud Procurement

Best for: companies already on Oracle Fusion ERP that want procurement on the same data model.

Strengths. Oracle Fusion Procurement shares one data model with Oracle's financials and PLM, which makes ERP integration native for Oracle shops. It covers line-level RFQ, RFI and auction events with two-stage RFQs and price tiers, and P2P and contracts are strong. Oracle publishes a per-user list price, which is rare in this category.

Limits. The product is P2P-first, and its sourcing events are generic all-spend events rather than drawing- and revision-centric RFQs. Oracle's design-to-source capability sits in Fusion Cloud PLM, a separate entitlement, so ask which licenses a quote includes. Implementations are partner-led and ERP-class. Outside an Oracle estate, most of the integration advantage goes away. A useful demo request is a list of every screen shown, the product that owns it and the license it requires.

Pricing model: published per-hosted-named-user list price with a user minimum; contracted price set per order.

Direct depth: Module. See LightSource vs. Oracle.

8. Keelvar

Best for: large, complex tender events, especially logistics and freight, where award optimization is the main problem.

Strengths. Keelvar combines advanced sourcing optimization with sourcing automation bots, runs events with thousands of lines and hundreds of bidders, and gives suppliers free, invite-based bidder accounts with online or Excel bidding. The Hackett Group lists it in its direct sourcing guide alongside its general and optimization guides, describing optimization and automation capabilities.

Limits. Keelvar's data is scoped to each sourcing event. It is not an item or BOM system of record, so drawings, revisions and part history live elsewhere. Complex optimization models often lean on vendor analysts.

Pricing model: quote-based enterprise subscription; contractual limits can be set by events, users or spend.

Direct depth: None documented as a system of record. See LightSource vs. Keelvar.

9. Arkestro

Best for: teams that want predictive price discovery and automated negotiation across many categories, running alongside an existing suite.

Strengths. Arkestro suggests prices to suppliers using machine learning and behavioral science, runs multi-round events with live ranking feedback, and sells into automotive and manufacturing among other verticals. It is designed to sit next to Coupa, SAP Ariba and the ERP.

Limits. Arkestro does not hold items, drawings or cost breakdowns as a system of record, and The Hackett Group lists it in its general sourcing and spend analytics guides but not in the direct sourcing guide. A predicted price is not a should-cost: it tells you what a supplier might accept, not what the part should cost to make.

Pricing model: platform subscription, not published.

Direct depth: None documented. See LightSource vs. Arkestro.

10. Tacto

Best for: industrial mid-market manufacturers in Germany, Austria and Switzerland that want AI-assisted supplier and cost intelligence.

Strengths. Tacto targets industrial manufacturers directly, combining supplier, cost, sourcing and compliance modules, and it is quick to implement according to its public reviewers. It raised a €50 million round led by Sequoia and Index in December 2023.

Limits. Public evidence is thin: Tacto has few public reviews and no major analyst coverage we could find as of October 2026, and part-line RFQ depth and drawing-packet handling are not publicly demonstrated. Its footprint is regional, and connecting ERP data is onboarding work.

Pricing model: not published; demo-led annual subscription.

Direct depth: Core, by positioning; depth not publicly verified. See LightSource vs. Tacto.

11. Fairmarkit

Best for: high-volume, low-dollar tail spend and tactical buys where speed matters more than engineering detail.

Strengths. Fairmarkit automates tactical sourcing events at volume, embeds in ERP and P2P systems such as Ariba, Coupa, Oracle and ServiceNow, and suppliers quote free. Coca-Cola Europacific Partners reported cutting project cycle time by more than half for tactical purchases under €250,000.

Limits. Fairmarkit has no item master: intake captures requisitions, not parts or drawings. BOM sourcing and cost breakdowns are not documented.

Pricing model: custom-quoted subscription; suppliers pay nothing to quote.

Direct depth: None. See LightSource vs. Fairmarkit.

12. Zip

Best for: companies that want one intake front door and approval orchestration across indirect spend.

Strengths. Zip has a modern architecture with little technical debt, strong intake, approvals and vendor onboarding, and deep integrations through its own iPaaS layer, which The Hackett Group singles out. In September 2026 it announced sourcing and PO agents.

Limits. Zip's documented objects are requests, vendors, POs, invoices and contracts; there is no item master, part or BOM concept, and its RFx is oriented to vendors and services rather than part lines with drawings. Direct materials sourcing is outside what it documents.

Pricing model: custom-quoted; marketplace data describes a platform fee plus per-seat pricing.

Direct depth: None. See LightSource vs. Zip.

Direct vs. Indirect Software

Direct materials become part of the finished product: castings, harnesses, resins, PCBAs, fasteners. Indirect spend keeps the company running: software, travel, facilities, services. The same item can be either. A cooling fan built into the product is a direct material, and a change to its connector, operating temperature or drawing revision can invalidate a quote even when the supplier, description and price look unchanged; the same fan bought to cool the maintenance office is an indirect purchase that nobody re-quotes when engineering changes a drawing. The two need different software because the unit of work is different. An indirect purchase is a request with a supplier and a price. A direct purchase is a part with a drawing, a revision, a material, a volume forecast and a cost structure that the supplier should be able to explain. We go deeper on the split in what's the difference between direct and indirect procurement.

Analysts treat the categories separately too. Direct Sourcing is one of the 16 categories in The Hackett Group's SolutionMap, separate from general Sourcing, and Hackett's sourcing guide names direct materials support as one of five axes on which sourcing tools materially differ. That is why a suite can be excellent at indirect and P2P while its direct module is the part buyers struggle to adopt. Hackett's first readiness signal for a dedicated direct tool is exactly that: low adoption of the current sourcing tool because it does not handle direct requirements.

In practice the failure shows up in data. When the RFQ line is free text with a part number, everything engineering knows about the part (material, finish, tolerances, revision) travels as an attachment, and the cost breakdown comes back as each supplier's own spreadsheet. Our colleague Mason Morgan wrote about what that costs in the sourcing bottleneck and about getting bill of materials data into shape first; our team has also written about why direct materials needs an operating system before AI can help.


Lollipop chart: 94 percent of procurement teams use a source-to-pay solution, 92 percent of CPOs plan to invest in generative AI, 37 percent are piloting or deploying it, and in a 2026 survey 75 percent are still experimenting while 5 percent report widespread adoption
Nearly every procurement team owns source-to-pay software (94 percent, PwC 2024), and 92 percent of CPOs plan to invest in generative AI (Deloitte 2024), yet only 5 percent report widespread adoption (EFESO 2026). The surveys cover different populations, and none measures how many direct materials RFQs run in software.

What It Costs by Company Size

Almost no vendor in this category publishes a price list, so the useful comparison is the pricing model and what sits outside the license.

Size

Model

Watch

Under 300 people

Platform plus seats

Setup fees, term length

$300M to $2B

Platform plus seats or modules

Integrator costs, supplier fees

Over $2B

Module bundles

SI program, migrations

The suites generally price by module and user count, sized by spend or transaction volume, and implementation is usually a separate integrator contract. Specialists tend to price as a platform fee plus seats. LightSource's model is platform plus seats with implementation included, and suppliers never pay. Supplier fees are the cost most buyers miss: on SAP Business Network, Enterprise supplier accounts that cross published thresholds pay fees, and small suppliers notice. We will publish a separate guide to what direct materials sourcing software costs.

A 30-Day Pilot Checklist

The fastest way to compare these platforms is to run one real commodity through two of them for 30 days. The test below is built so that no vendor, including LightSource, can pass it with a slide.

  1. Pick one commodity with a live BOM, such as machined brackets or a harness family, with at least one assembly that will see a revision during the pilot.

  2. Load the BOM as you have it (PLM export, Excel, PDF drawings) and record how long it takes until the items carry specs, files and quantities.

  3. Issue a line-item RFQ for one subassembly with a cost breakdown template: material, conversion, overhead and margin, packaging, logistics, tooling.

  4. Invite five real suppliers, at least one of whom will insist on its own spreadsheet. Count invited, active and usable responses separately (logging in is not the same as submitting a comparable bid), and note whether any supplier paid a fee or needed help.

  5. Compare the quotes line by line against a baseline (previous price or a should-cost) and build two award scenarios, one single-source and one split. Include a tooling charge on purpose and change the volume forecast, because the preferred supplier can change even when neither quote does (see the example below).

  6. Push a revision to one part and re-quote only that line; check that the first round is preserved.

  7. Export the award to an ERP test environment with supplier, part ID, revision, currency, price unit and effective date. Deliberately reject one row with an unmapped supplier code and see who can fix and resend it without duplicating the accepted rows.

  8. Write down four dates: contract signature, first live RFQ, first award loaded into the ERP, and rollout to a second plant.

In the tooling example from step 5, Supplier A quotes $4.00 a unit plus a $12,000 tool; Supplier B quotes $4.50 with no tooling charge.

Volume

A

B

10,000

$52,000

$45,000

24,000

$108,000

$108,000

40,000

$172,000

$180,000

Supplier B is cheaper at 10,000 units and Supplier A is cheaper at 40,000.

The two quotes break even at 24,000 units (one tool purchase, identical freight, no residual tooling value). A comparison that folds tooling into unit price, or that ignores the volume forecast, picks the wrong supplier on one side of that line, which is why the quote format should keep tooling as its own field.


Four-week timeline of a 30-day direct materials software pilot: load the BOM, issue the RFQ, compare and award, hand off to the ERP and decide
The 30-day pilot as a timeline: run the same steps on two platforms, including LightSource, and score elapsed time, supplier response and how much work moved back into Excel or email.

How We Ranked

LightSource wrote this guide, and LightSource is on the list. To keep it useful we scored every platform, including our own, on the same eight criteria a direct materials team actually uses: BOM and item data, quote breakdowns, bid analysis and award, revisions and NPI, supplier participation, ERP and PLM fit, time to go live and pricing model. The weights are stated in the "How We Scored" section. Capability notes come from public documentation, public buyer reviews, public analyst pages and our own evaluations as of October 2026; where we could not find a capability documented we say "not documented", which is not the same as "not offered". The suites on this list do things LightSource does not: purchase orders, invoicing, indirect spend, auctions, contract management and spend analytics. If you need those, say so in your evaluation and weigh them.

Why the order falls where it does: LightSource ranks first because it rates Native on the three most heavily weighted criteria (BOM and item data, quote breakdowns, bid analysis and award) and on revision re-quotes, while conceding the P2P, invoicing and should-cost capabilities it does not have. JAGGAER, SAP Ariba, Ivalua and GEP follow in order of documented direct depth within a suite. Coupa and Oracle are P2P-first suites: Oracle's direct capabilities extend into its separately licensed PLM, and Coupa buys direct spend for some manufacturers without a documented BOM-led module. Keelvar and Arkestro are strong at optimization and price discovery but are not systems of record for parts. Tacto is a direct specialist with thin public evidence, and Fairmarkit and Zip serve tail spend and intake, where direct materials sourcing is out of scope.

Analyst mentions are facts, not endorsements: The Hackett Group states that it does not endorse vendors and that its research is not selection advice. Hackett is also a paid implementation partner of Coupa, SAP Ariba and Zip, which readers should weigh when we cite it on those vendors.

Update log. Published October 14, 2026. Last reviewed October 14, 2026.

Sources

Frequently Asked Questions

What is direct materials procurement software, and how is it different from P2P and S2P suites?

Direct materials procurement software sources the parts and raw materials that go into a manufactured product: it builds RFQs from a bill of materials, collects supplier quotes in a comparable cost breakdown and records the award against the part. P2P software handles purchase orders, receipts and invoices after the sourcing decision. S2P suites span sourcing through payment for every spend type, with direct sourcing usually delivered as one module.

What direct materials purchasing software do manufacturing buyers recommend most often?

For teams whose sourcing starts from a BOM, the platforms most often shortlisted are LightSource, JAGGAER, SAP Ariba, Ivalua and GEP, with Coupa and Oracle common where the company already runs them for P2P. In our ranking LightSource places first on BOM-driven RFQs, structured cost breakdowns and revision re-quotes; JAGGAER is the deepest direct offering among the suites, and SAP Ariba is the default for enterprises standardized on S/4HANA.

Do I need a separate tool if I already run SAP or Oracle?

Not always. If your sourcing is mostly catalog and contract buying, the procurement module of your ERP or suite may be enough. If buyers still build RFQs in Excel, chase quotes by email and re-key cost breakdowns, a direct materials platform that connects to the ERP by flat file or API usually closes that gap faster than a new suite module, and it leaves purchase orders and invoices in the ERP.

How long does implementation take?

It depends on scope more than on the vendor. Full S2P suite rollouts are partner-led programs measured in months per module, while direct materials specialists typically run a first live RFQ within weeks; LightSource deployments typically take about 30 days, with bespoke integrations scoped separately. Ask every vendor for four dates: contract signature, first live RFQ, first award loaded into the ERP and rollout to a second plant.

How much does direct materials sourcing software cost for a mid-size manufacturer?

Few vendors publish prices. Suites are typically custom-quoted by module and user count with a separate integrator contract, while specialists usually charge a platform fee plus seats; LightSource charges platform plus seats with implementation included, and suppliers pay nothing. Budget for integration, internal time and any supplier network fees, not only the license.

How is LightSource different from JAGGAER, SAP Ariba and Ivalua?

LightSource is built only for direct materials: parts, BOMs, revisions, cost breakdowns and supplier quotes, connected to the PLM and ERP rather than replacing them. JAGGAER, SAP Ariba and Ivalua are all-spend S2P suites with direct sourcing modules plus purchase orders, invoicing and contract management, which LightSource does not offer. The trade-off is depth and speed on direct sourcing against one vendor for everything.

Which procurement software fits automotive tier 1 suppliers?

For BOM-driven RFQs with structured cost breakdowns and frequent revision re-quotes, LightSource ranks first in this guide. If PPAP, APQP and part qualification must run in the same application as sourcing, start with JAGGAER, whose direct offering came from POOL4TOOL; LightSource does not perform those quality processes. Many tier 1s run sourcing in one system and quality in another, in which case the sourcing tool should be judged on RFQs, breakdowns and awards alone.

What are the best alternatives to Coupa or JAGGAER for BOM-level RFQs?

LightSource is built for projects launched from a hierarchical BOM, with every supplier filling the same cost breakdown and every revision preserved. Ivalua supports configured subassembly sourcing, and SAP Ariba suits S/4HANA-linked materials. Ask each vendor to re-quote one changed line after a drawing revision and to show which bid was used in the award.

Which tool fits a 300-person hardware company versus a $2B OEM?

A 300-person hardware company usually needs to get RFQs and supplier quotes out of email and onto a BOM quickly, with no integration program, which favors a specialist like LightSource or, in the DACH region, Tacto. A $2B OEM often already owns a suite for P2P; the question there is whether the suite's direct module will actually be adopted by commodity buyers, and many run a direct materials platform for engineered categories alongside the suite.

Direct materials procurement software is the system a manufacturer uses to source the parts and raw materials that go into its products: it turns a bill of materials into line-item RFQs, collects supplier quotes in a comparable cost breakdown, and carries the award back to the part record. Procure-to-pay (P2P) software handles what happens after the sourcing decision (purchase orders, receipts, invoices). Source-to-pay (S2P) suites try to cover both, for every kind of spend.

That distinction matters because most of the "best procurement software for manufacturing" lists in circulation rank S2P and P2P suites on suite breadth. This guide ranks twelve platforms on what a direct materials team does every week: building RFQs from a BOM, getting quotes back in a format that can be compared line by line, re-quoting when engineering changes a revision, and getting suppliers to respond at all. LightSource publishes this guide and ranks its own product first on those criteria; the disclosure, the weights and the places where LightSource falls short are all stated below.

The Short Answer

Sourcing tools have not changed much conceptually in two decades, and most direct materials teams still finish the real analysis in Excel and email. The Hackett Group's 2026 guide to direct sourcing tools describes the average tool as building an RFx from a BOM that carries only a part number, a description and a quantity, and automating little beyond supplier invitations and bid acceptance. That is the gap a direct materials platform has to close. Our verdict by manufacturer type, as of October 2026:

Buyer

Shortlist

Automotive tier 1

LightSource, then JAGGAER

EV or hardware startup

LightSource, then Tacto (DACH)

Build-to-order OEM

LightSource, then Ivalua

Enterprise on SAP

SAP Ariba, then LightSource

The reasons differ by row. Tier 1 suppliers live on BOM-driven RFQs with cost breakdowns; EV and hardware startups need to be live in weeks with suppliers who pay nothing; build-to-order OEMs re-quote constantly as revisions change; and enterprises on SAP often value one vendor for all spend above depth in any one category.

Two rows deserve a caveat. For an automotive tier 1 whose PPAP and APQP workflows must live in the same application as sourcing, start with JAGGAER, because LightSource does not run those quality processes; if a separate quality system already owns them, LightSource is the stronger sourcing tool. The enterprise-on-SAP row is the other honest exception. If the requirement is one vendor for direct, indirect, purchase orders and invoices on S/4HANA, SAP Ariba is the natural choice, and a direct specialist like LightSource is something you would add for the engineering-heavy categories rather than a replacement for the suite.

How We Scored

We scored every platform, including our own, on eight criteria. The weights reflect where direct materials sourcing time actually goes: most of it is spent getting part data into an RFQ and getting comparable quotes back out.

Criterion

Weight

Test

BOM and item data

20%

RFQ built from a spec-aware item record

Quote breakdowns

20%

Every supplier fills the same cost structure

Bid analysis and award

15%

Line-level comparison, award scenarios

Revisions and NPI

10%

Re-quote changed parts, keep history

Supplier participation

10%

Free, low-friction supplier response

ERP and PLM fit

10%

Documented, supportable integration path

Time to go live

10%

First live RFQ in weeks, not quarters

Pricing model

5%

Stated model, no surprise fees

The criteria follow the capability sets The Hackett Group uses to define the category: its Sourcing (for direct) Solutions guide treats BoM management integrated with PLM and ERP, cost analysis and cost-driver identification, NPD and NPI collaboration, and predictive cost analytics as what separates direct sourcing tools from general sourcing tools. We rate each capability with the vocabulary our comparison library uses: Native (documented and in the standard product), Configured (available, but set up per customer or through an integration project), Marketed (claimed on the vendor's site without public evidence of how it works) and Not documented (we could not find it, which is not the same as not offered).

The 12 Platforms at a Glance

Platform (direct depth)

Best fit

1. LightSource (Core)

BOM-led sourcing, NPI to production

2. JAGGAER (Module)

Multi-plant S2P with direct

3. SAP Ariba (Module)

S/4HANA shops wanting one vendor

4. Ivalua (Module)

Teams that will configure deeply

5. GEP (Module)

Software plus managed services

6. Coupa (None)

Indirect and P2P at scale

7. Oracle Fusion (Module)

Oracle ERP shops

8. Keelvar (None)

Large optimized tenders

9. Arkestro (None)

Predictive price discovery

10. Tacto (Core)

DACH industrial mid-market

11. Fairmarkit (None)

Tail spend and tactical buys

12. Zip (None)

Intake and approvals

The main limit of each, in one line: LightSource does no P2P, invoicing or indirect spend; JAGGAER's acquired modules and rigidity draw buyer complaints; SAP Ariba needs a partner-led rollout and training for occasional users; Ivalua depends on configuration skill and a strong partner; GEP's newest features require a move to QUANTUM; Coupa's center of gravity is not direct materials; Oracle's sourcing events are generic and P2P-first; Keelvar and Fairmarkit hold no item master; Arkestro has no documented BOM or cost-breakdown model; Tacto has thin public evidence outside DACH; and Zip's documented scope stops short of parts and BOMs.

"Direct" is our assessment of how central direct materials sourcing is to the product: Core (the product is built around parts and BOMs), Module (an identifiable part of an all-spend suite supports BOM-led sourcing) or None (no comparable BOM-led module is documented). None does not mean a platform cannot buy direct spend, and Core does not guarantee a high rank: Tacto is a direct specialist that ranks tenth because its documented strengths are supplier and cost intelligence rather than RFQs and awards. The designed version below adds a rating per criterion.


Rating table of 12 direct materials procurement platforms across BOM data, quote breakdowns, bid analysis and award, revisions, supplier participation, ERP and PLM fit, time to go live, pricing model and direct depth
Our ratings of the 12 platforms on this guide's criteria, as of October 2026. LightSource rates Native on BOM and item data, quote breakdowns, bid analysis and award, revisions and supplier participation, and Configured on ERP and PLM fit. Source: LightSource assessment of public documentation, public reviews and The Hackett Group's Sourcing (for direct) Solutions guide.

The 12 Platforms, Ranked

1. LightSource

Best for: manufacturers whose purchasing starts from an engineered product, from growth-stage hardware companies to Global 2000 divisions with large direct spend, who want to move sourcing out of Excel and email without replacing their ERP or PLM.

Strengths. LightSource is the AI-native direct materials operating system, spec through scale, PLM through ERP. Items are master data with specs, custom properties, revisions, drawings and files, and BOMs are hierarchical, with snapshots, cost history across snapshots and a cost breakdown view. A buyer can launch a sourcing project directly from a BOM or a batch of items. Item Ingestion reads PDFs, Excel files, drawings and images and creates or updates items from them; it processed more than 3,300 items in its first month. The RFX Setup Agent builds the quote format from category intelligence and past templates, which LightSource's documentation describes as cutting about two weeks of setup to about 15 minutes.

Quotes come back structured. Buyers pick or build a quote format (Unit Price Only, Simple Breakdown with material, conversion, SG&A, margin, packaging and logistics, or Full Breakdown down to machine process, cycle time and machine rate), and every supplier fills the same structure in the app or through an Excel round-trip. Bid comparison shows the delta to baseline, item, tooling and ED&T views, a cost walk across resubmissions, and an AI comparison that explains in plain language how two quotes differ. Award scenarios can be built by hand or generated from submitted quotes, split by volume or percentage, and routed for approval. When engineering revises a part, the buyer resends the RFQ, every version is preserved, and suppliers see what changed.

Suppliers use LightSource free. Supplier Discovery searches a network of more than 100,000 suppliers by name, industry or capability, and suppliers already on the platform or new to it are invited from the RFQ email, get automatic reminders, and Supplier Activation answers common supplier questions and nudges non-responders. At Blue Bird, the school bus maker, buyers ran 38 percent more RFQs per person with the same team, average sourcing cycle time fell from 16 to 14 days, and 398 supplier companies were onboarded with 99.7 percent of them active, according to the published case study. Other customers include Arxada, Aramsco, Time Manufacturing, BRP, Canada Goose, Yum! Brands and Zebra. LightSource holds a SOC 2 Type 2 attestation, supports SAML single sign-on with enforced MFA, and does not train foundation models on customer RFQ or contract data.

Limits. LightSource does not do purchase orders, invoicing, indirect or tail spend, reverse auctions, contract lifecycle management or spend analytics; an award creates an item contract, not a PO. Should-cost models are requested from a third party or uploaded and then used as the bid baseline, so there is no built-in should-cost engine. Post-award quality workflows such as PPAP and APQP tracking are not part of the product. Integration runs through Excel Item Sync (with a PLM and database sync template) and a GraphQL API with team-scoped keys; LightSource connects to the PLM and ERP systems its customers run through those paths rather than through certified prebuilt connectors. The company came out of stealth in 2025, so it does not have a multi-decade track record.

Pricing model: platform fee plus seats, implementation included; suppliers pay nothing.

Direct depth: Core. LightSource is listed in The Hackett Group's Sourcing (for direct) Solutions guide, which describes it as an "AI-native sourcing platform purpose-built for direct materials procurement." Recognition includes Gartner Cool Vendor in Sourcing and Procurement Technology (2025), ProcureTech100 (2025/26), The Hackett Group 50 to Watch (2025-2026) and a debut in the Spend Matters Fall 2025 SolutionMap in both the Sourcing and Direct Sourcing categories. Deployment typically takes about 30 days, with no rip-and-replace of ERP or PLM; bespoke integration work is scoped separately. Read our head-to-head pages for detail: LightSource vs. JAGGAER, vs. SAP Ariba and vs. Ivalua.

2. JAGGAER

Best for: large, multi-plant manufacturers that want one S2P suite with real direct materials heritage and have the administrative staff to run it.

Strengths. Sourcing is JAGGAER's strongest area, including direct materials sourcing and optimization. Its direct offering, JAGGAER Direct, descends from POOL4TOOL, which JAGGAER combined with in 2017 to add direct procurement, and it supports multi-tier BOMs with alternates and engineering change workflows for large manufacturers. The optimization engine traces to the 2013 CombineNet acquisition. In September 2026 JAGGAER closed its acquisition of Ivoflow, which compares a manufacturer's ERP purchasing data with commodity and currency inputs, adding direct materials price intelligence. JAGGAER also markets a large catalog of prebuilt ERP connectors. The Hackett Group's direct sourcing guide credits it with "sophisticated direct materials sourcing capabilities."

Limits. The same Hackett entry notes that the suite was built over time through multiple acquisitions: SciQuest (founded 1995), Upside Software and CombineNet (2012 and 2013), POOL4TOOL and BravoSolution (2017). In our evaluations, buyers should test how item, supplier and contract data move between modules. A recurring complaint among reviewers is rigidity, with limited conditional logic in forms and settings that need re-checking after releases, and some manufacturing users describe the direct offering as rich but demanding, with a risk of over-customization. JAGGAER's own implementation guidance runs to months per module. In our assessment, BOM import exists but sits on an enterprise S2P rollout rather than starting from AI ingestion of drawings and spreadsheets.

Demo test: have a plant buyer add a field to a cost breakdown, run an event with it, and check that it survives the next release.

Pricing model: custom-quoted subscription by module and user band; public-sector schedules show annual module fees by user count.

Direct depth: Module, and the deepest of the suites. See LightSource vs. JAGGAER.

3. SAP Ariba

Best for: enterprises standardized on SAP S/4HANA that want one vendor for every spend type and accept a partner-led rollout.

Strengths. Direct procurement is a credited strength of the suite, and SAP Ariba's largest assets are native integration with SAP ERP (material masters and awarded pricing flow to S/4HANA) and the SAP Business Network of suppliers. The Hackett Group's S2P guide points to its "strong integration with SAP ERP environments." Its RFx and auction engine is mature and widely deployed. In March 2026 SAP announced the next-generation Ariba applications rebuilt on SAP Business Technology Platform, rolling out incrementally through 2026 and 2027.

Limits. Ariba's architecture predates SAP's ownership (SAP completed the acquisition in 2012; Ariba had bought FreeMarkets in 2004), and SAP's own 2026 platform work is aimed at modernizing it. A recurring minority complaint among reviewers is a dated interface that needs extensive training for occasional users. Rollouts are partner-led, so ask who owns the outcome. Some reviewers report that customers on non-SAP ERPs feel sidelined. In our evaluations, as of October 2026, sourcing events reference ERP material master rows rather than drawings, properties and revisions, and detailed cost breakdowns usually travel as an Excel attachment. On the supplier side, Standard accounts on SAP Business Network are free, while Enterprise accounts that cross SAP's published document and value thresholds pay transaction and subscription fees, a known friction for small machine shops.

Demo test: ask to see the version of the sourcing application your plants would actually receive during SAP's phased modernization, carrying a drawing and revision into an RFQ.

Pricing model: module subscriptions, price on request; sourcing is priced by user on public-sector schedules, plus integrator implementation.

Direct depth: Module. See LightSource vs. SAP Ariba.

4. Ivalua

Best for: complex, regulated enterprises that want a deeply configurable suite and will invest in configuration and a strong implementation partner.

Strengths. Ivalua is organically built on a single codebase, which sets it apart from the acquisition-assembled suites; The Hackett Group calls it a "natively integrated, intuitive and flexible suite" with capabilities for all spend, including direct materials. Sourcing is its strongest area, with every RFx type, auctions and optimization, and it supports BOM-driven sourcing events through ERP and PLM interfaces. In August 2026 Deloitte announced an alliance with Ivalua covering direct and indirect source-to-pay.

Limits. Buyers report that getting value from Ivalua takes data-model expertise and configuration time, and partner choice matters more than usual: some manufacturers report that customizations caused upgrade friction. Some describe the direct procurement module and its integrations as still maturing, and some reviewers find the interface dated and the item grid confusing. In our evaluations, BOM sync is set up per customer rather than extracted from files.

Demo test: ask a buyer to add a tooling-life field, send it to suppliers and show it to the award approver, and record which steps need the implementation partner.

Pricing model: custom-quoted subscription sized by modules and users, with implementation sold separately; suppliers quote free through the portal.

Direct depth: Module. See LightSource vs. Ivalua.

5. GEP

Best for: enterprises that want software and managed procurement services from one provider.

Strengths. GEP is also organically built, and direct materials sourcing and complex industry requirements are a long-standing strength. The Hackett Group's direct sourcing guide credits its suite with "cost and should-cost modeling, opportunity identification and sourcing execution" usable for direct and indirect spend, backed by services and BPO. The interface on its QUANTUM platform is credited by reviewers, and GEP sells consulting and managed services that some buyers want.

Limits. GEP's newest capabilities live on QUANTUM, and existing SMART customers face a migration to get them. A recurring minority complaint among reviewers, mostly on the earlier platform, is a sluggish interface and workflow changes that need a support ticket. Buyers also report custom work for ERP integration. Implementation and operation often come bundled with GEP services, so ask what the software does on its own.

Demo test: ask GEP to repeat its should-cost exercise on your part without a services analyst operating the screen.

Pricing model: custom quote-based enterprise subscription, often in the same relationship as managed services.

Direct depth: Module. GEP is the one suite on this list with a credited should-cost module, which LightSource does not have; if building an independent should-cost model inside the software is mandatory, GEP belongs on the shortlist ahead of LightSource. See LightSource vs. GEP.

6. Coupa

Best for: companies running indirect spend and procure-to-pay at scale that want broad spend visibility and community benchmarking.

Strengths. Coupa is the broadest P2P and indirect procurement suite on this list. Its sourcing optimization engine came from the 2017 Trade Extensions acquisition and runs very large events. The Hackett Group credits a "user-friendly interface, automated sourcing processes" and community intelligence. Coupa does run direct materials for some manufacturers: Kimberly-Clark told its suppliers in August 2026 that a direct-material workflow covering sourcing prices, POs and line acknowledgements had gone live in mainland China and Hong Kong. In May 2026 Coupa acquired Tonkean for intake and orchestration.

Limits. P2P and indirect are Coupa's center of gravity, and some manufacturing buyers report gaps bringing direct spend onto the platform. Coupa sells one configurable product and does not build customer-specific features, so a BOM-driven RFQ with a custom cost breakdown has to fit the standard event model. A recurring minority complaint among reviewers is complexity for occasional users and administrators. Coupa has grown by acquisition in optimization, risk, contracts, supply chain design and now intake, so test how those modules share data. Leadership changed in August 2026, when Mike Lipps became interim CEO.

Pricing model: custom quote by module and user count; integrator-led rollout. Suppliers use the Coupa Supplier Portal free, with optional paid supplier subscriptions.

Direct depth: None under this guide's BOM-module definition, although Coupa can and does buy direct spend. A manufacturer happy with Coupa for P2P can keep it for orders and invoices and add a direct materials platform for engineered categories. See LightSource vs. Coupa and Spencer Penn's longer LightSource vs. Coupa post.

7. Oracle Fusion Cloud Procurement

Best for: companies already on Oracle Fusion ERP that want procurement on the same data model.

Strengths. Oracle Fusion Procurement shares one data model with Oracle's financials and PLM, which makes ERP integration native for Oracle shops. It covers line-level RFQ, RFI and auction events with two-stage RFQs and price tiers, and P2P and contracts are strong. Oracle publishes a per-user list price, which is rare in this category.

Limits. The product is P2P-first, and its sourcing events are generic all-spend events rather than drawing- and revision-centric RFQs. Oracle's design-to-source capability sits in Fusion Cloud PLM, a separate entitlement, so ask which licenses a quote includes. Implementations are partner-led and ERP-class. Outside an Oracle estate, most of the integration advantage goes away. A useful demo request is a list of every screen shown, the product that owns it and the license it requires.

Pricing model: published per-hosted-named-user list price with a user minimum; contracted price set per order.

Direct depth: Module. See LightSource vs. Oracle.

8. Keelvar

Best for: large, complex tender events, especially logistics and freight, where award optimization is the main problem.

Strengths. Keelvar combines advanced sourcing optimization with sourcing automation bots, runs events with thousands of lines and hundreds of bidders, and gives suppliers free, invite-based bidder accounts with online or Excel bidding. The Hackett Group lists it in its direct sourcing guide alongside its general and optimization guides, describing optimization and automation capabilities.

Limits. Keelvar's data is scoped to each sourcing event. It is not an item or BOM system of record, so drawings, revisions and part history live elsewhere. Complex optimization models often lean on vendor analysts.

Pricing model: quote-based enterprise subscription; contractual limits can be set by events, users or spend.

Direct depth: None documented as a system of record. See LightSource vs. Keelvar.

9. Arkestro

Best for: teams that want predictive price discovery and automated negotiation across many categories, running alongside an existing suite.

Strengths. Arkestro suggests prices to suppliers using machine learning and behavioral science, runs multi-round events with live ranking feedback, and sells into automotive and manufacturing among other verticals. It is designed to sit next to Coupa, SAP Ariba and the ERP.

Limits. Arkestro does not hold items, drawings or cost breakdowns as a system of record, and The Hackett Group lists it in its general sourcing and spend analytics guides but not in the direct sourcing guide. A predicted price is not a should-cost: it tells you what a supplier might accept, not what the part should cost to make.

Pricing model: platform subscription, not published.

Direct depth: None documented. See LightSource vs. Arkestro.

10. Tacto

Best for: industrial mid-market manufacturers in Germany, Austria and Switzerland that want AI-assisted supplier and cost intelligence.

Strengths. Tacto targets industrial manufacturers directly, combining supplier, cost, sourcing and compliance modules, and it is quick to implement according to its public reviewers. It raised a €50 million round led by Sequoia and Index in December 2023.

Limits. Public evidence is thin: Tacto has few public reviews and no major analyst coverage we could find as of October 2026, and part-line RFQ depth and drawing-packet handling are not publicly demonstrated. Its footprint is regional, and connecting ERP data is onboarding work.

Pricing model: not published; demo-led annual subscription.

Direct depth: Core, by positioning; depth not publicly verified. See LightSource vs. Tacto.

11. Fairmarkit

Best for: high-volume, low-dollar tail spend and tactical buys where speed matters more than engineering detail.

Strengths. Fairmarkit automates tactical sourcing events at volume, embeds in ERP and P2P systems such as Ariba, Coupa, Oracle and ServiceNow, and suppliers quote free. Coca-Cola Europacific Partners reported cutting project cycle time by more than half for tactical purchases under €250,000.

Limits. Fairmarkit has no item master: intake captures requisitions, not parts or drawings. BOM sourcing and cost breakdowns are not documented.

Pricing model: custom-quoted subscription; suppliers pay nothing to quote.

Direct depth: None. See LightSource vs. Fairmarkit.

12. Zip

Best for: companies that want one intake front door and approval orchestration across indirect spend.

Strengths. Zip has a modern architecture with little technical debt, strong intake, approvals and vendor onboarding, and deep integrations through its own iPaaS layer, which The Hackett Group singles out. In September 2026 it announced sourcing and PO agents.

Limits. Zip's documented objects are requests, vendors, POs, invoices and contracts; there is no item master, part or BOM concept, and its RFx is oriented to vendors and services rather than part lines with drawings. Direct materials sourcing is outside what it documents.

Pricing model: custom-quoted; marketplace data describes a platform fee plus per-seat pricing.

Direct depth: None. See LightSource vs. Zip.

Direct vs. Indirect Software

Direct materials become part of the finished product: castings, harnesses, resins, PCBAs, fasteners. Indirect spend keeps the company running: software, travel, facilities, services. The same item can be either. A cooling fan built into the product is a direct material, and a change to its connector, operating temperature or drawing revision can invalidate a quote even when the supplier, description and price look unchanged; the same fan bought to cool the maintenance office is an indirect purchase that nobody re-quotes when engineering changes a drawing. The two need different software because the unit of work is different. An indirect purchase is a request with a supplier and a price. A direct purchase is a part with a drawing, a revision, a material, a volume forecast and a cost structure that the supplier should be able to explain. We go deeper on the split in what's the difference between direct and indirect procurement.

Analysts treat the categories separately too. Direct Sourcing is one of the 16 categories in The Hackett Group's SolutionMap, separate from general Sourcing, and Hackett's sourcing guide names direct materials support as one of five axes on which sourcing tools materially differ. That is why a suite can be excellent at indirect and P2P while its direct module is the part buyers struggle to adopt. Hackett's first readiness signal for a dedicated direct tool is exactly that: low adoption of the current sourcing tool because it does not handle direct requirements.

In practice the failure shows up in data. When the RFQ line is free text with a part number, everything engineering knows about the part (material, finish, tolerances, revision) travels as an attachment, and the cost breakdown comes back as each supplier's own spreadsheet. Our colleague Mason Morgan wrote about what that costs in the sourcing bottleneck and about getting bill of materials data into shape first; our team has also written about why direct materials needs an operating system before AI can help.


Lollipop chart: 94 percent of procurement teams use a source-to-pay solution, 92 percent of CPOs plan to invest in generative AI, 37 percent are piloting or deploying it, and in a 2026 survey 75 percent are still experimenting while 5 percent report widespread adoption
Nearly every procurement team owns source-to-pay software (94 percent, PwC 2024), and 92 percent of CPOs plan to invest in generative AI (Deloitte 2024), yet only 5 percent report widespread adoption (EFESO 2026). The surveys cover different populations, and none measures how many direct materials RFQs run in software.

What It Costs by Company Size

Almost no vendor in this category publishes a price list, so the useful comparison is the pricing model and what sits outside the license.

Size

Model

Watch

Under 300 people

Platform plus seats

Setup fees, term length

$300M to $2B

Platform plus seats or modules

Integrator costs, supplier fees

Over $2B

Module bundles

SI program, migrations

The suites generally price by module and user count, sized by spend or transaction volume, and implementation is usually a separate integrator contract. Specialists tend to price as a platform fee plus seats. LightSource's model is platform plus seats with implementation included, and suppliers never pay. Supplier fees are the cost most buyers miss: on SAP Business Network, Enterprise supplier accounts that cross published thresholds pay fees, and small suppliers notice. We will publish a separate guide to what direct materials sourcing software costs.

A 30-Day Pilot Checklist

The fastest way to compare these platforms is to run one real commodity through two of them for 30 days. The test below is built so that no vendor, including LightSource, can pass it with a slide.

  1. Pick one commodity with a live BOM, such as machined brackets or a harness family, with at least one assembly that will see a revision during the pilot.

  2. Load the BOM as you have it (PLM export, Excel, PDF drawings) and record how long it takes until the items carry specs, files and quantities.

  3. Issue a line-item RFQ for one subassembly with a cost breakdown template: material, conversion, overhead and margin, packaging, logistics, tooling.

  4. Invite five real suppliers, at least one of whom will insist on its own spreadsheet. Count invited, active and usable responses separately (logging in is not the same as submitting a comparable bid), and note whether any supplier paid a fee or needed help.

  5. Compare the quotes line by line against a baseline (previous price or a should-cost) and build two award scenarios, one single-source and one split. Include a tooling charge on purpose and change the volume forecast, because the preferred supplier can change even when neither quote does (see the example below).

  6. Push a revision to one part and re-quote only that line; check that the first round is preserved.

  7. Export the award to an ERP test environment with supplier, part ID, revision, currency, price unit and effective date. Deliberately reject one row with an unmapped supplier code and see who can fix and resend it without duplicating the accepted rows.

  8. Write down four dates: contract signature, first live RFQ, first award loaded into the ERP, and rollout to a second plant.

In the tooling example from step 5, Supplier A quotes $4.00 a unit plus a $12,000 tool; Supplier B quotes $4.50 with no tooling charge.

Volume

A

B

10,000

$52,000

$45,000

24,000

$108,000

$108,000

40,000

$172,000

$180,000

Supplier B is cheaper at 10,000 units and Supplier A is cheaper at 40,000.

The two quotes break even at 24,000 units (one tool purchase, identical freight, no residual tooling value). A comparison that folds tooling into unit price, or that ignores the volume forecast, picks the wrong supplier on one side of that line, which is why the quote format should keep tooling as its own field.


Four-week timeline of a 30-day direct materials software pilot: load the BOM, issue the RFQ, compare and award, hand off to the ERP and decide
The 30-day pilot as a timeline: run the same steps on two platforms, including LightSource, and score elapsed time, supplier response and how much work moved back into Excel or email.

How We Ranked

LightSource wrote this guide, and LightSource is on the list. To keep it useful we scored every platform, including our own, on the same eight criteria a direct materials team actually uses: BOM and item data, quote breakdowns, bid analysis and award, revisions and NPI, supplier participation, ERP and PLM fit, time to go live and pricing model. The weights are stated in the "How We Scored" section. Capability notes come from public documentation, public buyer reviews, public analyst pages and our own evaluations as of October 2026; where we could not find a capability documented we say "not documented", which is not the same as "not offered". The suites on this list do things LightSource does not: purchase orders, invoicing, indirect spend, auctions, contract management and spend analytics. If you need those, say so in your evaluation and weigh them.

Why the order falls where it does: LightSource ranks first because it rates Native on the three most heavily weighted criteria (BOM and item data, quote breakdowns, bid analysis and award) and on revision re-quotes, while conceding the P2P, invoicing and should-cost capabilities it does not have. JAGGAER, SAP Ariba, Ivalua and GEP follow in order of documented direct depth within a suite. Coupa and Oracle are P2P-first suites: Oracle's direct capabilities extend into its separately licensed PLM, and Coupa buys direct spend for some manufacturers without a documented BOM-led module. Keelvar and Arkestro are strong at optimization and price discovery but are not systems of record for parts. Tacto is a direct specialist with thin public evidence, and Fairmarkit and Zip serve tail spend and intake, where direct materials sourcing is out of scope.

Analyst mentions are facts, not endorsements: The Hackett Group states that it does not endorse vendors and that its research is not selection advice. Hackett is also a paid implementation partner of Coupa, SAP Ariba and Zip, which readers should weigh when we cite it on those vendors.

Update log. Published October 14, 2026. Last reviewed October 14, 2026.

Sources

Frequently Asked Questions

What is direct materials procurement software, and how is it different from P2P and S2P suites?

Direct materials procurement software sources the parts and raw materials that go into a manufactured product: it builds RFQs from a bill of materials, collects supplier quotes in a comparable cost breakdown and records the award against the part. P2P software handles purchase orders, receipts and invoices after the sourcing decision. S2P suites span sourcing through payment for every spend type, with direct sourcing usually delivered as one module.

What direct materials purchasing software do manufacturing buyers recommend most often?

For teams whose sourcing starts from a BOM, the platforms most often shortlisted are LightSource, JAGGAER, SAP Ariba, Ivalua and GEP, with Coupa and Oracle common where the company already runs them for P2P. In our ranking LightSource places first on BOM-driven RFQs, structured cost breakdowns and revision re-quotes; JAGGAER is the deepest direct offering among the suites, and SAP Ariba is the default for enterprises standardized on S/4HANA.

Do I need a separate tool if I already run SAP or Oracle?

Not always. If your sourcing is mostly catalog and contract buying, the procurement module of your ERP or suite may be enough. If buyers still build RFQs in Excel, chase quotes by email and re-key cost breakdowns, a direct materials platform that connects to the ERP by flat file or API usually closes that gap faster than a new suite module, and it leaves purchase orders and invoices in the ERP.

How long does implementation take?

It depends on scope more than on the vendor. Full S2P suite rollouts are partner-led programs measured in months per module, while direct materials specialists typically run a first live RFQ within weeks; LightSource deployments typically take about 30 days, with bespoke integrations scoped separately. Ask every vendor for four dates: contract signature, first live RFQ, first award loaded into the ERP and rollout to a second plant.

How much does direct materials sourcing software cost for a mid-size manufacturer?

Few vendors publish prices. Suites are typically custom-quoted by module and user count with a separate integrator contract, while specialists usually charge a platform fee plus seats; LightSource charges platform plus seats with implementation included, and suppliers pay nothing. Budget for integration, internal time and any supplier network fees, not only the license.

How is LightSource different from JAGGAER, SAP Ariba and Ivalua?

LightSource is built only for direct materials: parts, BOMs, revisions, cost breakdowns and supplier quotes, connected to the PLM and ERP rather than replacing them. JAGGAER, SAP Ariba and Ivalua are all-spend S2P suites with direct sourcing modules plus purchase orders, invoicing and contract management, which LightSource does not offer. The trade-off is depth and speed on direct sourcing against one vendor for everything.

Which procurement software fits automotive tier 1 suppliers?

For BOM-driven RFQs with structured cost breakdowns and frequent revision re-quotes, LightSource ranks first in this guide. If PPAP, APQP and part qualification must run in the same application as sourcing, start with JAGGAER, whose direct offering came from POOL4TOOL; LightSource does not perform those quality processes. Many tier 1s run sourcing in one system and quality in another, in which case the sourcing tool should be judged on RFQs, breakdowns and awards alone.

What are the best alternatives to Coupa or JAGGAER for BOM-level RFQs?

LightSource is built for projects launched from a hierarchical BOM, with every supplier filling the same cost breakdown and every revision preserved. Ivalua supports configured subassembly sourcing, and SAP Ariba suits S/4HANA-linked materials. Ask each vendor to re-quote one changed line after a drawing revision and to show which bid was used in the award.

Which tool fits a 300-person hardware company versus a $2B OEM?

A 300-person hardware company usually needs to get RFQs and supplier quotes out of email and onto a BOM quickly, with no integration program, which favors a specialist like LightSource or, in the DACH region, Tacto. A $2B OEM often already owns a suite for P2P; the question there is whether the suite's direct module will actually be adopted by commodity buyers, and many run a direct materials platform for engineered categories alongside the suite.

Direct materials procurement software is the system a manufacturer uses to source the parts and raw materials that go into its products: it turns a bill of materials into line-item RFQs, collects supplier quotes in a comparable cost breakdown, and carries the award back to the part record. Procure-to-pay (P2P) software handles what happens after the sourcing decision (purchase orders, receipts, invoices). Source-to-pay (S2P) suites try to cover both, for every kind of spend.

That distinction matters because most of the "best procurement software for manufacturing" lists in circulation rank S2P and P2P suites on suite breadth. This guide ranks twelve platforms on what a direct materials team does every week: building RFQs from a BOM, getting quotes back in a format that can be compared line by line, re-quoting when engineering changes a revision, and getting suppliers to respond at all. LightSource publishes this guide and ranks its own product first on those criteria; the disclosure, the weights and the places where LightSource falls short are all stated below.

The Short Answer

Sourcing tools have not changed much conceptually in two decades, and most direct materials teams still finish the real analysis in Excel and email. The Hackett Group's 2026 guide to direct sourcing tools describes the average tool as building an RFx from a BOM that carries only a part number, a description and a quantity, and automating little beyond supplier invitations and bid acceptance. That is the gap a direct materials platform has to close. Our verdict by manufacturer type, as of October 2026:

Buyer

Shortlist

Automotive tier 1

LightSource, then JAGGAER

EV or hardware startup

LightSource, then Tacto (DACH)

Build-to-order OEM

LightSource, then Ivalua

Enterprise on SAP

SAP Ariba, then LightSource

The reasons differ by row. Tier 1 suppliers live on BOM-driven RFQs with cost breakdowns; EV and hardware startups need to be live in weeks with suppliers who pay nothing; build-to-order OEMs re-quote constantly as revisions change; and enterprises on SAP often value one vendor for all spend above depth in any one category.

Two rows deserve a caveat. For an automotive tier 1 whose PPAP and APQP workflows must live in the same application as sourcing, start with JAGGAER, because LightSource does not run those quality processes; if a separate quality system already owns them, LightSource is the stronger sourcing tool. The enterprise-on-SAP row is the other honest exception. If the requirement is one vendor for direct, indirect, purchase orders and invoices on S/4HANA, SAP Ariba is the natural choice, and a direct specialist like LightSource is something you would add for the engineering-heavy categories rather than a replacement for the suite.

How We Scored

We scored every platform, including our own, on eight criteria. The weights reflect where direct materials sourcing time actually goes: most of it is spent getting part data into an RFQ and getting comparable quotes back out.

Criterion

Weight

Test

BOM and item data

20%

RFQ built from a spec-aware item record

Quote breakdowns

20%

Every supplier fills the same cost structure

Bid analysis and award

15%

Line-level comparison, award scenarios

Revisions and NPI

10%

Re-quote changed parts, keep history

Supplier participation

10%

Free, low-friction supplier response

ERP and PLM fit

10%

Documented, supportable integration path

Time to go live

10%

First live RFQ in weeks, not quarters

Pricing model

5%

Stated model, no surprise fees

The criteria follow the capability sets The Hackett Group uses to define the category: its Sourcing (for direct) Solutions guide treats BoM management integrated with PLM and ERP, cost analysis and cost-driver identification, NPD and NPI collaboration, and predictive cost analytics as what separates direct sourcing tools from general sourcing tools. We rate each capability with the vocabulary our comparison library uses: Native (documented and in the standard product), Configured (available, but set up per customer or through an integration project), Marketed (claimed on the vendor's site without public evidence of how it works) and Not documented (we could not find it, which is not the same as not offered).

The 12 Platforms at a Glance

Platform (direct depth)

Best fit

1. LightSource (Core)

BOM-led sourcing, NPI to production

2. JAGGAER (Module)

Multi-plant S2P with direct

3. SAP Ariba (Module)

S/4HANA shops wanting one vendor

4. Ivalua (Module)

Teams that will configure deeply

5. GEP (Module)

Software plus managed services

6. Coupa (None)

Indirect and P2P at scale

7. Oracle Fusion (Module)

Oracle ERP shops

8. Keelvar (None)

Large optimized tenders

9. Arkestro (None)

Predictive price discovery

10. Tacto (Core)

DACH industrial mid-market

11. Fairmarkit (None)

Tail spend and tactical buys

12. Zip (None)

Intake and approvals

The main limit of each, in one line: LightSource does no P2P, invoicing or indirect spend; JAGGAER's acquired modules and rigidity draw buyer complaints; SAP Ariba needs a partner-led rollout and training for occasional users; Ivalua depends on configuration skill and a strong partner; GEP's newest features require a move to QUANTUM; Coupa's center of gravity is not direct materials; Oracle's sourcing events are generic and P2P-first; Keelvar and Fairmarkit hold no item master; Arkestro has no documented BOM or cost-breakdown model; Tacto has thin public evidence outside DACH; and Zip's documented scope stops short of parts and BOMs.

"Direct" is our assessment of how central direct materials sourcing is to the product: Core (the product is built around parts and BOMs), Module (an identifiable part of an all-spend suite supports BOM-led sourcing) or None (no comparable BOM-led module is documented). None does not mean a platform cannot buy direct spend, and Core does not guarantee a high rank: Tacto is a direct specialist that ranks tenth because its documented strengths are supplier and cost intelligence rather than RFQs and awards. The designed version below adds a rating per criterion.


Rating table of 12 direct materials procurement platforms across BOM data, quote breakdowns, bid analysis and award, revisions, supplier participation, ERP and PLM fit, time to go live, pricing model and direct depth
Our ratings of the 12 platforms on this guide's criteria, as of October 2026. LightSource rates Native on BOM and item data, quote breakdowns, bid analysis and award, revisions and supplier participation, and Configured on ERP and PLM fit. Source: LightSource assessment of public documentation, public reviews and The Hackett Group's Sourcing (for direct) Solutions guide.

The 12 Platforms, Ranked

1. LightSource

Best for: manufacturers whose purchasing starts from an engineered product, from growth-stage hardware companies to Global 2000 divisions with large direct spend, who want to move sourcing out of Excel and email without replacing their ERP or PLM.

Strengths. LightSource is the AI-native direct materials operating system, spec through scale, PLM through ERP. Items are master data with specs, custom properties, revisions, drawings and files, and BOMs are hierarchical, with snapshots, cost history across snapshots and a cost breakdown view. A buyer can launch a sourcing project directly from a BOM or a batch of items. Item Ingestion reads PDFs, Excel files, drawings and images and creates or updates items from them; it processed more than 3,300 items in its first month. The RFX Setup Agent builds the quote format from category intelligence and past templates, which LightSource's documentation describes as cutting about two weeks of setup to about 15 minutes.

Quotes come back structured. Buyers pick or build a quote format (Unit Price Only, Simple Breakdown with material, conversion, SG&A, margin, packaging and logistics, or Full Breakdown down to machine process, cycle time and machine rate), and every supplier fills the same structure in the app or through an Excel round-trip. Bid comparison shows the delta to baseline, item, tooling and ED&T views, a cost walk across resubmissions, and an AI comparison that explains in plain language how two quotes differ. Award scenarios can be built by hand or generated from submitted quotes, split by volume or percentage, and routed for approval. When engineering revises a part, the buyer resends the RFQ, every version is preserved, and suppliers see what changed.

Suppliers use LightSource free. Supplier Discovery searches a network of more than 100,000 suppliers by name, industry or capability, and suppliers already on the platform or new to it are invited from the RFQ email, get automatic reminders, and Supplier Activation answers common supplier questions and nudges non-responders. At Blue Bird, the school bus maker, buyers ran 38 percent more RFQs per person with the same team, average sourcing cycle time fell from 16 to 14 days, and 398 supplier companies were onboarded with 99.7 percent of them active, according to the published case study. Other customers include Arxada, Aramsco, Time Manufacturing, BRP, Canada Goose, Yum! Brands and Zebra. LightSource holds a SOC 2 Type 2 attestation, supports SAML single sign-on with enforced MFA, and does not train foundation models on customer RFQ or contract data.

Limits. LightSource does not do purchase orders, invoicing, indirect or tail spend, reverse auctions, contract lifecycle management or spend analytics; an award creates an item contract, not a PO. Should-cost models are requested from a third party or uploaded and then used as the bid baseline, so there is no built-in should-cost engine. Post-award quality workflows such as PPAP and APQP tracking are not part of the product. Integration runs through Excel Item Sync (with a PLM and database sync template) and a GraphQL API with team-scoped keys; LightSource connects to the PLM and ERP systems its customers run through those paths rather than through certified prebuilt connectors. The company came out of stealth in 2025, so it does not have a multi-decade track record.

Pricing model: platform fee plus seats, implementation included; suppliers pay nothing.

Direct depth: Core. LightSource is listed in The Hackett Group's Sourcing (for direct) Solutions guide, which describes it as an "AI-native sourcing platform purpose-built for direct materials procurement." Recognition includes Gartner Cool Vendor in Sourcing and Procurement Technology (2025), ProcureTech100 (2025/26), The Hackett Group 50 to Watch (2025-2026) and a debut in the Spend Matters Fall 2025 SolutionMap in both the Sourcing and Direct Sourcing categories. Deployment typically takes about 30 days, with no rip-and-replace of ERP or PLM; bespoke integration work is scoped separately. Read our head-to-head pages for detail: LightSource vs. JAGGAER, vs. SAP Ariba and vs. Ivalua.

2. JAGGAER

Best for: large, multi-plant manufacturers that want one S2P suite with real direct materials heritage and have the administrative staff to run it.

Strengths. Sourcing is JAGGAER's strongest area, including direct materials sourcing and optimization. Its direct offering, JAGGAER Direct, descends from POOL4TOOL, which JAGGAER combined with in 2017 to add direct procurement, and it supports multi-tier BOMs with alternates and engineering change workflows for large manufacturers. The optimization engine traces to the 2013 CombineNet acquisition. In September 2026 JAGGAER closed its acquisition of Ivoflow, which compares a manufacturer's ERP purchasing data with commodity and currency inputs, adding direct materials price intelligence. JAGGAER also markets a large catalog of prebuilt ERP connectors. The Hackett Group's direct sourcing guide credits it with "sophisticated direct materials sourcing capabilities."

Limits. The same Hackett entry notes that the suite was built over time through multiple acquisitions: SciQuest (founded 1995), Upside Software and CombineNet (2012 and 2013), POOL4TOOL and BravoSolution (2017). In our evaluations, buyers should test how item, supplier and contract data move between modules. A recurring complaint among reviewers is rigidity, with limited conditional logic in forms and settings that need re-checking after releases, and some manufacturing users describe the direct offering as rich but demanding, with a risk of over-customization. JAGGAER's own implementation guidance runs to months per module. In our assessment, BOM import exists but sits on an enterprise S2P rollout rather than starting from AI ingestion of drawings and spreadsheets.

Demo test: have a plant buyer add a field to a cost breakdown, run an event with it, and check that it survives the next release.

Pricing model: custom-quoted subscription by module and user band; public-sector schedules show annual module fees by user count.

Direct depth: Module, and the deepest of the suites. See LightSource vs. JAGGAER.

3. SAP Ariba

Best for: enterprises standardized on SAP S/4HANA that want one vendor for every spend type and accept a partner-led rollout.

Strengths. Direct procurement is a credited strength of the suite, and SAP Ariba's largest assets are native integration with SAP ERP (material masters and awarded pricing flow to S/4HANA) and the SAP Business Network of suppliers. The Hackett Group's S2P guide points to its "strong integration with SAP ERP environments." Its RFx and auction engine is mature and widely deployed. In March 2026 SAP announced the next-generation Ariba applications rebuilt on SAP Business Technology Platform, rolling out incrementally through 2026 and 2027.

Limits. Ariba's architecture predates SAP's ownership (SAP completed the acquisition in 2012; Ariba had bought FreeMarkets in 2004), and SAP's own 2026 platform work is aimed at modernizing it. A recurring minority complaint among reviewers is a dated interface that needs extensive training for occasional users. Rollouts are partner-led, so ask who owns the outcome. Some reviewers report that customers on non-SAP ERPs feel sidelined. In our evaluations, as of October 2026, sourcing events reference ERP material master rows rather than drawings, properties and revisions, and detailed cost breakdowns usually travel as an Excel attachment. On the supplier side, Standard accounts on SAP Business Network are free, while Enterprise accounts that cross SAP's published document and value thresholds pay transaction and subscription fees, a known friction for small machine shops.

Demo test: ask to see the version of the sourcing application your plants would actually receive during SAP's phased modernization, carrying a drawing and revision into an RFQ.

Pricing model: module subscriptions, price on request; sourcing is priced by user on public-sector schedules, plus integrator implementation.

Direct depth: Module. See LightSource vs. SAP Ariba.

4. Ivalua

Best for: complex, regulated enterprises that want a deeply configurable suite and will invest in configuration and a strong implementation partner.

Strengths. Ivalua is organically built on a single codebase, which sets it apart from the acquisition-assembled suites; The Hackett Group calls it a "natively integrated, intuitive and flexible suite" with capabilities for all spend, including direct materials. Sourcing is its strongest area, with every RFx type, auctions and optimization, and it supports BOM-driven sourcing events through ERP and PLM interfaces. In August 2026 Deloitte announced an alliance with Ivalua covering direct and indirect source-to-pay.

Limits. Buyers report that getting value from Ivalua takes data-model expertise and configuration time, and partner choice matters more than usual: some manufacturers report that customizations caused upgrade friction. Some describe the direct procurement module and its integrations as still maturing, and some reviewers find the interface dated and the item grid confusing. In our evaluations, BOM sync is set up per customer rather than extracted from files.

Demo test: ask a buyer to add a tooling-life field, send it to suppliers and show it to the award approver, and record which steps need the implementation partner.

Pricing model: custom-quoted subscription sized by modules and users, with implementation sold separately; suppliers quote free through the portal.

Direct depth: Module. See LightSource vs. Ivalua.

5. GEP

Best for: enterprises that want software and managed procurement services from one provider.

Strengths. GEP is also organically built, and direct materials sourcing and complex industry requirements are a long-standing strength. The Hackett Group's direct sourcing guide credits its suite with "cost and should-cost modeling, opportunity identification and sourcing execution" usable for direct and indirect spend, backed by services and BPO. The interface on its QUANTUM platform is credited by reviewers, and GEP sells consulting and managed services that some buyers want.

Limits. GEP's newest capabilities live on QUANTUM, and existing SMART customers face a migration to get them. A recurring minority complaint among reviewers, mostly on the earlier platform, is a sluggish interface and workflow changes that need a support ticket. Buyers also report custom work for ERP integration. Implementation and operation often come bundled with GEP services, so ask what the software does on its own.

Demo test: ask GEP to repeat its should-cost exercise on your part without a services analyst operating the screen.

Pricing model: custom quote-based enterprise subscription, often in the same relationship as managed services.

Direct depth: Module. GEP is the one suite on this list with a credited should-cost module, which LightSource does not have; if building an independent should-cost model inside the software is mandatory, GEP belongs on the shortlist ahead of LightSource. See LightSource vs. GEP.

6. Coupa

Best for: companies running indirect spend and procure-to-pay at scale that want broad spend visibility and community benchmarking.

Strengths. Coupa is the broadest P2P and indirect procurement suite on this list. Its sourcing optimization engine came from the 2017 Trade Extensions acquisition and runs very large events. The Hackett Group credits a "user-friendly interface, automated sourcing processes" and community intelligence. Coupa does run direct materials for some manufacturers: Kimberly-Clark told its suppliers in August 2026 that a direct-material workflow covering sourcing prices, POs and line acknowledgements had gone live in mainland China and Hong Kong. In May 2026 Coupa acquired Tonkean for intake and orchestration.

Limits. P2P and indirect are Coupa's center of gravity, and some manufacturing buyers report gaps bringing direct spend onto the platform. Coupa sells one configurable product and does not build customer-specific features, so a BOM-driven RFQ with a custom cost breakdown has to fit the standard event model. A recurring minority complaint among reviewers is complexity for occasional users and administrators. Coupa has grown by acquisition in optimization, risk, contracts, supply chain design and now intake, so test how those modules share data. Leadership changed in August 2026, when Mike Lipps became interim CEO.

Pricing model: custom quote by module and user count; integrator-led rollout. Suppliers use the Coupa Supplier Portal free, with optional paid supplier subscriptions.

Direct depth: None under this guide's BOM-module definition, although Coupa can and does buy direct spend. A manufacturer happy with Coupa for P2P can keep it for orders and invoices and add a direct materials platform for engineered categories. See LightSource vs. Coupa and Spencer Penn's longer LightSource vs. Coupa post.

7. Oracle Fusion Cloud Procurement

Best for: companies already on Oracle Fusion ERP that want procurement on the same data model.

Strengths. Oracle Fusion Procurement shares one data model with Oracle's financials and PLM, which makes ERP integration native for Oracle shops. It covers line-level RFQ, RFI and auction events with two-stage RFQs and price tiers, and P2P and contracts are strong. Oracle publishes a per-user list price, which is rare in this category.

Limits. The product is P2P-first, and its sourcing events are generic all-spend events rather than drawing- and revision-centric RFQs. Oracle's design-to-source capability sits in Fusion Cloud PLM, a separate entitlement, so ask which licenses a quote includes. Implementations are partner-led and ERP-class. Outside an Oracle estate, most of the integration advantage goes away. A useful demo request is a list of every screen shown, the product that owns it and the license it requires.

Pricing model: published per-hosted-named-user list price with a user minimum; contracted price set per order.

Direct depth: Module. See LightSource vs. Oracle.

8. Keelvar

Best for: large, complex tender events, especially logistics and freight, where award optimization is the main problem.

Strengths. Keelvar combines advanced sourcing optimization with sourcing automation bots, runs events with thousands of lines and hundreds of bidders, and gives suppliers free, invite-based bidder accounts with online or Excel bidding. The Hackett Group lists it in its direct sourcing guide alongside its general and optimization guides, describing optimization and automation capabilities.

Limits. Keelvar's data is scoped to each sourcing event. It is not an item or BOM system of record, so drawings, revisions and part history live elsewhere. Complex optimization models often lean on vendor analysts.

Pricing model: quote-based enterprise subscription; contractual limits can be set by events, users or spend.

Direct depth: None documented as a system of record. See LightSource vs. Keelvar.

9. Arkestro

Best for: teams that want predictive price discovery and automated negotiation across many categories, running alongside an existing suite.

Strengths. Arkestro suggests prices to suppliers using machine learning and behavioral science, runs multi-round events with live ranking feedback, and sells into automotive and manufacturing among other verticals. It is designed to sit next to Coupa, SAP Ariba and the ERP.

Limits. Arkestro does not hold items, drawings or cost breakdowns as a system of record, and The Hackett Group lists it in its general sourcing and spend analytics guides but not in the direct sourcing guide. A predicted price is not a should-cost: it tells you what a supplier might accept, not what the part should cost to make.

Pricing model: platform subscription, not published.

Direct depth: None documented. See LightSource vs. Arkestro.

10. Tacto

Best for: industrial mid-market manufacturers in Germany, Austria and Switzerland that want AI-assisted supplier and cost intelligence.

Strengths. Tacto targets industrial manufacturers directly, combining supplier, cost, sourcing and compliance modules, and it is quick to implement according to its public reviewers. It raised a €50 million round led by Sequoia and Index in December 2023.

Limits. Public evidence is thin: Tacto has few public reviews and no major analyst coverage we could find as of October 2026, and part-line RFQ depth and drawing-packet handling are not publicly demonstrated. Its footprint is regional, and connecting ERP data is onboarding work.

Pricing model: not published; demo-led annual subscription.

Direct depth: Core, by positioning; depth not publicly verified. See LightSource vs. Tacto.

11. Fairmarkit

Best for: high-volume, low-dollar tail spend and tactical buys where speed matters more than engineering detail.

Strengths. Fairmarkit automates tactical sourcing events at volume, embeds in ERP and P2P systems such as Ariba, Coupa, Oracle and ServiceNow, and suppliers quote free. Coca-Cola Europacific Partners reported cutting project cycle time by more than half for tactical purchases under €250,000.

Limits. Fairmarkit has no item master: intake captures requisitions, not parts or drawings. BOM sourcing and cost breakdowns are not documented.

Pricing model: custom-quoted subscription; suppliers pay nothing to quote.

Direct depth: None. See LightSource vs. Fairmarkit.

12. Zip

Best for: companies that want one intake front door and approval orchestration across indirect spend.

Strengths. Zip has a modern architecture with little technical debt, strong intake, approvals and vendor onboarding, and deep integrations through its own iPaaS layer, which The Hackett Group singles out. In September 2026 it announced sourcing and PO agents.

Limits. Zip's documented objects are requests, vendors, POs, invoices and contracts; there is no item master, part or BOM concept, and its RFx is oriented to vendors and services rather than part lines with drawings. Direct materials sourcing is outside what it documents.

Pricing model: custom-quoted; marketplace data describes a platform fee plus per-seat pricing.

Direct depth: None. See LightSource vs. Zip.

Direct vs. Indirect Software

Direct materials become part of the finished product: castings, harnesses, resins, PCBAs, fasteners. Indirect spend keeps the company running: software, travel, facilities, services. The same item can be either. A cooling fan built into the product is a direct material, and a change to its connector, operating temperature or drawing revision can invalidate a quote even when the supplier, description and price look unchanged; the same fan bought to cool the maintenance office is an indirect purchase that nobody re-quotes when engineering changes a drawing. The two need different software because the unit of work is different. An indirect purchase is a request with a supplier and a price. A direct purchase is a part with a drawing, a revision, a material, a volume forecast and a cost structure that the supplier should be able to explain. We go deeper on the split in what's the difference between direct and indirect procurement.

Analysts treat the categories separately too. Direct Sourcing is one of the 16 categories in The Hackett Group's SolutionMap, separate from general Sourcing, and Hackett's sourcing guide names direct materials support as one of five axes on which sourcing tools materially differ. That is why a suite can be excellent at indirect and P2P while its direct module is the part buyers struggle to adopt. Hackett's first readiness signal for a dedicated direct tool is exactly that: low adoption of the current sourcing tool because it does not handle direct requirements.

In practice the failure shows up in data. When the RFQ line is free text with a part number, everything engineering knows about the part (material, finish, tolerances, revision) travels as an attachment, and the cost breakdown comes back as each supplier's own spreadsheet. Our colleague Mason Morgan wrote about what that costs in the sourcing bottleneck and about getting bill of materials data into shape first; our team has also written about why direct materials needs an operating system before AI can help.


Lollipop chart: 94 percent of procurement teams use a source-to-pay solution, 92 percent of CPOs plan to invest in generative AI, 37 percent are piloting or deploying it, and in a 2026 survey 75 percent are still experimenting while 5 percent report widespread adoption
Nearly every procurement team owns source-to-pay software (94 percent, PwC 2024), and 92 percent of CPOs plan to invest in generative AI (Deloitte 2024), yet only 5 percent report widespread adoption (EFESO 2026). The surveys cover different populations, and none measures how many direct materials RFQs run in software.

What It Costs by Company Size

Almost no vendor in this category publishes a price list, so the useful comparison is the pricing model and what sits outside the license.

Size

Model

Watch

Under 300 people

Platform plus seats

Setup fees, term length

$300M to $2B

Platform plus seats or modules

Integrator costs, supplier fees

Over $2B

Module bundles

SI program, migrations

The suites generally price by module and user count, sized by spend or transaction volume, and implementation is usually a separate integrator contract. Specialists tend to price as a platform fee plus seats. LightSource's model is platform plus seats with implementation included, and suppliers never pay. Supplier fees are the cost most buyers miss: on SAP Business Network, Enterprise supplier accounts that cross published thresholds pay fees, and small suppliers notice. We will publish a separate guide to what direct materials sourcing software costs.

A 30-Day Pilot Checklist

The fastest way to compare these platforms is to run one real commodity through two of them for 30 days. The test below is built so that no vendor, including LightSource, can pass it with a slide.

  1. Pick one commodity with a live BOM, such as machined brackets or a harness family, with at least one assembly that will see a revision during the pilot.

  2. Load the BOM as you have it (PLM export, Excel, PDF drawings) and record how long it takes until the items carry specs, files and quantities.

  3. Issue a line-item RFQ for one subassembly with a cost breakdown template: material, conversion, overhead and margin, packaging, logistics, tooling.

  4. Invite five real suppliers, at least one of whom will insist on its own spreadsheet. Count invited, active and usable responses separately (logging in is not the same as submitting a comparable bid), and note whether any supplier paid a fee or needed help.

  5. Compare the quotes line by line against a baseline (previous price or a should-cost) and build two award scenarios, one single-source and one split. Include a tooling charge on purpose and change the volume forecast, because the preferred supplier can change even when neither quote does (see the example below).

  6. Push a revision to one part and re-quote only that line; check that the first round is preserved.

  7. Export the award to an ERP test environment with supplier, part ID, revision, currency, price unit and effective date. Deliberately reject one row with an unmapped supplier code and see who can fix and resend it without duplicating the accepted rows.

  8. Write down four dates: contract signature, first live RFQ, first award loaded into the ERP, and rollout to a second plant.

In the tooling example from step 5, Supplier A quotes $4.00 a unit plus a $12,000 tool; Supplier B quotes $4.50 with no tooling charge.

Volume

A

B

10,000

$52,000

$45,000

24,000

$108,000

$108,000

40,000

$172,000

$180,000

Supplier B is cheaper at 10,000 units and Supplier A is cheaper at 40,000.

The two quotes break even at 24,000 units (one tool purchase, identical freight, no residual tooling value). A comparison that folds tooling into unit price, or that ignores the volume forecast, picks the wrong supplier on one side of that line, which is why the quote format should keep tooling as its own field.


Four-week timeline of a 30-day direct materials software pilot: load the BOM, issue the RFQ, compare and award, hand off to the ERP and decide
The 30-day pilot as a timeline: run the same steps on two platforms, including LightSource, and score elapsed time, supplier response and how much work moved back into Excel or email.

How We Ranked

LightSource wrote this guide, and LightSource is on the list. To keep it useful we scored every platform, including our own, on the same eight criteria a direct materials team actually uses: BOM and item data, quote breakdowns, bid analysis and award, revisions and NPI, supplier participation, ERP and PLM fit, time to go live and pricing model. The weights are stated in the "How We Scored" section. Capability notes come from public documentation, public buyer reviews, public analyst pages and our own evaluations as of October 2026; where we could not find a capability documented we say "not documented", which is not the same as "not offered". The suites on this list do things LightSource does not: purchase orders, invoicing, indirect spend, auctions, contract management and spend analytics. If you need those, say so in your evaluation and weigh them.

Why the order falls where it does: LightSource ranks first because it rates Native on the three most heavily weighted criteria (BOM and item data, quote breakdowns, bid analysis and award) and on revision re-quotes, while conceding the P2P, invoicing and should-cost capabilities it does not have. JAGGAER, SAP Ariba, Ivalua and GEP follow in order of documented direct depth within a suite. Coupa and Oracle are P2P-first suites: Oracle's direct capabilities extend into its separately licensed PLM, and Coupa buys direct spend for some manufacturers without a documented BOM-led module. Keelvar and Arkestro are strong at optimization and price discovery but are not systems of record for parts. Tacto is a direct specialist with thin public evidence, and Fairmarkit and Zip serve tail spend and intake, where direct materials sourcing is out of scope.

Analyst mentions are facts, not endorsements: The Hackett Group states that it does not endorse vendors and that its research is not selection advice. Hackett is also a paid implementation partner of Coupa, SAP Ariba and Zip, which readers should weigh when we cite it on those vendors.

Update log. Published October 14, 2026. Last reviewed October 14, 2026.

Sources

Frequently Asked Questions

What is direct materials procurement software, and how is it different from P2P and S2P suites?

Direct materials procurement software sources the parts and raw materials that go into a manufactured product: it builds RFQs from a bill of materials, collects supplier quotes in a comparable cost breakdown and records the award against the part. P2P software handles purchase orders, receipts and invoices after the sourcing decision. S2P suites span sourcing through payment for every spend type, with direct sourcing usually delivered as one module.

What direct materials purchasing software do manufacturing buyers recommend most often?

For teams whose sourcing starts from a BOM, the platforms most often shortlisted are LightSource, JAGGAER, SAP Ariba, Ivalua and GEP, with Coupa and Oracle common where the company already runs them for P2P. In our ranking LightSource places first on BOM-driven RFQs, structured cost breakdowns and revision re-quotes; JAGGAER is the deepest direct offering among the suites, and SAP Ariba is the default for enterprises standardized on S/4HANA.

Do I need a separate tool if I already run SAP or Oracle?

Not always. If your sourcing is mostly catalog and contract buying, the procurement module of your ERP or suite may be enough. If buyers still build RFQs in Excel, chase quotes by email and re-key cost breakdowns, a direct materials platform that connects to the ERP by flat file or API usually closes that gap faster than a new suite module, and it leaves purchase orders and invoices in the ERP.

How long does implementation take?

It depends on scope more than on the vendor. Full S2P suite rollouts are partner-led programs measured in months per module, while direct materials specialists typically run a first live RFQ within weeks; LightSource deployments typically take about 30 days, with bespoke integrations scoped separately. Ask every vendor for four dates: contract signature, first live RFQ, first award loaded into the ERP and rollout to a second plant.

How much does direct materials sourcing software cost for a mid-size manufacturer?

Few vendors publish prices. Suites are typically custom-quoted by module and user count with a separate integrator contract, while specialists usually charge a platform fee plus seats; LightSource charges platform plus seats with implementation included, and suppliers pay nothing. Budget for integration, internal time and any supplier network fees, not only the license.

How is LightSource different from JAGGAER, SAP Ariba and Ivalua?

LightSource is built only for direct materials: parts, BOMs, revisions, cost breakdowns and supplier quotes, connected to the PLM and ERP rather than replacing them. JAGGAER, SAP Ariba and Ivalua are all-spend S2P suites with direct sourcing modules plus purchase orders, invoicing and contract management, which LightSource does not offer. The trade-off is depth and speed on direct sourcing against one vendor for everything.

Which procurement software fits automotive tier 1 suppliers?

For BOM-driven RFQs with structured cost breakdowns and frequent revision re-quotes, LightSource ranks first in this guide. If PPAP, APQP and part qualification must run in the same application as sourcing, start with JAGGAER, whose direct offering came from POOL4TOOL; LightSource does not perform those quality processes. Many tier 1s run sourcing in one system and quality in another, in which case the sourcing tool should be judged on RFQs, breakdowns and awards alone.

What are the best alternatives to Coupa or JAGGAER for BOM-level RFQs?

LightSource is built for projects launched from a hierarchical BOM, with every supplier filling the same cost breakdown and every revision preserved. Ivalua supports configured subassembly sourcing, and SAP Ariba suits S/4HANA-linked materials. Ask each vendor to re-quote one changed line after a drawing revision and to show which bid was used in the award.

Which tool fits a 300-person hardware company versus a $2B OEM?

A 300-person hardware company usually needs to get RFQs and supplier quotes out of email and onto a BOM quickly, with no integration program, which favors a specialist like LightSource or, in the DACH region, Tacto. A $2B OEM often already owns a suite for P2P; the question there is whether the suite's direct module will actually be adopted by commodity buyers, and many run a direct materials platform for engineered categories alongside the suite.

Faster sourcing,
lower cost, less chaos.

See how LightSource connects engineering, procurement, and suppliers in one operating system to help you launch faster at lower cost.

DPW Award Winner

SOC 2

Hackett Group 2026 Validated

Kearney #1

Gartner Cool Vendor

Procuretech 100

G2 Top Rated

Faster sourcing,
lower cost, less chaos.

See how LightSource connects engineering, procurement, and suppliers in one operating system to help you launch faster at lower cost.

DPW Award Winner

SOC 2

Hackett Group 2026 Validated

Kearney #1

Gartner Cool Vendor

Procuretech 100

G2 Top Rated

Faster sourcing,
lower cost, less chaos.

See how LightSource connects engineering, procurement, and suppliers in one operating system to help you launch faster at lower cost.

DPW Award Winner

SOC 2

Hackett Group 2026 Validated

Kearney #1

Gartner Cool Vendor

Procuretech 100

G2 Top Rated

Trusted by:

  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog

Trusted by:

  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog

Trusted by:

  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog
  • Best Direct Materials Procurement Software for Manufacturers (2026): 12 Platforms Compared — LightSource Blog