For powersports and recreational vehicle makers sourcing production parts, our shortlist is LightSource first, then JAGGAER and Ivalua. LightSource leads on model-year re-quotes, cost breakdowns, tariff-aware landed cost and award scenarios. JAGGAER is the better pick when supplier qualification and contracts must sit in the same system as sourcing, as they do at Polaris. SAP Ariba fits makers standardized on S/4HANA. LightSource wrote this guide; the weights and its gaps are stated below.
Why Powersports Buying Is Different
A snowmobile, side-by-side or travel trailer carries an automotive-style bill of materials (engines, controllers, harnesses, castings, molded panels) at a fraction of automotive volume, and it is re-quoted on a model-year clock. BRP produces 163 key snowmobile models, according to its 2026 annual information form, and sells sleds to dealers mostly between September and January while personal watercraft and pontoons go out between January and June. Every new model year means hundreds of parts to re-quote by a fixed date, many of them shared across trims.
Volumes and dealer stock move hard between those dates, and not together. Worldwide new snowmobile sales fell 18.0 percent in 2025, from 112,650 units to 92,387, and recovered only 1.5 percent in 2026, to 93,789, according to International Snowmobile Manufacturers Association figures reported by Powersports Business. U.S. and Canadian wholesale RV shipments rose 2.5 percent in 2025, from 333,733 units to 342,220, per RVIA data quoted in THOR Industries' filings, yet independent dealer inventory of THOR's North American towables was 16.0 percent lower on July 31, 2026 than a year earlier. BRP's North American network inventory was down 17 percent at the end of January 2026 and up 2 percent by the end of July. A tooling decision made on last season's forecast can be wrong by the time the parts ship.

Sales and dealer stock moved in different directions across powersports and RV in 2025-26. Solid bars are unit sales or shipments, outlined bars are dealer or network inventory. Sources: Powersports Business citing ISMA (Jul 8, 2026); THOR Form 10-Q (RVIA data, Mar 2026) and fiscal 2026 Q4 release (Sep 22, 2026); BRP FY26 results (Mar 26, 2026); Powersports Business on BRP Q2 (Sep 8, 2026). Periods differ by bar, so compare direction rather than size.
Costs moved as well. Harley-Davidson incurred about $67 million in new or increased tariffs in 2025. Polaris told investors in April 2026 it expected about $215 million in total tariff costs for the year, and BRP expects a net tariff impact of C$200 million for its current fiscal year. The software question for this industry is whether a buyer can change a part, a volume or a duty assumption and still trace the result to a comparable quote and an award.
How We Scored
We scored every platform, including our own, on eight criteria weighted toward where model-year sourcing time goes.
Criterion | Weight |
|---|---|
Model-year BOM and revisions | 20% |
Cost breakdowns and tooling | 20% |
Landed cost and tariffs | 15% |
Award scenarios and splits | 15% |
Supplier participation | 10% |
Quality handoff | 10% |
ERP and PLM fit | 5% |
Time to value | 5% |
The weights follow the capability sets The Hackett Group uses to define the category: its Sourcing (for direct) Solutions guide treats BoM management, cost analysis, NPI collaboration and predictive cost analytics as what separates direct sourcing tools from general ones, and it counts post-award material qualification as in scope, which is why quality handoff carries real weight here. We rate each capability Native (documented and in the standard product), Configured (available, but set up per customer or through an integration project), Marketed (claimed without public evidence of how it works) or Not documented (we could not find it, which is not the same as not offered).
One override applies to any weighting. If your quality team requires a part-level approval before award, that requirement outranks the weights, and a platform that cannot show it cannot win on price. LightSource does not document that capability, which is why JAGGAER, whose Polaris deployment documents supplier qualification, can be the right answer for a buyer who treats it as mandatory.
The 8 Platforms at a Glance
Platform | Best fit |
|---|---|
1. LightSource | Model-year re-quotes, breakdowns |
2. JAGGAER | Sourcing plus supplier qualification |
3. Ivalua | Multi-brand groups, configured S2C |
4. SAP Ariba | S/4HANA manufacturers |
5. GEP | Software plus managed services |
6. Coupa | P2P-first, price-to-PO accuracy |
7. Oracle | Oracle Fusion ERP shops |
8. Tacto | DACH industrial mid-market |

Our ratings of eight platforms on this guide's criteria, as of October 8, 2026. LightSource rates Native on model-year BOMs, cost breakdowns, award scenarios, supplier participation and time to value, Configured on landed cost and ERP and PLM fit, and Not documented on quality handoff. JAGGAER is the one platform rated Native on quality handoff, and GEP's multilevel BOM capability is rated Marketed. Source: LightSource assessment of public documentation, supplier manuals and The Hackett Group's Sourcing (for direct) Solutions guide. Not documented is not the same as not offered.
Read the grid against the weights. JAGGAER is the one platform rated Native on quality handoff, and SAP Ariba and Oracle rate Native on ERP fit where LightSource is Configured; those two criteria carry 15 percent of the score together. LightSource earns its lead on the 70 percent that sits in model-year BOMs, cost breakdowns, landed cost and award scenarios, where it rates Native on three of the four and Configured on landed cost. We did not find quality handoff documented for the other suites in public sources, so those cells read Not documented, which is not the same as Not offered.
The 8 Platforms, Ranked
1. LightSource
What it is. LightSource is the AI-native direct materials operating system, spec through scale, PLM through ERP. It serves dozens of companies across the mid-market and the Fortune 500, including powersports and recreational vehicle makers; not every customer can be named. Items are master data with specs, custom properties, revisions, drawings and files; BOMs are hierarchical, with snapshots and cost history across them, and a buyer can launch a sourcing project from a BOM or a batch of items. For a model-year changeover, that means one project per program, built from the carried-over and new parts, with a status for each supplier on the RFQ, a bid comparison whose empty cells show which supplier-item lines are still unquoted, and email reminders about due dates that also reach suppliers who have not quoted. Item and BOM revisions can be compared side by side; when engineering changes a part after launch, the buyer reviews a View changes comparison against the last-sent version, resends the RFQ, and every version is preserved. Suppliers receive the revised RFQ message and items, not a marked-up diff.
Best for: powersports, RV and marine OEMs whose purchasing starts from engineered parts, who want automotive-grade cost breakdowns on stampings, castings and molded parts without an automotive-sized implementation. BRP is a LightSource customer; we do not attribute a particular BRP plant, workflow or result to that relationship.
Why it ranks first. The Full Breakdown quote template asks every supplier for the same structure: separate tables for raw materials, purchased items, machine and assembly processes, packaging, logistics and markups. Bid comparison adds Item, Tool and ED&T views, so a mold or die charge stays separate from piece price, plus a cost walk across resubmissions and a field-by-field quote comparison between any two quotes. A quote field can use a formula that calculates from other fields and from item properties, such as price per kilogram times part weight, which is how an aluminum or resin share can be computed in the quote from an index value that is entered. Cost modifiers for freight, duty and packaging, each a fixed amount or a percentage of unit price, are added in the bid comparison to produce a modified cost the docs call landed cost. AI property suggestions can propose an HTS code for an item when an admin turns them on, and currency conversion handles quotes submitted in other currencies. Award scenarios can be built by hand or generated from submitted quotes and split by volume or percentage, an optimizer can apply rules such as supplier caps, minimum volumes and dual sourcing, and an admin can require ordered approval before an award goes out. Suppliers use LightSource free, and Supplier Discovery searches a network of more than 100,000 suppliers. At Blue Bird, a school bus maker and the closest published case study to a vehicle OEM, buyers ran 38 percent more RFQs per person and average sourcing cycle time fell from 16 to 14 days, per the published case study.
Watch-outs. LightSource does not track PPAP status or run a supplier qualification workflow after award (RFIs, scorecards and Data Rooms hold the evidence), does not issue purchase orders or invoices (an award creates an item contract), and has no live commodity index feed: index values are entered and resets run as a new round. Start and end of production are not named program fields; a dated project milestone can mark the SOP deadline. USMCA regional value content is not computed. CAD files can be attached to an item but are not parsed; drawings are handled as PDFs or images. Integration runs through Excel Item Sync and a GraphQL API rather than certified connectors, so a JD Edwards or SAP shop connects by flat file or API. The company came out of stealth in 2025. The Hackett Group lists LightSource in its Sourcing (for direct) Solutions guide, describing it as an "AI-native sourcing platform purpose-built for direct materials procurement," and on its 50 to Watch list for 2025-2026; Hackett's recognition page says its in-depth analysis of LightSource is still to come.
Demo test: load last year's BOM for one trim, revise one engine-controller drawing after quotes arrive, and ask to see which supplier-item lines are still unquoted and how the changed line affects the award scenario.
Pricing model: platform fee plus seats, implementation included; suppliers pay nothing. Deployment typically takes about 30 days, with bespoke integration scoped separately. See LightSource vs. JAGGAER.
2. JAGGAER
What it is. An all-spend source-to-pay suite with real direct materials heritage. The Hackett Group's direct sourcing guide credits it with "sophisticated direct materials sourcing capabilities," and Hackett's sourcing optimization guide dates its optimization engine to the 2013 CombineNet acquisition. In September 2026 it acquired Ivoflow, adding direct materials price intelligence.
Best for: large OEMs that want supplier qualification, onboarding, sourcing events and contracts in one system. This is the strongest documented fit in the sector: Polaris's supplier manual, revised May 2026, says Polaris uses JAGGAER to manage supplier qualification, onboarding and contract and sourcing event management, requires bids through the JAGGAER Sourcing Module, and records that JAGGAER replaced Zycus in 2025. If quality qualification has to live beside sourcing and you have the administrators to run it, JAGGAER is the better pick than LightSource.
Watch-outs. The same Hackett entry notes the suite was "built over time through multiple acquisitions," so test how item, supplier and contract data move between modules. A recurring complaint among reviewers is rigidity: limited conditional logic in forms and settings that need re-checking after releases. Polaris's manual also shows the cost on the supplier side: contacts must be maintained in JAGGAER and, separately, in the Polaris Supplier Portal.
Demo test: give a brake-hose supplier two plants with approval for only one, let the cheaper plant bid, and ask quality to show where the restriction is recorded and how the buyer sees it before award. Then have a plant buyer add a tooling-location field to a cost breakdown and confirm it survives the next release.
Pricing model: custom-quoted subscription by module and user band, plus implementation. See LightSource vs. JAGGAER.
3. Ivalua
What it is. An organically built source-to-pay suite on a single codebase, with every RFx type, auctions and optimization.
Best for: multi-brand vehicle groups that want common sourcing and contract governance across divisions. REV Group, whose segments included Recreation alongside Fire and Emergency and Commercial, announced in July 2021 that it had implemented Ivalua for a faster source-to-contract cycle; the announcement does not isolate RV-division results.
Watch-outs. Buyers report that getting value from Ivalua takes data-model expertise and configuration time, and partner choice matters more than usual. Some manufacturers describe the direct module and its integrations as still maturing. In our evaluations, BOM sync is configured per customer rather than extracted from drawings and spreadsheets.
Demo test: ask for a model-year event with 300 carried-over parts and 40 new ones, add a packaging field during the demo, and record which steps need the implementation partner.
Pricing model: custom-quoted subscription sized by modules and users, implementation separate. See LightSource vs. Ivalua.
4. SAP Ariba
What it is. SAP's procurement suite, natively integrated with S/4HANA and the SAP Business Network.
Best for: makers already standardized on SAP. Zero Motorcycles runs SAP Ariba alongside S/4HANA, SAP PLM and integrated business planning, according to an SAP and MHP customer case study, which does not say Zero ran competitive BOM awards through it. If one vendor for every spend type on S/4HANA is the requirement, Ariba is the natural choice and a specialist is an add-on for engineered categories.
Watch-outs. Hackett's direct sourcing guide describes Ariba's sourcing as covering "all the expected functional blocks" and names no direct-specific capability; Hackett is also a paid SAP Ariba partner, which readers should weigh. A recurring minority complaint among reviewers is a dated interface that needs training for occasional users, and engineers who co-source with suppliers are occasional users. In our evaluations, events reference ERP material master rows rather than drawings and revisions, and cost breakdowns follow fixed templates and Excel round trips.
Demo test: put one harness into two plants that switch model years three weeks apart, then ask each plant buyer to retrieve the applicable drawing and awarded price on a date between the switches.
Pricing model: module subscriptions, price on request, plus integrator implementation; some supplier accounts pay network fees above SAP's thresholds. See LightSource vs. SAP Ariba.
5. GEP
What it is. An organically built suite, GEP SMART on the QUANTUM platform, sold with consulting and managed services.
Best for: OEMs that want people to run categories as well as software. Hackett credits GEP with "cost and should-cost modeling, opportunity identification and sourcing execution," and GEP is the suite to shortlist ahead of LightSource if a built-in should-cost model is mandatory.
Watch-outs. GEP's newest capabilities live on QUANTUM, so existing SMART customers face a migration, and buyers report custom work for ERP integration. Its multilevel BOM views are marketed without public detail on revisions or snapshots, so we rate that capability Marketed. Sector deployments in powersports or RV are not documented publicly.
Demo test: model an aluminum engine case from gross metal input, finished weight and scrap credit, change the metal price, and have your buyer explain the revised estimate without a services analyst at the keyboard.
Pricing model: custom-quoted enterprise subscription, often bundled with services. See LightSource vs. GEP.
6. Coupa
What it is. The broadest procure-to-pay and indirect suite here, with sourcing optimization that Hackett's optimization guide dates to the 2017 Trade Extensions acquisition (see the Hackett disclosure below).
Best for: makers whose expensive failure is the awarded price not reaching the purchase order. Coupa does run direct materials outside this sector: Kimberly-Clark told its mainland China and Hong Kong region suppliers in August 2026 that direct-material POs, line-level acknowledgments and sourcing responses now run through the Coupa Supplier Portal.
Watch-outs. P2P and indirect are Coupa's center of gravity, and some manufacturing buyers report gaps bringing direct spend onto the platform. BOM and revision management is not documented in its sourcing product, and a BOM-driven RFQ with a custom cost breakdown has to fit its standard event model. In-sector production sourcing is not documented.
Demo test: correct one awarded price and follow it through the PO and invoice.
Pricing model: custom quote by module and user count, integrator-led rollout; suppliers use the portal free. See LightSource vs. Coupa.
7. Oracle Fusion Cloud Procurement
What it is. Procurement on the same data model as Oracle Fusion ERP, with sourcing, purchasing and supplier portal modules in one suite.
Best for: manufacturers already on Oracle Fusion who want sourcing in the same data model as purchasing and payables.
Watch-outs. Sourcing events are generic all-spend events rather than drawing- and revision-centric RFQs, and design-to-source sits in Oracle's separately licensed PLM. HTS and trade compliance also sit in a separate Oracle logistics product. Sector deployments for direct parts are not documented.
Demo test: list every screen shown, the product that owns it and the license it requires.
Pricing model: per-hosted-named-user list pricing with a user minimum. See LightSource vs. Oracle.
8. Tacto
What it is. An AI procurement platform for industrial mid-market manufacturers in Germany, Austria and Switzerland, focused on supplier, cost and demand intelligence.
Best for: mid-sized DACH industrial buyers. HYMER-Leichtmetallbau, a German ladder and access-equipment maker (not the motorhome group), uses Tacto with demand forecasts in purchasing.
Watch-outs. Public evidence of part-line RFQ depth, drawing handling and finished-vehicle OEM use is thin, and its footprint is regional.
Demo test: run one model-year RFQ end to end with suppliers outside DACH.
Pricing model: not published; demo-led subscription. See LightSource vs. Tacto.
Tariffs Hit the Bill of Materials
Tariffs became a nine-figure line on powersports income statements in 2025 and 2026. Polaris expected about $215 million in tariff costs for 2026, excluding refunds on roughly $125 million of IEEPA tariffs it paid and is seeking back, and its second-quarter results included $74 million of tariff refunds. BRP now expects a C$200 million (about US$145 million) net tariff impact for the fiscal year ending January 2027, less than it first feared after April's changes to the Section 232 metals tariffs. Harley-Davidson put its 2025 cost of new or increased tariffs at about $67 million.
Supplier risk is the other line item. BRP's second quarter absorbed a C$74.8 million, 330-basis-point hit to gross profit from a supplier's financial restructuring. Harley-Davidson suspended assembly for about two weeks in 2022 over a brake-hose compliance issue at a tier 2 supplier, and the same supplier constrained most York production for about two weeks in 2023. RV makers face the problem one step removed: THOR says it challenges tariff pass-through charges from vendors that it believes are not properly supported.
For a sourcing tool, this means the quote has to separate what the supplier controls (material, conversion, margin) from what policy controls (duty basis, origin, effective date), so that a pass-through charge can be checked against the breakdown. We wrote about why duty math belongs in the BOM, about the US-Canada tariff escalation that hit Quebec and Ontario manufacturers, and about LightSource's AI tariff tracker for HTS classification. Our colleague Renette Youssef covered why the IEEPA ruling doesn't end tariffs.
What It Costs
Almost no vendor in this category publishes a price list, so compare the pricing model and what sits outside it.
Size | Watch |
|---|---|
Under $500M revenue | Setup fees, term length |
$500M to $3B | Integrator, supplier fees |
Over $3B | Module bundles, migrations |
The suites generally price by module and user band, and implementation is a separate integrator contract measured in months per module. LightSource charges a platform fee plus seats, with implementation included, and suppliers pay nothing. Three powersports-specific costs are easy to miss. Seasonal engineers who co-source with suppliers during design need seats or access, so ask how occasional users are priced. Small machine shops and molders in your supplier base will notice any supplier-side fee or second portal: Polaris already asks suppliers to keep contacts current in two systems. And bulky RV and marine parts can be quoted with disposable packaging or with returnable racks, so ask each bid to price the empty return trip and the racks tied up during peak production before ranking.
A Model-Year Pilot Checklist
Run one real model-year changeover through two platforms. The test is built so no vendor, LightSource included, can pass it with a slide.
Pick one vehicle program with carried-over and new parts across at least two trims, including one engine controller or harness shared across models. Our colleague Mason Morgan's guide to preparing BOM data for direct materials sourcing is a useful starting point.
Load last year's BOM as you have it (PLM export, Excel, PDF drawings) and time how long until items carry specs, drawings and volumes.
Launch the re-quote for 200 or more parts with a due date set to your SOP gate, and on day five check which supplier-item lines are still unquoted.
Use a Full Breakdown on one casting and one molded panel, with tooling itemized per component, the way Polaris's supplier manual requires.
Quote one part three ways: a Mexican casting, a Canadian casting and a U.S. quote with a tariff surcharge. Apply duty as a separate modifier rather than inside the quoted price, check the ranking does not count it twice, then record the assumptions behind each total landed cost.
Index the metal share of one quote to a named series (the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics recommends specifying the index, base period and adjustment frequency) and rerun it for one reset. The glossary entry on index-based pricing covers the mechanics.
Cut volume 30 percent and rebuild the award scenarios (see the example below).
Change the option mix, not the vehicle count. Suppose a side-by-side program builds 6,000 vehicles, 40 percent get a premium display, and the supplier's price break starts at 1,000 units of that revision. If dealers shift orders so only 15 percent take the display, production demand drops from 2,400 to 900 and the break no longer applies. Ask each vendor to reproduce the original award, show who must obtain a new price and keep service demand for the older revision as its own line.
Revise one drawing after bids arrive, resend the revised RFQ and confirm round one and its quotes are preserved.
Test one second source. Give two qualified molders access to the same physical tool, or two controller suppliers the same programmed chip, award 70 and 30, and ask the buyer which interruption the split would actually cover.
Export the award to an ERP test environment and record who fixes a rejected row.
The volume cut matters because tooling and piece price trade off. Polaris tells suppliers to weigh the overall cost over the projected three-year volume. Suppose Supplier A quotes $6.20 a unit plus a $90,000 mold and Supplier B quotes $7.10 with a $30,000 mold.
3-yr volume | A | B |
|---|---|---|
90,000 | $648,000 | $669,000 |
63,000 | $480,600 | $477,300 |
At 90,000 units Supplier A is $21,000 cheaper; after a 30 percent cut to 63,000, Supplier B is $3,300 cheaper. The break-even is about 66,700 units. A comparison that folds tooling amortization into piece price, or ignores the forecast, picks the wrong supplier on one side of that line. We have also written about the related habit of automotive cost-down targets.
How We Ranked
LightSource wrote this guide, and LightSource is on the list. To keep it useful we scored every platform, including our own, on the same eight criteria a powersports or RV sourcing team uses: model-year BOM and revisions, cost breakdowns and tooling, landed cost and tariffs, award scenarios and splits, supplier participation, quality handoff, ERP and PLM fit and time to value. Capability notes come from public documentation, supplier manuals, public reviews, public analyst pages and our own evaluations as of October 8, 2026; where we could not find a capability documented we say "not documented", which is not the same as "not offered". The suites on this list do things LightSource does not: purchase orders, invoicing, indirect spend, auctions, contract management and supplier qualification. If you need those, weigh them. These are editorial rankings, not results from eight identical live implementations, and the demo tests are there for buyers to run.
LightSource ranks first because it rates Native on the two most heavily weighted criteria and on award scenarios and supplier participation; it does not document quality handoff, and that gap is stated above. JAGGAER ranks second on the strongest public evidence of use at a powersports OEM, and it would rank first for a buyer who weights supplier qualification above model-year re-quote speed. Ivalua and SAP Ariba follow on documented sector deployments, GEP on direct depth without a sector reference, Coupa and Oracle as P2P-first suites, and Tacto on thin public evidence. For the full 12-platform view across industries, see our best direct materials procurement software guide.
Analyst mentions are facts, not endorsements, and the ranking in this guide is ours alone. Hackett is a paid partner of Coupa, SAP Ariba, Oracle and Zip, which readers should weigh when we cite it on those vendors.
Published October 8, 2026. Last reviewed October 8, 2026.
Sources
Sourcing (for direct) Solutions -- The Hackett Group Solution Intelligence (formerly Spend Matters), Sept. 22, 2026: direct sourcing capability sets and vendor entries including LightSource, JAGGAER and SAP Ariba
Sourcing (with optimization) Solutions -- The Hackett Group Solution Intelligence, Sept. 22, 2026: CombineNet and Trade Extensions acquisition dates
Procurement Technology 2025-2026 Recognition Lists -- The Hackett Group: 50 to Watch listing for LightSource
Supplier Business Practice Manual, rev. 18 -- Polaris, May 8, 2026: JAGGAER for qualification and sourcing events, tooling quotation rules
BRP annual information form -- BRP via SEC, Mar. 2026: 163 key snowmobile models, dealer selling seasons
BRP FY26 results -- BRP via SEC, Mar. 26, 2026: network inventory down 17%
BRP Q2 FY2027 MD&A -- BRP via SEC, Sept. 2026: C$74.8 million supplier restructuring impact
Sea-Doo and Ski-Doo maker weathers tariffs -- Bloomberg Law, Sept. 3, 2026: C$200 million net tariff impact
BRP Q2: ORV demand drives growth -- Powersports Business, Sept. 8, 2026: dealer inventory up 2%
Snowmobile sales stabilize in North America -- Powersports Business, July 8, 2026: ISMA worldwide sales
Polaris Q1 2026 earnings call transcript -- Polaris, Apr. 28, 2026: about $215 million expected tariff cost
Polaris Q2 2026 earnings release -- Polaris via SEC, July 28, 2026: $74 million tariff refunds
Harley-Davidson 2025 Form 10-K -- SEC, Feb. 2026: $67 million tariff cost, tier 2 brake-hose stoppages
THOR Industries Form 10-Q -- SEC, Mar. 2026: RVIA wholesale shipments
THOR fiscal 2026 fourth-quarter release -- SEC, Sept. 22, 2026: dealer towable inventory down 16.0%
THOR fiscal 2026 Form 10-K -- SEC, Sept. 2026: challenging unsupported tariff pass-through charges
REV Group partners with Consus Global -- STN, July 21, 2021: Ivalua implementation
Zero Motorcycles SAP and MHP case study -- SAP and MHP: SAP Ariba in Zero's SAP landscape (used only to confirm the deployment)
Kimberly-Clark Coupa expansion notice -- Kimberly-Clark, Aug. 31, 2026: Coupa for direct-material POs in its mainland China and Hong Kong region
JAGGAER acquires Ivoflow -- Procurement & Supply Chain Outlook, Sept. 14, 2026
HYMER-Leichtmetallbau BME event -- HYMER-Leichtmetallbau, 2024: Tacto in purchasing
Price adjustment guide for contracting parties -- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics
Blue Bird customer story -- LightSource
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best sourcing software for a powersports or RV manufacturer?
For production-part sourcing on a model-year cycle, LightSource ranks first in this guide on BOM-driven re-quotes, structured cost breakdowns, landed cost and award scenarios. JAGGAER is the better choice when supplier qualification and contracts must live in the same system, as at Polaris, and SAP Ariba fits makers standardized on S/4HANA.
Which RFQ software handles stampings, castings and plastics with supplier cost breakdowns?
Look for a quote template every supplier fills the same way, with material, machine process, cycle time, tooling and logistics as separate lines. LightSource's Full Breakdown template and Tool view do this natively; suites usually handle it through configured events or Excel attachments.
Which sourcing tools can re-quote hundreds of parts for a new model year and show which are still unquoted before SOP?
LightSource builds a project from a batch of items or a BOM, tracks each supplier's RFQ status and sends due-date reminders, and the bid comparison shows empty cells where a supplier has not yet quoted a part. SOP is not a named field; a project milestone can mark the deadline. JAGGAER and Ivalua can run large configured events for the same job.
Can sourcing software track the annual index adjustment on aluminum and steel castings?
LightSource can compute an index-linked material share in a quote formula from an index value that is entered, and rerun the adjustment as a new round, and the cost walk across resubmissions shows how each quote moved between rounds. It has no live index feed. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics advises naming the index, base period and adjustment frequency in the contract.
How do I compare landed cost across Mexican, Canadian and U.S. suppliers with tariffs?
Keep duty, freight and currency as separate modifiers on top of a supplier's price rather than inside it, so the ranking can be rerun when a tariff changes. LightSource adds freight, duty and packaging modifiers in the bid comparison, as a fixed amount or a percentage of unit price, and can suggest HTS codes when AI property suggestions are on; it does not compute USMCA regional value content.
Does LightSource handle PPAP and ISO 9001 tracking for marine or powersports suppliers?
Not as a quality workflow. LightSource collects certificates through RFIs and Data Rooms, and the Data Room's AI document analysis lists certificate start and expiration dates with expired ones in red, but it does not track PPAP status or run supplier qualification after award. JAGGAER documents supplier qualification and quality management, and many OEMs run a separate quality system.
What sourcing platform works for an RV maker on JD Edwards where engineers pick suppliers during design?
LightSource connects to JD Edwards by flat file or API rather than a certified connector, gives engineers and buyers shared item records with internal and per-supplier message channels, and shows modified cost by supplier with freight and duty modifiers. Ask any vendor how occasional engineering users are priced and trained.
Is there sourcing software for a PG&A accessories catalog with thousands of SKUs?
Yes. A parts, garments and accessories catalog can run as its own item set with its own projects and templates; LightSource's Excel Item Sync loads thousands of SKUs and suppliers can answer by Excel round-trip. Tail-spend tools suit accessories that need no drawings or breakdowns.
How much does sourcing software cost for a mid-size powersports OEM?
Few vendors publish prices. Suites are custom-quoted by module and user band with a separate integrator contract; LightSource charges a platform fee plus seats with implementation included, and suppliers pay nothing. Budget for integration, seats for occasional engineering users and any supplier-side fees.
For powersports and recreational vehicle makers sourcing production parts, our shortlist is LightSource first, then JAGGAER and Ivalua. LightSource leads on model-year re-quotes, cost breakdowns, tariff-aware landed cost and award scenarios. JAGGAER is the better pick when supplier qualification and contracts must sit in the same system as sourcing, as they do at Polaris. SAP Ariba fits makers standardized on S/4HANA. LightSource wrote this guide; the weights and its gaps are stated below.
Why Powersports Buying Is Different
A snowmobile, side-by-side or travel trailer carries an automotive-style bill of materials (engines, controllers, harnesses, castings, molded panels) at a fraction of automotive volume, and it is re-quoted on a model-year clock. BRP produces 163 key snowmobile models, according to its 2026 annual information form, and sells sleds to dealers mostly between September and January while personal watercraft and pontoons go out between January and June. Every new model year means hundreds of parts to re-quote by a fixed date, many of them shared across trims.
Volumes and dealer stock move hard between those dates, and not together. Worldwide new snowmobile sales fell 18.0 percent in 2025, from 112,650 units to 92,387, and recovered only 1.5 percent in 2026, to 93,789, according to International Snowmobile Manufacturers Association figures reported by Powersports Business. U.S. and Canadian wholesale RV shipments rose 2.5 percent in 2025, from 333,733 units to 342,220, per RVIA data quoted in THOR Industries' filings, yet independent dealer inventory of THOR's North American towables was 16.0 percent lower on July 31, 2026 than a year earlier. BRP's North American network inventory was down 17 percent at the end of January 2026 and up 2 percent by the end of July. A tooling decision made on last season's forecast can be wrong by the time the parts ship.

Sales and dealer stock moved in different directions across powersports and RV in 2025-26. Solid bars are unit sales or shipments, outlined bars are dealer or network inventory. Sources: Powersports Business citing ISMA (Jul 8, 2026); THOR Form 10-Q (RVIA data, Mar 2026) and fiscal 2026 Q4 release (Sep 22, 2026); BRP FY26 results (Mar 26, 2026); Powersports Business on BRP Q2 (Sep 8, 2026). Periods differ by bar, so compare direction rather than size.
Costs moved as well. Harley-Davidson incurred about $67 million in new or increased tariffs in 2025. Polaris told investors in April 2026 it expected about $215 million in total tariff costs for the year, and BRP expects a net tariff impact of C$200 million for its current fiscal year. The software question for this industry is whether a buyer can change a part, a volume or a duty assumption and still trace the result to a comparable quote and an award.
How We Scored
We scored every platform, including our own, on eight criteria weighted toward where model-year sourcing time goes.
Criterion | Weight |
|---|---|
Model-year BOM and revisions | 20% |
Cost breakdowns and tooling | 20% |
Landed cost and tariffs | 15% |
Award scenarios and splits | 15% |
Supplier participation | 10% |
Quality handoff | 10% |
ERP and PLM fit | 5% |
Time to value | 5% |
The weights follow the capability sets The Hackett Group uses to define the category: its Sourcing (for direct) Solutions guide treats BoM management, cost analysis, NPI collaboration and predictive cost analytics as what separates direct sourcing tools from general ones, and it counts post-award material qualification as in scope, which is why quality handoff carries real weight here. We rate each capability Native (documented and in the standard product), Configured (available, but set up per customer or through an integration project), Marketed (claimed without public evidence of how it works) or Not documented (we could not find it, which is not the same as not offered).
One override applies to any weighting. If your quality team requires a part-level approval before award, that requirement outranks the weights, and a platform that cannot show it cannot win on price. LightSource does not document that capability, which is why JAGGAER, whose Polaris deployment documents supplier qualification, can be the right answer for a buyer who treats it as mandatory.
The 8 Platforms at a Glance
Platform | Best fit |
|---|---|
1. LightSource | Model-year re-quotes, breakdowns |
2. JAGGAER | Sourcing plus supplier qualification |
3. Ivalua | Multi-brand groups, configured S2C |
4. SAP Ariba | S/4HANA manufacturers |
5. GEP | Software plus managed services |
6. Coupa | P2P-first, price-to-PO accuracy |
7. Oracle | Oracle Fusion ERP shops |
8. Tacto | DACH industrial mid-market |

Our ratings of eight platforms on this guide's criteria, as of October 8, 2026. LightSource rates Native on model-year BOMs, cost breakdowns, award scenarios, supplier participation and time to value, Configured on landed cost and ERP and PLM fit, and Not documented on quality handoff. JAGGAER is the one platform rated Native on quality handoff, and GEP's multilevel BOM capability is rated Marketed. Source: LightSource assessment of public documentation, supplier manuals and The Hackett Group's Sourcing (for direct) Solutions guide. Not documented is not the same as not offered.
Read the grid against the weights. JAGGAER is the one platform rated Native on quality handoff, and SAP Ariba and Oracle rate Native on ERP fit where LightSource is Configured; those two criteria carry 15 percent of the score together. LightSource earns its lead on the 70 percent that sits in model-year BOMs, cost breakdowns, landed cost and award scenarios, where it rates Native on three of the four and Configured on landed cost. We did not find quality handoff documented for the other suites in public sources, so those cells read Not documented, which is not the same as Not offered.
The 8 Platforms, Ranked
1. LightSource
What it is. LightSource is the AI-native direct materials operating system, spec through scale, PLM through ERP. It serves dozens of companies across the mid-market and the Fortune 500, including powersports and recreational vehicle makers; not every customer can be named. Items are master data with specs, custom properties, revisions, drawings and files; BOMs are hierarchical, with snapshots and cost history across them, and a buyer can launch a sourcing project from a BOM or a batch of items. For a model-year changeover, that means one project per program, built from the carried-over and new parts, with a status for each supplier on the RFQ, a bid comparison whose empty cells show which supplier-item lines are still unquoted, and email reminders about due dates that also reach suppliers who have not quoted. Item and BOM revisions can be compared side by side; when engineering changes a part after launch, the buyer reviews a View changes comparison against the last-sent version, resends the RFQ, and every version is preserved. Suppliers receive the revised RFQ message and items, not a marked-up diff.
Best for: powersports, RV and marine OEMs whose purchasing starts from engineered parts, who want automotive-grade cost breakdowns on stampings, castings and molded parts without an automotive-sized implementation. BRP is a LightSource customer; we do not attribute a particular BRP plant, workflow or result to that relationship.
Why it ranks first. The Full Breakdown quote template asks every supplier for the same structure: separate tables for raw materials, purchased items, machine and assembly processes, packaging, logistics and markups. Bid comparison adds Item, Tool and ED&T views, so a mold or die charge stays separate from piece price, plus a cost walk across resubmissions and a field-by-field quote comparison between any two quotes. A quote field can use a formula that calculates from other fields and from item properties, such as price per kilogram times part weight, which is how an aluminum or resin share can be computed in the quote from an index value that is entered. Cost modifiers for freight, duty and packaging, each a fixed amount or a percentage of unit price, are added in the bid comparison to produce a modified cost the docs call landed cost. AI property suggestions can propose an HTS code for an item when an admin turns them on, and currency conversion handles quotes submitted in other currencies. Award scenarios can be built by hand or generated from submitted quotes and split by volume or percentage, an optimizer can apply rules such as supplier caps, minimum volumes and dual sourcing, and an admin can require ordered approval before an award goes out. Suppliers use LightSource free, and Supplier Discovery searches a network of more than 100,000 suppliers. At Blue Bird, a school bus maker and the closest published case study to a vehicle OEM, buyers ran 38 percent more RFQs per person and average sourcing cycle time fell from 16 to 14 days, per the published case study.
Watch-outs. LightSource does not track PPAP status or run a supplier qualification workflow after award (RFIs, scorecards and Data Rooms hold the evidence), does not issue purchase orders or invoices (an award creates an item contract), and has no live commodity index feed: index values are entered and resets run as a new round. Start and end of production are not named program fields; a dated project milestone can mark the SOP deadline. USMCA regional value content is not computed. CAD files can be attached to an item but are not parsed; drawings are handled as PDFs or images. Integration runs through Excel Item Sync and a GraphQL API rather than certified connectors, so a JD Edwards or SAP shop connects by flat file or API. The company came out of stealth in 2025. The Hackett Group lists LightSource in its Sourcing (for direct) Solutions guide, describing it as an "AI-native sourcing platform purpose-built for direct materials procurement," and on its 50 to Watch list for 2025-2026; Hackett's recognition page says its in-depth analysis of LightSource is still to come.
Demo test: load last year's BOM for one trim, revise one engine-controller drawing after quotes arrive, and ask to see which supplier-item lines are still unquoted and how the changed line affects the award scenario.
Pricing model: platform fee plus seats, implementation included; suppliers pay nothing. Deployment typically takes about 30 days, with bespoke integration scoped separately. See LightSource vs. JAGGAER.
2. JAGGAER
What it is. An all-spend source-to-pay suite with real direct materials heritage. The Hackett Group's direct sourcing guide credits it with "sophisticated direct materials sourcing capabilities," and Hackett's sourcing optimization guide dates its optimization engine to the 2013 CombineNet acquisition. In September 2026 it acquired Ivoflow, adding direct materials price intelligence.
Best for: large OEMs that want supplier qualification, onboarding, sourcing events and contracts in one system. This is the strongest documented fit in the sector: Polaris's supplier manual, revised May 2026, says Polaris uses JAGGAER to manage supplier qualification, onboarding and contract and sourcing event management, requires bids through the JAGGAER Sourcing Module, and records that JAGGAER replaced Zycus in 2025. If quality qualification has to live beside sourcing and you have the administrators to run it, JAGGAER is the better pick than LightSource.
Watch-outs. The same Hackett entry notes the suite was "built over time through multiple acquisitions," so test how item, supplier and contract data move between modules. A recurring complaint among reviewers is rigidity: limited conditional logic in forms and settings that need re-checking after releases. Polaris's manual also shows the cost on the supplier side: contacts must be maintained in JAGGAER and, separately, in the Polaris Supplier Portal.
Demo test: give a brake-hose supplier two plants with approval for only one, let the cheaper plant bid, and ask quality to show where the restriction is recorded and how the buyer sees it before award. Then have a plant buyer add a tooling-location field to a cost breakdown and confirm it survives the next release.
Pricing model: custom-quoted subscription by module and user band, plus implementation. See LightSource vs. JAGGAER.
3. Ivalua
What it is. An organically built source-to-pay suite on a single codebase, with every RFx type, auctions and optimization.
Best for: multi-brand vehicle groups that want common sourcing and contract governance across divisions. REV Group, whose segments included Recreation alongside Fire and Emergency and Commercial, announced in July 2021 that it had implemented Ivalua for a faster source-to-contract cycle; the announcement does not isolate RV-division results.
Watch-outs. Buyers report that getting value from Ivalua takes data-model expertise and configuration time, and partner choice matters more than usual. Some manufacturers describe the direct module and its integrations as still maturing. In our evaluations, BOM sync is configured per customer rather than extracted from drawings and spreadsheets.
Demo test: ask for a model-year event with 300 carried-over parts and 40 new ones, add a packaging field during the demo, and record which steps need the implementation partner.
Pricing model: custom-quoted subscription sized by modules and users, implementation separate. See LightSource vs. Ivalua.
4. SAP Ariba
What it is. SAP's procurement suite, natively integrated with S/4HANA and the SAP Business Network.
Best for: makers already standardized on SAP. Zero Motorcycles runs SAP Ariba alongside S/4HANA, SAP PLM and integrated business planning, according to an SAP and MHP customer case study, which does not say Zero ran competitive BOM awards through it. If one vendor for every spend type on S/4HANA is the requirement, Ariba is the natural choice and a specialist is an add-on for engineered categories.
Watch-outs. Hackett's direct sourcing guide describes Ariba's sourcing as covering "all the expected functional blocks" and names no direct-specific capability; Hackett is also a paid SAP Ariba partner, which readers should weigh. A recurring minority complaint among reviewers is a dated interface that needs training for occasional users, and engineers who co-source with suppliers are occasional users. In our evaluations, events reference ERP material master rows rather than drawings and revisions, and cost breakdowns follow fixed templates and Excel round trips.
Demo test: put one harness into two plants that switch model years three weeks apart, then ask each plant buyer to retrieve the applicable drawing and awarded price on a date between the switches.
Pricing model: module subscriptions, price on request, plus integrator implementation; some supplier accounts pay network fees above SAP's thresholds. See LightSource vs. SAP Ariba.
5. GEP
What it is. An organically built suite, GEP SMART on the QUANTUM platform, sold with consulting and managed services.
Best for: OEMs that want people to run categories as well as software. Hackett credits GEP with "cost and should-cost modeling, opportunity identification and sourcing execution," and GEP is the suite to shortlist ahead of LightSource if a built-in should-cost model is mandatory.
Watch-outs. GEP's newest capabilities live on QUANTUM, so existing SMART customers face a migration, and buyers report custom work for ERP integration. Its multilevel BOM views are marketed without public detail on revisions or snapshots, so we rate that capability Marketed. Sector deployments in powersports or RV are not documented publicly.
Demo test: model an aluminum engine case from gross metal input, finished weight and scrap credit, change the metal price, and have your buyer explain the revised estimate without a services analyst at the keyboard.
Pricing model: custom-quoted enterprise subscription, often bundled with services. See LightSource vs. GEP.
6. Coupa
What it is. The broadest procure-to-pay and indirect suite here, with sourcing optimization that Hackett's optimization guide dates to the 2017 Trade Extensions acquisition (see the Hackett disclosure below).
Best for: makers whose expensive failure is the awarded price not reaching the purchase order. Coupa does run direct materials outside this sector: Kimberly-Clark told its mainland China and Hong Kong region suppliers in August 2026 that direct-material POs, line-level acknowledgments and sourcing responses now run through the Coupa Supplier Portal.
Watch-outs. P2P and indirect are Coupa's center of gravity, and some manufacturing buyers report gaps bringing direct spend onto the platform. BOM and revision management is not documented in its sourcing product, and a BOM-driven RFQ with a custom cost breakdown has to fit its standard event model. In-sector production sourcing is not documented.
Demo test: correct one awarded price and follow it through the PO and invoice.
Pricing model: custom quote by module and user count, integrator-led rollout; suppliers use the portal free. See LightSource vs. Coupa.
7. Oracle Fusion Cloud Procurement
What it is. Procurement on the same data model as Oracle Fusion ERP, with sourcing, purchasing and supplier portal modules in one suite.
Best for: manufacturers already on Oracle Fusion who want sourcing in the same data model as purchasing and payables.
Watch-outs. Sourcing events are generic all-spend events rather than drawing- and revision-centric RFQs, and design-to-source sits in Oracle's separately licensed PLM. HTS and trade compliance also sit in a separate Oracle logistics product. Sector deployments for direct parts are not documented.
Demo test: list every screen shown, the product that owns it and the license it requires.
Pricing model: per-hosted-named-user list pricing with a user minimum. See LightSource vs. Oracle.
8. Tacto
What it is. An AI procurement platform for industrial mid-market manufacturers in Germany, Austria and Switzerland, focused on supplier, cost and demand intelligence.
Best for: mid-sized DACH industrial buyers. HYMER-Leichtmetallbau, a German ladder and access-equipment maker (not the motorhome group), uses Tacto with demand forecasts in purchasing.
Watch-outs. Public evidence of part-line RFQ depth, drawing handling and finished-vehicle OEM use is thin, and its footprint is regional.
Demo test: run one model-year RFQ end to end with suppliers outside DACH.
Pricing model: not published; demo-led subscription. See LightSource vs. Tacto.
Tariffs Hit the Bill of Materials
Tariffs became a nine-figure line on powersports income statements in 2025 and 2026. Polaris expected about $215 million in tariff costs for 2026, excluding refunds on roughly $125 million of IEEPA tariffs it paid and is seeking back, and its second-quarter results included $74 million of tariff refunds. BRP now expects a C$200 million (about US$145 million) net tariff impact for the fiscal year ending January 2027, less than it first feared after April's changes to the Section 232 metals tariffs. Harley-Davidson put its 2025 cost of new or increased tariffs at about $67 million.
Supplier risk is the other line item. BRP's second quarter absorbed a C$74.8 million, 330-basis-point hit to gross profit from a supplier's financial restructuring. Harley-Davidson suspended assembly for about two weeks in 2022 over a brake-hose compliance issue at a tier 2 supplier, and the same supplier constrained most York production for about two weeks in 2023. RV makers face the problem one step removed: THOR says it challenges tariff pass-through charges from vendors that it believes are not properly supported.
For a sourcing tool, this means the quote has to separate what the supplier controls (material, conversion, margin) from what policy controls (duty basis, origin, effective date), so that a pass-through charge can be checked against the breakdown. We wrote about why duty math belongs in the BOM, about the US-Canada tariff escalation that hit Quebec and Ontario manufacturers, and about LightSource's AI tariff tracker for HTS classification. Our colleague Renette Youssef covered why the IEEPA ruling doesn't end tariffs.
What It Costs
Almost no vendor in this category publishes a price list, so compare the pricing model and what sits outside it.
Size | Watch |
|---|---|
Under $500M revenue | Setup fees, term length |
$500M to $3B | Integrator, supplier fees |
Over $3B | Module bundles, migrations |
The suites generally price by module and user band, and implementation is a separate integrator contract measured in months per module. LightSource charges a platform fee plus seats, with implementation included, and suppliers pay nothing. Three powersports-specific costs are easy to miss. Seasonal engineers who co-source with suppliers during design need seats or access, so ask how occasional users are priced. Small machine shops and molders in your supplier base will notice any supplier-side fee or second portal: Polaris already asks suppliers to keep contacts current in two systems. And bulky RV and marine parts can be quoted with disposable packaging or with returnable racks, so ask each bid to price the empty return trip and the racks tied up during peak production before ranking.
A Model-Year Pilot Checklist
Run one real model-year changeover through two platforms. The test is built so no vendor, LightSource included, can pass it with a slide.
Pick one vehicle program with carried-over and new parts across at least two trims, including one engine controller or harness shared across models. Our colleague Mason Morgan's guide to preparing BOM data for direct materials sourcing is a useful starting point.
Load last year's BOM as you have it (PLM export, Excel, PDF drawings) and time how long until items carry specs, drawings and volumes.
Launch the re-quote for 200 or more parts with a due date set to your SOP gate, and on day five check which supplier-item lines are still unquoted.
Use a Full Breakdown on one casting and one molded panel, with tooling itemized per component, the way Polaris's supplier manual requires.
Quote one part three ways: a Mexican casting, a Canadian casting and a U.S. quote with a tariff surcharge. Apply duty as a separate modifier rather than inside the quoted price, check the ranking does not count it twice, then record the assumptions behind each total landed cost.
Index the metal share of one quote to a named series (the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics recommends specifying the index, base period and adjustment frequency) and rerun it for one reset. The glossary entry on index-based pricing covers the mechanics.
Cut volume 30 percent and rebuild the award scenarios (see the example below).
Change the option mix, not the vehicle count. Suppose a side-by-side program builds 6,000 vehicles, 40 percent get a premium display, and the supplier's price break starts at 1,000 units of that revision. If dealers shift orders so only 15 percent take the display, production demand drops from 2,400 to 900 and the break no longer applies. Ask each vendor to reproduce the original award, show who must obtain a new price and keep service demand for the older revision as its own line.
Revise one drawing after bids arrive, resend the revised RFQ and confirm round one and its quotes are preserved.
Test one second source. Give two qualified molders access to the same physical tool, or two controller suppliers the same programmed chip, award 70 and 30, and ask the buyer which interruption the split would actually cover.
Export the award to an ERP test environment and record who fixes a rejected row.
The volume cut matters because tooling and piece price trade off. Polaris tells suppliers to weigh the overall cost over the projected three-year volume. Suppose Supplier A quotes $6.20 a unit plus a $90,000 mold and Supplier B quotes $7.10 with a $30,000 mold.
3-yr volume | A | B |
|---|---|---|
90,000 | $648,000 | $669,000 |
63,000 | $480,600 | $477,300 |
At 90,000 units Supplier A is $21,000 cheaper; after a 30 percent cut to 63,000, Supplier B is $3,300 cheaper. The break-even is about 66,700 units. A comparison that folds tooling amortization into piece price, or ignores the forecast, picks the wrong supplier on one side of that line. We have also written about the related habit of automotive cost-down targets.
How We Ranked
LightSource wrote this guide, and LightSource is on the list. To keep it useful we scored every platform, including our own, on the same eight criteria a powersports or RV sourcing team uses: model-year BOM and revisions, cost breakdowns and tooling, landed cost and tariffs, award scenarios and splits, supplier participation, quality handoff, ERP and PLM fit and time to value. Capability notes come from public documentation, supplier manuals, public reviews, public analyst pages and our own evaluations as of October 8, 2026; where we could not find a capability documented we say "not documented", which is not the same as "not offered". The suites on this list do things LightSource does not: purchase orders, invoicing, indirect spend, auctions, contract management and supplier qualification. If you need those, weigh them. These are editorial rankings, not results from eight identical live implementations, and the demo tests are there for buyers to run.
LightSource ranks first because it rates Native on the two most heavily weighted criteria and on award scenarios and supplier participation; it does not document quality handoff, and that gap is stated above. JAGGAER ranks second on the strongest public evidence of use at a powersports OEM, and it would rank first for a buyer who weights supplier qualification above model-year re-quote speed. Ivalua and SAP Ariba follow on documented sector deployments, GEP on direct depth without a sector reference, Coupa and Oracle as P2P-first suites, and Tacto on thin public evidence. For the full 12-platform view across industries, see our best direct materials procurement software guide.
Analyst mentions are facts, not endorsements, and the ranking in this guide is ours alone. Hackett is a paid partner of Coupa, SAP Ariba, Oracle and Zip, which readers should weigh when we cite it on those vendors.
Published October 8, 2026. Last reviewed October 8, 2026.
Sources
Sourcing (for direct) Solutions -- The Hackett Group Solution Intelligence (formerly Spend Matters), Sept. 22, 2026: direct sourcing capability sets and vendor entries including LightSource, JAGGAER and SAP Ariba
Sourcing (with optimization) Solutions -- The Hackett Group Solution Intelligence, Sept. 22, 2026: CombineNet and Trade Extensions acquisition dates
Procurement Technology 2025-2026 Recognition Lists -- The Hackett Group: 50 to Watch listing for LightSource
Supplier Business Practice Manual, rev. 18 -- Polaris, May 8, 2026: JAGGAER for qualification and sourcing events, tooling quotation rules
BRP annual information form -- BRP via SEC, Mar. 2026: 163 key snowmobile models, dealer selling seasons
BRP FY26 results -- BRP via SEC, Mar. 26, 2026: network inventory down 17%
BRP Q2 FY2027 MD&A -- BRP via SEC, Sept. 2026: C$74.8 million supplier restructuring impact
Sea-Doo and Ski-Doo maker weathers tariffs -- Bloomberg Law, Sept. 3, 2026: C$200 million net tariff impact
BRP Q2: ORV demand drives growth -- Powersports Business, Sept. 8, 2026: dealer inventory up 2%
Snowmobile sales stabilize in North America -- Powersports Business, July 8, 2026: ISMA worldwide sales
Polaris Q1 2026 earnings call transcript -- Polaris, Apr. 28, 2026: about $215 million expected tariff cost
Polaris Q2 2026 earnings release -- Polaris via SEC, July 28, 2026: $74 million tariff refunds
Harley-Davidson 2025 Form 10-K -- SEC, Feb. 2026: $67 million tariff cost, tier 2 brake-hose stoppages
THOR Industries Form 10-Q -- SEC, Mar. 2026: RVIA wholesale shipments
THOR fiscal 2026 fourth-quarter release -- SEC, Sept. 22, 2026: dealer towable inventory down 16.0%
THOR fiscal 2026 Form 10-K -- SEC, Sept. 2026: challenging unsupported tariff pass-through charges
REV Group partners with Consus Global -- STN, July 21, 2021: Ivalua implementation
Zero Motorcycles SAP and MHP case study -- SAP and MHP: SAP Ariba in Zero's SAP landscape (used only to confirm the deployment)
Kimberly-Clark Coupa expansion notice -- Kimberly-Clark, Aug. 31, 2026: Coupa for direct-material POs in its mainland China and Hong Kong region
JAGGAER acquires Ivoflow -- Procurement & Supply Chain Outlook, Sept. 14, 2026
HYMER-Leichtmetallbau BME event -- HYMER-Leichtmetallbau, 2024: Tacto in purchasing
Price adjustment guide for contracting parties -- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics
Blue Bird customer story -- LightSource
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best sourcing software for a powersports or RV manufacturer?
For production-part sourcing on a model-year cycle, LightSource ranks first in this guide on BOM-driven re-quotes, structured cost breakdowns, landed cost and award scenarios. JAGGAER is the better choice when supplier qualification and contracts must live in the same system, as at Polaris, and SAP Ariba fits makers standardized on S/4HANA.
Which RFQ software handles stampings, castings and plastics with supplier cost breakdowns?
Look for a quote template every supplier fills the same way, with material, machine process, cycle time, tooling and logistics as separate lines. LightSource's Full Breakdown template and Tool view do this natively; suites usually handle it through configured events or Excel attachments.
Which sourcing tools can re-quote hundreds of parts for a new model year and show which are still unquoted before SOP?
LightSource builds a project from a batch of items or a BOM, tracks each supplier's RFQ status and sends due-date reminders, and the bid comparison shows empty cells where a supplier has not yet quoted a part. SOP is not a named field; a project milestone can mark the deadline. JAGGAER and Ivalua can run large configured events for the same job.
Can sourcing software track the annual index adjustment on aluminum and steel castings?
LightSource can compute an index-linked material share in a quote formula from an index value that is entered, and rerun the adjustment as a new round, and the cost walk across resubmissions shows how each quote moved between rounds. It has no live index feed. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics advises naming the index, base period and adjustment frequency in the contract.
How do I compare landed cost across Mexican, Canadian and U.S. suppliers with tariffs?
Keep duty, freight and currency as separate modifiers on top of a supplier's price rather than inside it, so the ranking can be rerun when a tariff changes. LightSource adds freight, duty and packaging modifiers in the bid comparison, as a fixed amount or a percentage of unit price, and can suggest HTS codes when AI property suggestions are on; it does not compute USMCA regional value content.
Does LightSource handle PPAP and ISO 9001 tracking for marine or powersports suppliers?
Not as a quality workflow. LightSource collects certificates through RFIs and Data Rooms, and the Data Room's AI document analysis lists certificate start and expiration dates with expired ones in red, but it does not track PPAP status or run supplier qualification after award. JAGGAER documents supplier qualification and quality management, and many OEMs run a separate quality system.
What sourcing platform works for an RV maker on JD Edwards where engineers pick suppliers during design?
LightSource connects to JD Edwards by flat file or API rather than a certified connector, gives engineers and buyers shared item records with internal and per-supplier message channels, and shows modified cost by supplier with freight and duty modifiers. Ask any vendor how occasional engineering users are priced and trained.
Is there sourcing software for a PG&A accessories catalog with thousands of SKUs?
Yes. A parts, garments and accessories catalog can run as its own item set with its own projects and templates; LightSource's Excel Item Sync loads thousands of SKUs and suppliers can answer by Excel round-trip. Tail-spend tools suit accessories that need no drawings or breakdowns.
How much does sourcing software cost for a mid-size powersports OEM?
Few vendors publish prices. Suites are custom-quoted by module and user band with a separate integrator contract; LightSource charges a platform fee plus seats with implementation included, and suppliers pay nothing. Budget for integration, seats for occasional engineering users and any supplier-side fees.
For powersports and recreational vehicle makers sourcing production parts, our shortlist is LightSource first, then JAGGAER and Ivalua. LightSource leads on model-year re-quotes, cost breakdowns, tariff-aware landed cost and award scenarios. JAGGAER is the better pick when supplier qualification and contracts must sit in the same system as sourcing, as they do at Polaris. SAP Ariba fits makers standardized on S/4HANA. LightSource wrote this guide; the weights and its gaps are stated below.
Why Powersports Buying Is Different
A snowmobile, side-by-side or travel trailer carries an automotive-style bill of materials (engines, controllers, harnesses, castings, molded panels) at a fraction of automotive volume, and it is re-quoted on a model-year clock. BRP produces 163 key snowmobile models, according to its 2026 annual information form, and sells sleds to dealers mostly between September and January while personal watercraft and pontoons go out between January and June. Every new model year means hundreds of parts to re-quote by a fixed date, many of them shared across trims.
Volumes and dealer stock move hard between those dates, and not together. Worldwide new snowmobile sales fell 18.0 percent in 2025, from 112,650 units to 92,387, and recovered only 1.5 percent in 2026, to 93,789, according to International Snowmobile Manufacturers Association figures reported by Powersports Business. U.S. and Canadian wholesale RV shipments rose 2.5 percent in 2025, from 333,733 units to 342,220, per RVIA data quoted in THOR Industries' filings, yet independent dealer inventory of THOR's North American towables was 16.0 percent lower on July 31, 2026 than a year earlier. BRP's North American network inventory was down 17 percent at the end of January 2026 and up 2 percent by the end of July. A tooling decision made on last season's forecast can be wrong by the time the parts ship.

Sales and dealer stock moved in different directions across powersports and RV in 2025-26. Solid bars are unit sales or shipments, outlined bars are dealer or network inventory. Sources: Powersports Business citing ISMA (Jul 8, 2026); THOR Form 10-Q (RVIA data, Mar 2026) and fiscal 2026 Q4 release (Sep 22, 2026); BRP FY26 results (Mar 26, 2026); Powersports Business on BRP Q2 (Sep 8, 2026). Periods differ by bar, so compare direction rather than size.
Costs moved as well. Harley-Davidson incurred about $67 million in new or increased tariffs in 2025. Polaris told investors in April 2026 it expected about $215 million in total tariff costs for the year, and BRP expects a net tariff impact of C$200 million for its current fiscal year. The software question for this industry is whether a buyer can change a part, a volume or a duty assumption and still trace the result to a comparable quote and an award.
How We Scored
We scored every platform, including our own, on eight criteria weighted toward where model-year sourcing time goes.
Criterion | Weight |
|---|---|
Model-year BOM and revisions | 20% |
Cost breakdowns and tooling | 20% |
Landed cost and tariffs | 15% |
Award scenarios and splits | 15% |
Supplier participation | 10% |
Quality handoff | 10% |
ERP and PLM fit | 5% |
Time to value | 5% |
The weights follow the capability sets The Hackett Group uses to define the category: its Sourcing (for direct) Solutions guide treats BoM management, cost analysis, NPI collaboration and predictive cost analytics as what separates direct sourcing tools from general ones, and it counts post-award material qualification as in scope, which is why quality handoff carries real weight here. We rate each capability Native (documented and in the standard product), Configured (available, but set up per customer or through an integration project), Marketed (claimed without public evidence of how it works) or Not documented (we could not find it, which is not the same as not offered).
One override applies to any weighting. If your quality team requires a part-level approval before award, that requirement outranks the weights, and a platform that cannot show it cannot win on price. LightSource does not document that capability, which is why JAGGAER, whose Polaris deployment documents supplier qualification, can be the right answer for a buyer who treats it as mandatory.
The 8 Platforms at a Glance
Platform | Best fit |
|---|---|
1. LightSource | Model-year re-quotes, breakdowns |
2. JAGGAER | Sourcing plus supplier qualification |
3. Ivalua | Multi-brand groups, configured S2C |
4. SAP Ariba | S/4HANA manufacturers |
5. GEP | Software plus managed services |
6. Coupa | P2P-first, price-to-PO accuracy |
7. Oracle | Oracle Fusion ERP shops |
8. Tacto | DACH industrial mid-market |

Our ratings of eight platforms on this guide's criteria, as of October 8, 2026. LightSource rates Native on model-year BOMs, cost breakdowns, award scenarios, supplier participation and time to value, Configured on landed cost and ERP and PLM fit, and Not documented on quality handoff. JAGGAER is the one platform rated Native on quality handoff, and GEP's multilevel BOM capability is rated Marketed. Source: LightSource assessment of public documentation, supplier manuals and The Hackett Group's Sourcing (for direct) Solutions guide. Not documented is not the same as not offered.
Read the grid against the weights. JAGGAER is the one platform rated Native on quality handoff, and SAP Ariba and Oracle rate Native on ERP fit where LightSource is Configured; those two criteria carry 15 percent of the score together. LightSource earns its lead on the 70 percent that sits in model-year BOMs, cost breakdowns, landed cost and award scenarios, where it rates Native on three of the four and Configured on landed cost. We did not find quality handoff documented for the other suites in public sources, so those cells read Not documented, which is not the same as Not offered.
The 8 Platforms, Ranked
1. LightSource
What it is. LightSource is the AI-native direct materials operating system, spec through scale, PLM through ERP. It serves dozens of companies across the mid-market and the Fortune 500, including powersports and recreational vehicle makers; not every customer can be named. Items are master data with specs, custom properties, revisions, drawings and files; BOMs are hierarchical, with snapshots and cost history across them, and a buyer can launch a sourcing project from a BOM or a batch of items. For a model-year changeover, that means one project per program, built from the carried-over and new parts, with a status for each supplier on the RFQ, a bid comparison whose empty cells show which supplier-item lines are still unquoted, and email reminders about due dates that also reach suppliers who have not quoted. Item and BOM revisions can be compared side by side; when engineering changes a part after launch, the buyer reviews a View changes comparison against the last-sent version, resends the RFQ, and every version is preserved. Suppliers receive the revised RFQ message and items, not a marked-up diff.
Best for: powersports, RV and marine OEMs whose purchasing starts from engineered parts, who want automotive-grade cost breakdowns on stampings, castings and molded parts without an automotive-sized implementation. BRP is a LightSource customer; we do not attribute a particular BRP plant, workflow or result to that relationship.
Why it ranks first. The Full Breakdown quote template asks every supplier for the same structure: separate tables for raw materials, purchased items, machine and assembly processes, packaging, logistics and markups. Bid comparison adds Item, Tool and ED&T views, so a mold or die charge stays separate from piece price, plus a cost walk across resubmissions and a field-by-field quote comparison between any two quotes. A quote field can use a formula that calculates from other fields and from item properties, such as price per kilogram times part weight, which is how an aluminum or resin share can be computed in the quote from an index value that is entered. Cost modifiers for freight, duty and packaging, each a fixed amount or a percentage of unit price, are added in the bid comparison to produce a modified cost the docs call landed cost. AI property suggestions can propose an HTS code for an item when an admin turns them on, and currency conversion handles quotes submitted in other currencies. Award scenarios can be built by hand or generated from submitted quotes and split by volume or percentage, an optimizer can apply rules such as supplier caps, minimum volumes and dual sourcing, and an admin can require ordered approval before an award goes out. Suppliers use LightSource free, and Supplier Discovery searches a network of more than 100,000 suppliers. At Blue Bird, a school bus maker and the closest published case study to a vehicle OEM, buyers ran 38 percent more RFQs per person and average sourcing cycle time fell from 16 to 14 days, per the published case study.
Watch-outs. LightSource does not track PPAP status or run a supplier qualification workflow after award (RFIs, scorecards and Data Rooms hold the evidence), does not issue purchase orders or invoices (an award creates an item contract), and has no live commodity index feed: index values are entered and resets run as a new round. Start and end of production are not named program fields; a dated project milestone can mark the SOP deadline. USMCA regional value content is not computed. CAD files can be attached to an item but are not parsed; drawings are handled as PDFs or images. Integration runs through Excel Item Sync and a GraphQL API rather than certified connectors, so a JD Edwards or SAP shop connects by flat file or API. The company came out of stealth in 2025. The Hackett Group lists LightSource in its Sourcing (for direct) Solutions guide, describing it as an "AI-native sourcing platform purpose-built for direct materials procurement," and on its 50 to Watch list for 2025-2026; Hackett's recognition page says its in-depth analysis of LightSource is still to come.
Demo test: load last year's BOM for one trim, revise one engine-controller drawing after quotes arrive, and ask to see which supplier-item lines are still unquoted and how the changed line affects the award scenario.
Pricing model: platform fee plus seats, implementation included; suppliers pay nothing. Deployment typically takes about 30 days, with bespoke integration scoped separately. See LightSource vs. JAGGAER.
2. JAGGAER
What it is. An all-spend source-to-pay suite with real direct materials heritage. The Hackett Group's direct sourcing guide credits it with "sophisticated direct materials sourcing capabilities," and Hackett's sourcing optimization guide dates its optimization engine to the 2013 CombineNet acquisition. In September 2026 it acquired Ivoflow, adding direct materials price intelligence.
Best for: large OEMs that want supplier qualification, onboarding, sourcing events and contracts in one system. This is the strongest documented fit in the sector: Polaris's supplier manual, revised May 2026, says Polaris uses JAGGAER to manage supplier qualification, onboarding and contract and sourcing event management, requires bids through the JAGGAER Sourcing Module, and records that JAGGAER replaced Zycus in 2025. If quality qualification has to live beside sourcing and you have the administrators to run it, JAGGAER is the better pick than LightSource.
Watch-outs. The same Hackett entry notes the suite was "built over time through multiple acquisitions," so test how item, supplier and contract data move between modules. A recurring complaint among reviewers is rigidity: limited conditional logic in forms and settings that need re-checking after releases. Polaris's manual also shows the cost on the supplier side: contacts must be maintained in JAGGAER and, separately, in the Polaris Supplier Portal.
Demo test: give a brake-hose supplier two plants with approval for only one, let the cheaper plant bid, and ask quality to show where the restriction is recorded and how the buyer sees it before award. Then have a plant buyer add a tooling-location field to a cost breakdown and confirm it survives the next release.
Pricing model: custom-quoted subscription by module and user band, plus implementation. See LightSource vs. JAGGAER.
3. Ivalua
What it is. An organically built source-to-pay suite on a single codebase, with every RFx type, auctions and optimization.
Best for: multi-brand vehicle groups that want common sourcing and contract governance across divisions. REV Group, whose segments included Recreation alongside Fire and Emergency and Commercial, announced in July 2021 that it had implemented Ivalua for a faster source-to-contract cycle; the announcement does not isolate RV-division results.
Watch-outs. Buyers report that getting value from Ivalua takes data-model expertise and configuration time, and partner choice matters more than usual. Some manufacturers describe the direct module and its integrations as still maturing. In our evaluations, BOM sync is configured per customer rather than extracted from drawings and spreadsheets.
Demo test: ask for a model-year event with 300 carried-over parts and 40 new ones, add a packaging field during the demo, and record which steps need the implementation partner.
Pricing model: custom-quoted subscription sized by modules and users, implementation separate. See LightSource vs. Ivalua.
4. SAP Ariba
What it is. SAP's procurement suite, natively integrated with S/4HANA and the SAP Business Network.
Best for: makers already standardized on SAP. Zero Motorcycles runs SAP Ariba alongside S/4HANA, SAP PLM and integrated business planning, according to an SAP and MHP customer case study, which does not say Zero ran competitive BOM awards through it. If one vendor for every spend type on S/4HANA is the requirement, Ariba is the natural choice and a specialist is an add-on for engineered categories.
Watch-outs. Hackett's direct sourcing guide describes Ariba's sourcing as covering "all the expected functional blocks" and names no direct-specific capability; Hackett is also a paid SAP Ariba partner, which readers should weigh. A recurring minority complaint among reviewers is a dated interface that needs training for occasional users, and engineers who co-source with suppliers are occasional users. In our evaluations, events reference ERP material master rows rather than drawings and revisions, and cost breakdowns follow fixed templates and Excel round trips.
Demo test: put one harness into two plants that switch model years three weeks apart, then ask each plant buyer to retrieve the applicable drawing and awarded price on a date between the switches.
Pricing model: module subscriptions, price on request, plus integrator implementation; some supplier accounts pay network fees above SAP's thresholds. See LightSource vs. SAP Ariba.
5. GEP
What it is. An organically built suite, GEP SMART on the QUANTUM platform, sold with consulting and managed services.
Best for: OEMs that want people to run categories as well as software. Hackett credits GEP with "cost and should-cost modeling, opportunity identification and sourcing execution," and GEP is the suite to shortlist ahead of LightSource if a built-in should-cost model is mandatory.
Watch-outs. GEP's newest capabilities live on QUANTUM, so existing SMART customers face a migration, and buyers report custom work for ERP integration. Its multilevel BOM views are marketed without public detail on revisions or snapshots, so we rate that capability Marketed. Sector deployments in powersports or RV are not documented publicly.
Demo test: model an aluminum engine case from gross metal input, finished weight and scrap credit, change the metal price, and have your buyer explain the revised estimate without a services analyst at the keyboard.
Pricing model: custom-quoted enterprise subscription, often bundled with services. See LightSource vs. GEP.
6. Coupa
What it is. The broadest procure-to-pay and indirect suite here, with sourcing optimization that Hackett's optimization guide dates to the 2017 Trade Extensions acquisition (see the Hackett disclosure below).
Best for: makers whose expensive failure is the awarded price not reaching the purchase order. Coupa does run direct materials outside this sector: Kimberly-Clark told its mainland China and Hong Kong region suppliers in August 2026 that direct-material POs, line-level acknowledgments and sourcing responses now run through the Coupa Supplier Portal.
Watch-outs. P2P and indirect are Coupa's center of gravity, and some manufacturing buyers report gaps bringing direct spend onto the platform. BOM and revision management is not documented in its sourcing product, and a BOM-driven RFQ with a custom cost breakdown has to fit its standard event model. In-sector production sourcing is not documented.
Demo test: correct one awarded price and follow it through the PO and invoice.
Pricing model: custom quote by module and user count, integrator-led rollout; suppliers use the portal free. See LightSource vs. Coupa.
7. Oracle Fusion Cloud Procurement
What it is. Procurement on the same data model as Oracle Fusion ERP, with sourcing, purchasing and supplier portal modules in one suite.
Best for: manufacturers already on Oracle Fusion who want sourcing in the same data model as purchasing and payables.
Watch-outs. Sourcing events are generic all-spend events rather than drawing- and revision-centric RFQs, and design-to-source sits in Oracle's separately licensed PLM. HTS and trade compliance also sit in a separate Oracle logistics product. Sector deployments for direct parts are not documented.
Demo test: list every screen shown, the product that owns it and the license it requires.
Pricing model: per-hosted-named-user list pricing with a user minimum. See LightSource vs. Oracle.
8. Tacto
What it is. An AI procurement platform for industrial mid-market manufacturers in Germany, Austria and Switzerland, focused on supplier, cost and demand intelligence.
Best for: mid-sized DACH industrial buyers. HYMER-Leichtmetallbau, a German ladder and access-equipment maker (not the motorhome group), uses Tacto with demand forecasts in purchasing.
Watch-outs. Public evidence of part-line RFQ depth, drawing handling and finished-vehicle OEM use is thin, and its footprint is regional.
Demo test: run one model-year RFQ end to end with suppliers outside DACH.
Pricing model: not published; demo-led subscription. See LightSource vs. Tacto.
Tariffs Hit the Bill of Materials
Tariffs became a nine-figure line on powersports income statements in 2025 and 2026. Polaris expected about $215 million in tariff costs for 2026, excluding refunds on roughly $125 million of IEEPA tariffs it paid and is seeking back, and its second-quarter results included $74 million of tariff refunds. BRP now expects a C$200 million (about US$145 million) net tariff impact for the fiscal year ending January 2027, less than it first feared after April's changes to the Section 232 metals tariffs. Harley-Davidson put its 2025 cost of new or increased tariffs at about $67 million.
Supplier risk is the other line item. BRP's second quarter absorbed a C$74.8 million, 330-basis-point hit to gross profit from a supplier's financial restructuring. Harley-Davidson suspended assembly for about two weeks in 2022 over a brake-hose compliance issue at a tier 2 supplier, and the same supplier constrained most York production for about two weeks in 2023. RV makers face the problem one step removed: THOR says it challenges tariff pass-through charges from vendors that it believes are not properly supported.
For a sourcing tool, this means the quote has to separate what the supplier controls (material, conversion, margin) from what policy controls (duty basis, origin, effective date), so that a pass-through charge can be checked against the breakdown. We wrote about why duty math belongs in the BOM, about the US-Canada tariff escalation that hit Quebec and Ontario manufacturers, and about LightSource's AI tariff tracker for HTS classification. Our colleague Renette Youssef covered why the IEEPA ruling doesn't end tariffs.
What It Costs
Almost no vendor in this category publishes a price list, so compare the pricing model and what sits outside it.
Size | Watch |
|---|---|
Under $500M revenue | Setup fees, term length |
$500M to $3B | Integrator, supplier fees |
Over $3B | Module bundles, migrations |
The suites generally price by module and user band, and implementation is a separate integrator contract measured in months per module. LightSource charges a platform fee plus seats, with implementation included, and suppliers pay nothing. Three powersports-specific costs are easy to miss. Seasonal engineers who co-source with suppliers during design need seats or access, so ask how occasional users are priced. Small machine shops and molders in your supplier base will notice any supplier-side fee or second portal: Polaris already asks suppliers to keep contacts current in two systems. And bulky RV and marine parts can be quoted with disposable packaging or with returnable racks, so ask each bid to price the empty return trip and the racks tied up during peak production before ranking.
A Model-Year Pilot Checklist
Run one real model-year changeover through two platforms. The test is built so no vendor, LightSource included, can pass it with a slide.
Pick one vehicle program with carried-over and new parts across at least two trims, including one engine controller or harness shared across models. Our colleague Mason Morgan's guide to preparing BOM data for direct materials sourcing is a useful starting point.
Load last year's BOM as you have it (PLM export, Excel, PDF drawings) and time how long until items carry specs, drawings and volumes.
Launch the re-quote for 200 or more parts with a due date set to your SOP gate, and on day five check which supplier-item lines are still unquoted.
Use a Full Breakdown on one casting and one molded panel, with tooling itemized per component, the way Polaris's supplier manual requires.
Quote one part three ways: a Mexican casting, a Canadian casting and a U.S. quote with a tariff surcharge. Apply duty as a separate modifier rather than inside the quoted price, check the ranking does not count it twice, then record the assumptions behind each total landed cost.
Index the metal share of one quote to a named series (the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics recommends specifying the index, base period and adjustment frequency) and rerun it for one reset. The glossary entry on index-based pricing covers the mechanics.
Cut volume 30 percent and rebuild the award scenarios (see the example below).
Change the option mix, not the vehicle count. Suppose a side-by-side program builds 6,000 vehicles, 40 percent get a premium display, and the supplier's price break starts at 1,000 units of that revision. If dealers shift orders so only 15 percent take the display, production demand drops from 2,400 to 900 and the break no longer applies. Ask each vendor to reproduce the original award, show who must obtain a new price and keep service demand for the older revision as its own line.
Revise one drawing after bids arrive, resend the revised RFQ and confirm round one and its quotes are preserved.
Test one second source. Give two qualified molders access to the same physical tool, or two controller suppliers the same programmed chip, award 70 and 30, and ask the buyer which interruption the split would actually cover.
Export the award to an ERP test environment and record who fixes a rejected row.
The volume cut matters because tooling and piece price trade off. Polaris tells suppliers to weigh the overall cost over the projected three-year volume. Suppose Supplier A quotes $6.20 a unit plus a $90,000 mold and Supplier B quotes $7.10 with a $30,000 mold.
3-yr volume | A | B |
|---|---|---|
90,000 | $648,000 | $669,000 |
63,000 | $480,600 | $477,300 |
At 90,000 units Supplier A is $21,000 cheaper; after a 30 percent cut to 63,000, Supplier B is $3,300 cheaper. The break-even is about 66,700 units. A comparison that folds tooling amortization into piece price, or ignores the forecast, picks the wrong supplier on one side of that line. We have also written about the related habit of automotive cost-down targets.
How We Ranked
LightSource wrote this guide, and LightSource is on the list. To keep it useful we scored every platform, including our own, on the same eight criteria a powersports or RV sourcing team uses: model-year BOM and revisions, cost breakdowns and tooling, landed cost and tariffs, award scenarios and splits, supplier participation, quality handoff, ERP and PLM fit and time to value. Capability notes come from public documentation, supplier manuals, public reviews, public analyst pages and our own evaluations as of October 8, 2026; where we could not find a capability documented we say "not documented", which is not the same as "not offered". The suites on this list do things LightSource does not: purchase orders, invoicing, indirect spend, auctions, contract management and supplier qualification. If you need those, weigh them. These are editorial rankings, not results from eight identical live implementations, and the demo tests are there for buyers to run.
LightSource ranks first because it rates Native on the two most heavily weighted criteria and on award scenarios and supplier participation; it does not document quality handoff, and that gap is stated above. JAGGAER ranks second on the strongest public evidence of use at a powersports OEM, and it would rank first for a buyer who weights supplier qualification above model-year re-quote speed. Ivalua and SAP Ariba follow on documented sector deployments, GEP on direct depth without a sector reference, Coupa and Oracle as P2P-first suites, and Tacto on thin public evidence. For the full 12-platform view across industries, see our best direct materials procurement software guide.
Analyst mentions are facts, not endorsements, and the ranking in this guide is ours alone. Hackett is a paid partner of Coupa, SAP Ariba, Oracle and Zip, which readers should weigh when we cite it on those vendors.
Published October 8, 2026. Last reviewed October 8, 2026.
Sources
Sourcing (for direct) Solutions -- The Hackett Group Solution Intelligence (formerly Spend Matters), Sept. 22, 2026: direct sourcing capability sets and vendor entries including LightSource, JAGGAER and SAP Ariba
Sourcing (with optimization) Solutions -- The Hackett Group Solution Intelligence, Sept. 22, 2026: CombineNet and Trade Extensions acquisition dates
Procurement Technology 2025-2026 Recognition Lists -- The Hackett Group: 50 to Watch listing for LightSource
Supplier Business Practice Manual, rev. 18 -- Polaris, May 8, 2026: JAGGAER for qualification and sourcing events, tooling quotation rules
BRP annual information form -- BRP via SEC, Mar. 2026: 163 key snowmobile models, dealer selling seasons
BRP FY26 results -- BRP via SEC, Mar. 26, 2026: network inventory down 17%
BRP Q2 FY2027 MD&A -- BRP via SEC, Sept. 2026: C$74.8 million supplier restructuring impact
Sea-Doo and Ski-Doo maker weathers tariffs -- Bloomberg Law, Sept. 3, 2026: C$200 million net tariff impact
BRP Q2: ORV demand drives growth -- Powersports Business, Sept. 8, 2026: dealer inventory up 2%
Snowmobile sales stabilize in North America -- Powersports Business, July 8, 2026: ISMA worldwide sales
Polaris Q1 2026 earnings call transcript -- Polaris, Apr. 28, 2026: about $215 million expected tariff cost
Polaris Q2 2026 earnings release -- Polaris via SEC, July 28, 2026: $74 million tariff refunds
Harley-Davidson 2025 Form 10-K -- SEC, Feb. 2026: $67 million tariff cost, tier 2 brake-hose stoppages
THOR Industries Form 10-Q -- SEC, Mar. 2026: RVIA wholesale shipments
THOR fiscal 2026 fourth-quarter release -- SEC, Sept. 22, 2026: dealer towable inventory down 16.0%
THOR fiscal 2026 Form 10-K -- SEC, Sept. 2026: challenging unsupported tariff pass-through charges
REV Group partners with Consus Global -- STN, July 21, 2021: Ivalua implementation
Zero Motorcycles SAP and MHP case study -- SAP and MHP: SAP Ariba in Zero's SAP landscape (used only to confirm the deployment)
Kimberly-Clark Coupa expansion notice -- Kimberly-Clark, Aug. 31, 2026: Coupa for direct-material POs in its mainland China and Hong Kong region
JAGGAER acquires Ivoflow -- Procurement & Supply Chain Outlook, Sept. 14, 2026
HYMER-Leichtmetallbau BME event -- HYMER-Leichtmetallbau, 2024: Tacto in purchasing
Price adjustment guide for contracting parties -- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics
Blue Bird customer story -- LightSource
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best sourcing software for a powersports or RV manufacturer?
For production-part sourcing on a model-year cycle, LightSource ranks first in this guide on BOM-driven re-quotes, structured cost breakdowns, landed cost and award scenarios. JAGGAER is the better choice when supplier qualification and contracts must live in the same system, as at Polaris, and SAP Ariba fits makers standardized on S/4HANA.
Which RFQ software handles stampings, castings and plastics with supplier cost breakdowns?
Look for a quote template every supplier fills the same way, with material, machine process, cycle time, tooling and logistics as separate lines. LightSource's Full Breakdown template and Tool view do this natively; suites usually handle it through configured events or Excel attachments.
Which sourcing tools can re-quote hundreds of parts for a new model year and show which are still unquoted before SOP?
LightSource builds a project from a batch of items or a BOM, tracks each supplier's RFQ status and sends due-date reminders, and the bid comparison shows empty cells where a supplier has not yet quoted a part. SOP is not a named field; a project milestone can mark the deadline. JAGGAER and Ivalua can run large configured events for the same job.
Can sourcing software track the annual index adjustment on aluminum and steel castings?
LightSource can compute an index-linked material share in a quote formula from an index value that is entered, and rerun the adjustment as a new round, and the cost walk across resubmissions shows how each quote moved between rounds. It has no live index feed. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics advises naming the index, base period and adjustment frequency in the contract.
How do I compare landed cost across Mexican, Canadian and U.S. suppliers with tariffs?
Keep duty, freight and currency as separate modifiers on top of a supplier's price rather than inside it, so the ranking can be rerun when a tariff changes. LightSource adds freight, duty and packaging modifiers in the bid comparison, as a fixed amount or a percentage of unit price, and can suggest HTS codes when AI property suggestions are on; it does not compute USMCA regional value content.
Does LightSource handle PPAP and ISO 9001 tracking for marine or powersports suppliers?
Not as a quality workflow. LightSource collects certificates through RFIs and Data Rooms, and the Data Room's AI document analysis lists certificate start and expiration dates with expired ones in red, but it does not track PPAP status or run supplier qualification after award. JAGGAER documents supplier qualification and quality management, and many OEMs run a separate quality system.
What sourcing platform works for an RV maker on JD Edwards where engineers pick suppliers during design?
LightSource connects to JD Edwards by flat file or API rather than a certified connector, gives engineers and buyers shared item records with internal and per-supplier message channels, and shows modified cost by supplier with freight and duty modifiers. Ask any vendor how occasional engineering users are priced and trained.
Is there sourcing software for a PG&A accessories catalog with thousands of SKUs?
Yes. A parts, garments and accessories catalog can run as its own item set with its own projects and templates; LightSource's Excel Item Sync loads thousands of SKUs and suppliers can answer by Excel round-trip. Tail-spend tools suit accessories that need no drawings or breakdowns.
How much does sourcing software cost for a mid-size powersports OEM?
Few vendors publish prices. Suites are custom-quoted by module and user band with a separate integrator contract; LightSource charges a platform fee plus seats with implementation included, and suppliers pay nothing. Budget for integration, seats for occasional engineering users and any supplier-side fees.
Faster sourcing,
lower cost, less chaos.
See how LightSource connects engineering, procurement, and suppliers in one operating system to help you launch faster at lower cost.
DPW Award Winner
SOC 2
Hackett Group 2026 Validated
Kearney #1
Gartner Cool Vendor
Procuretech 100
G2 Top Rated
Faster sourcing,
lower cost, less chaos.
See how LightSource connects engineering, procurement, and suppliers in one operating system to help you launch faster at lower cost.
DPW Award Winner
SOC 2
Hackett Group 2026 Validated
Kearney #1
Gartner Cool Vendor
Procuretech 100
G2 Top Rated
Faster sourcing,
lower cost, less chaos.
See how LightSource connects engineering, procurement, and suppliers in one operating system to help you launch faster at lower cost.
DPW Award Winner
SOC 2
Hackett Group 2026 Validated
Kearney #1
Gartner Cool Vendor
Procuretech 100
G2 Top Rated
Trusted by:
Trusted by:
Trusted by:




